DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   CD-r played on XBOX?? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/273101-cd-r-played-xbox.html)

raven56706 02-21-03 07:35 AM

CD-r played on XBOX??
 
I was trying to play one of my cd-r on my xbox and it doesnt play. Does anyone know why? Has anyone had the luck?

Groucho 02-21-03 07:45 AM

Xbox has a lot of the trouble recognizing CD-R. However, it does seem to handle CD-RW a lot better.

duz 02-21-03 07:58 AM

to prevent piracy of music

Nefarious 02-21-03 08:55 AM


Originally posted by duz
to prevent piracy of music
They'd have been better off not including a hard-drive if that was their goal :)

s}{ammer 02-21-03 09:43 AM


Originally posted by Groucho
Xbox has a lot of the trouble recognizing CD-R. However, it does seem to handle CD-RW a lot better.
there is a list of CD-Rs that work but I have never been able to get any of them to work. I have also never had a CD-RW fail to be read. Just pick up one or two CD-RWs.

Centurion 02-21-03 10:19 AM

Yup, CD-RW is what I used. Just transfer your tracks.

olie029 02-21-03 10:58 AM

Cool so it can read CD-RW with music? I havent tried that yet.

Crizzar 02-21-03 11:33 AM

yes

Young Vito 02-21-03 11:42 AM

some of the newer xboxes with the phillips model cd drive have been reported to play cdrs, the older ones which usually have the thompson drives dont play cdrs at all.

mrpayroll 02-21-03 12:29 PM

What about DVD+R, DVD-R, DVD+RW & DVD-RW?

Thanx

Joshic 02-21-03 12:55 PM


What about DVD+R, DVD-R, DVD+RW & DVD-RW
no, no, no & no.

mrpayroll 02-21-03 01:05 PM


Originally posted by Joshic
no, no, no & no.
What? Why not. It is a DVD player! Thanx

Chris

edstein 02-21-03 02:22 PM

Can the xbox recognize a CD-RW audio disc with CD-Text or do I still have to input the track names?

AgtFox 02-21-03 02:41 PM


Originally posted by mrpayroll
What? Why not. It is a DVD player! Thanx
Actually, it is somewhat of a proprietary DVD player. You would have to do some modifications to be able to read DVD recorded discs. This would push it into the totally illegal realm, but it also allows you to play imports.

AgtFox 02-21-03 02:42 PM


Originally posted by edstein
Can the xbox recognize a CD-RW audio disc with CD-Text or do I still have to input the track names?
Good question...I'm not sure. Chances are it wouldn't is my initial answer.

Sloth911 02-21-03 02:52 PM

You can find a list of cd-r that are playable on some x-box hacker sites. However, as noted several times, it should read your cd-rw.


You would have to do some modifications to be able to read DVD recorded discs. This would push it into the totally illegal realm
That is a false statement. It is not illegal to mod your xBox.

Is it illegal to own an axe because there are axe murderers?

AgtFox 02-21-03 04:45 PM


Originally posted by jasonr114
That is a false statement. It is not illegal to mod your xBox.
Thank you for reading further into that. I said it can allow you to play imported games. I was just saying that modding ALLOWS the chance to get into more illegal-type dealings, that's all.

Darknight 02-21-03 05:48 PM

Actually it is illegal to mod your Xbox. Under the DMCA, it is unlawful to use any device that has its main purpose to circumvent a copy protection scheme. A mod chip does just that. Not to mention the fact that the bios you use on a chip uses modified copyrighted code from Microsoft.

With regards to what media the Xbox reads, it's Samsung drives, not Philips which can read CD-Rs. The irony is that the Samsung drives are in newer systems so newer systems actually can read more media than older ones.

Centurion 02-21-03 08:02 PM


Originally posted by Darknight
Actually it is illegal to mod your Xbox. Under the DMCA, it is unlawful to use any device that has its main purpose to circumvent a copy protection scheme. A mod chip does just that. Not to mention the fact that the bios you use on a chip uses modified copyrighted code from Microsoft.
Let's say this is true. The problem with this statement is this part:
...its main purpose to circumvent a copy protection scheme.

One would have to prove the user was using a mod chip primarily to play copied games. As it goes, a mod chip is able to do more than just that which allows these chips to bypass most (if not all) of the legal issues surrounding them.

Shawn 02-21-03 09:02 PM

I have a quick question....Does the Xbox (with the DVD playback kit) play VCD's? If this is a stupid question, sorry, but I'd like to know the answer. Thanks in advance.

cubanx 02-21-03 09:53 PM

http://www.funxbox.com/cdlist.php

I have not verified this list but Enjoy!

Naan 02-21-03 11:28 PM


Originally posted by Joshic
no, no, no & no.
I've had no problems with DVD-R, but had problems with -RW. Haven't tried any +R or +RW media.

-Naan

Darknight 02-21-03 11:29 PM

Centurion: The problem is, copy protection doesn't mean playing copied games. In order to get any software to run, you have to bypass the security check which is the copy protection scheme. So yes, under DMCA, it is illegal. Mod chips can't do jack without bypassing the security check. And again, the bios is modified MS code. Using that is illegal in itself.

edytwinky 02-22-03 01:51 AM

CD-RW, as you've probably read earlier is your answer.

duz 02-22-03 02:20 AM

nevermind the fact it says on the side of the box to not mod the seXbox


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:18 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.