Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by fujishig
(Post 13862760)
I feel like you have to take most cartoons out of the equation. The fact that the Simpsons don't age is like the least of the believability problems with them. If that's what ruins the show for you, I'm not sure what show you're watching... :)
|
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by Count Dooku
(Post 13862809)
You guys need to develop a radar for irony.
On a related note, I do feel like a bunch of shows basically "Homer Simpson" a character and make them so dumb that it takes me out of the show (maybe this didn't originate with Homer, and I just associate it with him... maybe Woody on Cheers? But Homer definitely started off kinda slow and then it just got worse and worse). edited to add: actually I never understood why the trope is named after Ned Flanders instead of Homer. I realize Ned got dumber too but I always thought Homer did it first. |
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Yeah, Flanderization bothers me more on something like the Simpsons than the sliding timescale ever does.
Homer was a dope but lovable in the early years, but as it went on he started approaching special needs kind of dumb. |
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by fujishig
(Post 13862649)
I'm not sure if this is more a sign of the times but it's hard to watch Married with Children, where the Bundys are basically a single income family with two children off of a shoe salesmen's salary and always down on their luck but they are able to afford a two story house.
|
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by milo bloom
(Post 13862765)
People living in extremely nice places that they shouldn't be able to afford is one. Frasier in that kind of apartment doing a radio show? Even if they're using Martin's benefits and Niles chips in, that's a really nice place.
And radio hosts could make good money if they have a large audience. But I agree in general - many shows have characters living lives way above their means (ie. house/condo, clothing, other expenditures). A couple things I always found funny (but doesn't ruin the show for me - I just accept it) is that people in sitcoms always have their lights on in every room. The other thing is that they never seem to take their shoes off when they enter their home... just tracking dirt inside all the time. The kids will even run upstairs with their shoes on and lie down on their bed - no issues. |
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
And they always open wrapped presents by lifting the top off the box instead of having to rip off the paper! And their to-go coffee cups are always empty!
|
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by morriscroy
(Post 13862758)
Beavis and Butthead didn't appear to age either. (Except maybe the flashbacks in the movie).
They appeared to be the same age in the 2011 revival, as the original series in the mid-1990s. But with then-current topical references. The only thing Mike Judge got wrong about Idiocracy is the timeline; it will happen WAY sooner. |
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by milo bloom
(Post 13862832)
Yeah, Flanderization bothers me more on something like the Simpsons than the sliding timescale ever does.
Characters' quirks, neuroses, and personality traits get amplified to the point where they consume the character. Kelly Bundy and Joey Tribiani get dumber, Phoebe gets loopier, Ross gets creepier, Ted from HIMYM gets needier, Fonzie can fix anyting by snapping his fingers, etc. |
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by Coral
(Post 13862837)
Didn't Frasier make decent bank when he was a psychiatrist in Boston on Cheers?
And radio hosts could make good money if they have a large audience. But I agree in general - many shows have characters living lives way above their means (ie. house/condo, clothing, other expenditures). A couple things I always found funny (but doesn't ruin the show for me - I just accept it) is that people in sitcoms always have their lights on in every room. The other thing is that they never seem to take their shoes off when they enter their home... just tracking dirt inside all the time. The kids will even run upstairs with their shoes on and lie down on their bed - no issues. The above their means thing is, I guess, necessary mainly because most people don't want to watch sitcoms that parallel real life where people are struggling to pay rent in a tiny apartment (not to mention how boring it would be to shoot in such a place). Even a show like Roseanne that focused on relative lack of money, they had a pretty large house. |
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Lots of shows have it so people all gather around one side of a table but nobody ever did it more glaringly than Taxi. It’s because there is a table on the right side of the soundstage and it always looked so unnatural.
https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...16d0cfe54.jpeg https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/dvdtalk...140788d4a.jpeg |
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Yea, I always find it funny when characters squish together around a table even though there's this big gap where no one sits.
Originally Posted by fujishig
(Post 13862894)
We're Asian so we take off our shoes, but I thought that some people just wipe the dirt off and leave their shoes on in the house?
|
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by Coral
(Post 13862980)
I don't know anyone who leave their shoes on when entering a house on a frequent basis whether it's summer or winter. The only time is when you go it to get something real quick and go back outside. Wiping your shoes doesn't get rid of all the dirt - there's always something. And shows do that in the winter time, characters coming inside with their shoes after they've been out in the snow. Wiping your shoes/boots doesn't dry your shoes and it will leave a mess inside.
|
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Imagine a three-camera sitcom where the kids run onstage from the "outside" door, and then stop for 60 seconds to untie their shoes before they say their lines. Nope nope nope.
|
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by morriscroy
(Post 13862652)
Not any particular show.
Generally any show which portrays computer processing / hacking in a manner which is entirely wrong at a technical level. The camera panned over to her laptop screen. It was a Java case statement... |
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by Nick Danger
(Post 13863001)
Imagine a three-camera sitcom where the kids run onstage from the "outside" door, and then stop for 60 seconds to untie their shoes before they say their lines. Nope nope nope.
Now, spending a few minutes watching character find their shoes in a pile and sit down while putting them back on before they exit the scene is a different story. |
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
As far as shoes go, I know that when watching any anime that shows them taking off and putting on shoes, it never slows down the scene, it always feels organic to the rhythm of the scene.
|
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Every post in this thread is just nitpicking. If anything mentioned so far actually ruined the show for you (which is the thread question) I don't know how you manage to make it through anything.
|
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by The Questyen
(Post 13863508)
Every post in this thread is just nitpicking. If anything mentioned so far actually ruined the show for you (which is the thread question) I don't know how you manage to make it through anything.
|
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by The Questyen
(Post 13863508)
Every post in this thread is just nitpicking. If anything mentioned so far actually ruined the show for you (which is the thread question) I don't know how you manage to make it through anything.
As to your larger point . . . I can't manage to make it through anything. I've almost given up on TV shows. |
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by milo bloom
(Post 13862765)
Time sliding in animation doesn't bother me, but when live-action shows have someone give birth and the next season the kid is a toddler, that's a jump the shark moment.
I'm a little more forgiving here, since we don't really know how time travel works. If we really are living in a simulation, then we may remember quantum traces of other realities. People living in extremely nice places that they shouldn't be able to afford is one. Frasier in that kind of apartment doing a radio show? Even if they're using Martin's benefits and Niles chips in, that's a really nice place. |
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by Count Dooku
(Post 13862839)
And they always open wrapped presents by lifting the top off the box instead of having to rip off the paper! And their to-go coffee cups are always empty!
|
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by Decker
(Post 13862899)
Lots of shows have it so people all gather around one side of a table but nobody ever did it more glaringly than Taxi. It’s because there is a table on the right side of the soundstage and it always looked so unnatural.
For some reason when people are already seated sitcom style, or when the table is already set that way and they just sit down, it is not so striking, but watching someone set it up makes it jump out as weird. |
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by The Questyen
(Post 13863508)
Every post in this thread is just nitpicking. If anything mentioned so far actually ruined the show for you (which is the thread question) I don't know how you manage to make it through anything.
|
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by movieguru
(Post 13863541)
And whenever they go to their regular coffeehouse. bar or restaurant, no other customer is ever sitting at their regular table or seat. You would thing that the couch at Central Perk would be the most desirable section for customers to want to sit at, but no matter what time any of the six friends went there, that section was always available unless they wanted to make that the plot point of the scene.
|
Re: TV Shows With Such Glaring Holes They Ruin Everything Else
Originally Posted by Coral
(Post 13863635)
Not everything posted was something that ruined the show (ie. not taking shoes off) - it was just a funny quirk we've accepted.
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:21 AM. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.