I'm having some irritating problems with my controller S. In JSRF, I have to push down into the "analog" section of the buttons in order for it to register...same with Oddworld. Does this happen to everyone else, whether using the S or the original? If so, why would the programmers do something so stupid?

It's not just you. Same thing happens to me. It drives me nuts too.

Is this only with one type of controller and not the other?