Super Monkey Ball NGC

There went my next round pick

a great game that I completely forgot about. Nice pick.

I have had more fun with this game, than I can count. What a blast of a game this is!

Round 5 pick. I think this is the right system.

Paper Mario - GameCube

Yep, this was released on GC and I am currently playing it now.

Round 5 - The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past w/ the Four Swords - GBA

Compilation games are ineligible. Compilation games are defined as games in which there is no default game to play as opposed to games where additional games are available as special features.
The default game is A link to the past and four swords is a special feature.

though if you still think this game in Ineligible then ill pick The legend of Zelda : Wind Waker -Game Cube

Paper Mario 2 is on the GC Paper Mario 1 is on N64

well paper mario origionally came out for the Nintendo 64 and there is Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door

I rule it eligible.

Grand Theft Auto - Vice City (PS2)

Round 5:

Saturn Bomberman

Sega Saturn

I was thinking the original.

So. Updated Round 5 pick.

Paper Mario - N64

Round 5 pick:
Katamari Damacy (PS2)

Round Five:
Adventure - Atari 2600

Burnout 3 XBOX for the fifth round

Advance Wars 2 - GBA

I am surprised at the Nintendo dominance in this draft.

My thinking was there are fewer great Nintendo titles so get the giants early, whereas there was much more depth in Sony and XBox.

It will be interesting to see how each system and publisher is represented when all of the choices are made.

I'm guessing it's nostalgia. I don't know the ages of everyone playing, but I grew up on NES and SNES and am guessing a lot of others did as well.

I will have to disagree with you here. There are so many good games released by Nintendo that I dont even think that we scratched the surface. I truly do not believe that there is that much more depth with Sony, but maybe a little. Xbox is not as deep as the NES console alone, let alone SNES, N64, and NGC combined. I wont include handheld here, but if I did, it easily would be deeper than Sony and Xbox.

What is funny to me is that I consider myself a Nintendo guy, and through 5 rounds, I have yet to pick a Nintendo game.

I'm a Sony guy and I didn't pick a Sony title until round 4.

I'm all about the XBox, but strangely, through 5 rounds, I haven't picked a single XBox game or even any new gen console so far.

I'm having a hard time, since I skipped the SNES/Dreamcast era....I was away from gaming for a while. I started back into it with the PS2. I'll manage though