Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
#26
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
No one is calling for Robert Downey Jr to be cancelled because he wore blackface in a movie. You know why? Because he's not an outspoken liberal that the right is trying to destroy.
#27
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
Did Downey do blackface? I was under the impression blackface is an exaggerated caricature (burnt cork or shoe polish, exaggerated lips) intended to demean and dehumanize. Isn't that a far different thing than an actor using makeup to make themselves resemble a character of a different skin colour, especially when this change of skin colour is irrelevant to the joke (like Jimmy Kimmel imitating Karl Malone, or Rob Lowe imitating Arsenio Hall, or Zoe Saldana playing Nina Simone...)?
#28
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
Pointing to Robert Downey Jr’s role in Tropic Thunder doesn’t address Silverman’s history of using racist language and imagery for laughs.
#29
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
I don't need to address people's comedy from 15-20 years ago that's not what the discussion was about. The original discussion was what Chappelle and other older comics are saying right now.
#30
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
Did Downey do blackface? I was under the impression blackface is an exaggerated caricature (burnt cork or shoe polish, exaggerated lips) intended to demean and dehumanize. Isn't that a far different thing than an actor using makeup to make themselves resemble a character of a different skin colour, especially when this change of skin colour is irrelevant to the joke (like Jimmy Kimmel imitating Karl Malone, or Rob Lowe imitating Arsenio Hall, or Zoe Saldana playing Nina Simone...)?
I don’t think Tropic Thunder excuses Silverman’s past behavior but I do think it’s interesting that RDJ and that film as a whole has gotten a pass. To this day “Soul Man” is still heavily criticized but not “Tropic Thunder.” I guess because the latter stars Iron Man, was a hilarious film, and a big mainstream hit.
Back to Chappelle, I thought at first his jokes about the the LGBT community were outdated and made him seem old, but I think it’s just because they simply weren’t funny. I was watching Amy Schumer’s Leather Special and she has political opinions I agree with in her comedy special, but I also found the jokes to be unfunny and lame, in particular her gun control bit. But I didn’t once attribute it to her having the wrong politics or age being a factor.
Last edited by brayzie; 09-01-19 at 03:40 PM.
#31
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
Watched it over the weekend. I'd say there was a half hour of good/great material throughout the hour special.
The bit about identifying as Chinese was cringe-worthy.
The bit comparing white heroin addicts to black crack addicts of the 80's and defending his house with a shotgun was fucking hilarious.
He also made a very good point to the audience...want gun control to get fast-tracked? Have every black person in America buy one legally. Boom; instant gun control legislation.
The bit about identifying as Chinese was cringe-worthy.
The bit comparing white heroin addicts to black crack addicts of the 80's and defending his house with a shotgun was fucking hilarious.
He also made a very good point to the audience...want gun control to get fast-tracked? Have every black person in America buy one legally. Boom; instant gun control legislation.
#32
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
The bit comparing white heroin addicts to black crack addicts of the 80's and defending his house with a shotgun was fucking hilarious.
He also made a very good point to the audience...want gun control to get fast-tracked? Have every black person in America buy one legally. Boom; instant gun control legislation.
He also made a very good point to the audience...want gun control to get fast-tracked? Have every black person in America buy one legally. Boom; instant gun control legislation.
#33
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
Birdshot, Buckshot, Birdshot.....buckshot, buckshot, buckshot!
lmao
lmao
#35
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
#36
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
Did Downey do blackface? I was under the impression blackface is an exaggerated caricature (burnt cork or shoe polish, exaggerated lips) intended to demean and dehumanize. Isn't that a far different thing than an actor using makeup to make themselves resemble a character of a different skin colour, especially when this change of skin colour is irrelevant to the joke (like Jimmy Kimmel imitating Karl Malone, or Rob Lowe imitating Arsenio Hall, or Zoe Saldana playing Nina Simone...)?
#37
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
Posts: 63,299
Received 1,816 Likes
on
1,131 Posts
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
It's sad but i feel like many entertainers in the Black Community, the comedians in particular, want a "Cultural Pass" for being anti-LGBT.
#38
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
By a literal definition, it was blackface, however it wasn't used in a way to demean people of color. It was used to highlight exactly how absurd blackface is to begin with and to mock the notion of method acting in such a way; his character is quite pitiful and sad throughout the movie as a whole due to his actions and intentionally so.
Why did RDJ and the film get a pass, when Soul Man is criticized to this day? That film didn't have the main character playing a black caricature. He talked and acted his normal self even when he was pretending to be black. Billy Crystal got criticized for resurrecting his Sammy Davis Jr impersonation complete with make-up to darken his skin and wig, and from what I saw of it, it didn't seem to be intended to demean Davis's ethnicity.
If Tropic Thunder had Loqueesha-level production quality and star power it probably would have been labeled racist.
#39
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
I've started rewatching the Chappelle Show after seeing this thread.
#40
Senior Member
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
Chappellle nailed it out of the park with this one. I hate fucking politics because both sides, well, and the middle, don't even get started. Anyway, it's interesting to see his "base" slowly go "wtf is happening?" You could especially see it on the faces of the people in the audience as their heads slowly implode and then the outrage everywhere online too.
It's hysterical actually, totally next level. Once those who are offended the most can truly see the forest for the trees will they then see this for the genius that it is.
It's hysterical actually, totally next level. Once those who are offended the most can truly see the forest for the trees will they then see this for the genius that it is.
#41
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
One of the reasons Chappelle quit the business back then was he was in Disney World with his kids. Some super fans would go up to him and his kids in line and say, "I'm Rick James, bitch!!!!!" That's how great the show was because that is one of the best skits of all-time, yet I totally see how he would get annoyed that grown men would repeat it in front of his kids without any clue that they are kids.
#42
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
#43
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
One of the reasons Chappelle quit the business back then was he was in Disney World with his kids. Some super fans would go up to him and his kids in line and say, "I'm Rick James, bitch!!!!!" That's how great the show was because that is one of the best skits of all-time, yet I totally see how he would get annoyed that grown men would repeat it in front of his kids without any clue that they are kids.
Last edited by Bluelitespecial; 09-07-19 at 09:20 PM.
#44
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
I think most sketch/variety shows come off as dated because most of the skits deal with current events at that time. What happens is the younger generations don't really get the context of that joke when they see something from 20 years ago. For example, when Chevy Chase used to trip all over the place like Gerald Ford, I'm sure that was hysterical in 1975. But if you watch it now, most people don't know why President Ford was portrayed that way, or would feel it is over the top. Now there are exceptions as the 'Rick James skit' will always be funny simply because it's so damn funny.
#45
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Dave Chappelle Netflix Special - Sticks & Stones -- premieres 8/26/19
His opioid and heroin comparison to crack was great. “Just say no”. Haha.