In the spirit of Maryanne vs Ginger I chose Beverly Crusher. I prefer willowy redheads to, er, womanly brunettes.

Re-watching TNG on my favorite streaming service it is a lot is different than I remembered. Wesley is still annoying but I see him as an exposition device more than a character. I'm only in season 2 so I'm sure that opinion will change. I still hate Doctor Pulaski, making her antagonistic to Data sealed her fate.

Tasha for a crew member. But if anyone is eligible, then K'Ehleyr...

Both are good for different reasons. I think I’d give the slight edge to Deanna. She was more interesting and I would say was more sexy in comparison. Neither really had great character centric episodes, but I think I’d take a Troi episode over a Crusher episode.

I do like Beverly too though. I always liked her chemistry with Picard, and plus even though the character gets shit sometimes I liked the dynamic of her and Wesley as well.

can I just say how surprised I am this is not a zombie thread resurrected from 10 years ago?? Always had a thing for both, and if I had the option I would say both, but if I have to pick one its Troi but I do love redheads..

Both?

I loves me a big red bush, so the choice is obvious.

But I wouldn't turn down being the meat in a Crusher-Troi sandwich.

What year is this?

Troi was one of my first crushes. Rewatching a few years back, I crushed more on Crusher. Enough so that I was bummed when she wasn't there during season 2.

Troi by far.

I find Deanna more attractive, so if that's the poll, that's my pick.

If it's a bone poll, then I pick Crusher because Troi has done the nasty with Worf, and I would never be able to keep up with whatever freaky shit she is into. Beverly gives off a more "grateful for what she gets" MILF vibe.

If I can pick any crew member over the course of the series, then I'm going Ensign Robin Lefler (played by Ashley Judd).

So ... a real menages a Trois.

That would be a threesome with Lwaxana Troi and Deanna Troi.

I always wondered if Picard would have been willing to give Lwaxana the shag she so desperately wanted, if a go at Deanna had been thrown into the mix.

Once you've had two dicks, you can't go back to just one.

As long as we’re going there, Janeway is a murderer.

Poor Tuvix.

No love for Klingon boob windows?

That’s either a porno or a Pringle’s slogan.

Elizabeth Montgomery agrees.

Troi, and it's not even close. Marina Sirtis will be 65 this month and can still get it.

Let’s get this party started then ...

Crusher. Redhead. Plus a Brandeis alum so there's that.

Character-wise? Troi. Actress wise? Gates.

This whole subforum missed the “Me too” movement. If any women ever discover it it’s going to be shut down.