I have friends over all the time, and we need a new game to play, something like baldur's gate. The game needs to be 3 players, and most of the ones i have found are only 2. We have play D&D:Heroes, but found that to be a little too short. any suggestions?

X-Men Legends is a good one...

Yep, I'd definitely second that one... I played through single player, but definitely felt multiplayer would have been the way to go when playing it.

Not sure what console you are talking about but Brute Force could be a decent one as well... I played it through single player quite some time back, and its fairly cheap now. But X-Men legends would be the first choice.