You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
#51
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
I think that the show is narrated by the protagonist is what makes the show good. You get to know the main characters motivations for his actions, even if at times they are a bit twisted. Sometimes you can agree with what the character is thinking and how he is justifying his behaviors; more so in seasons two and three.
#52
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
Season 3 reaction:
Spoiler:
Last edited by MLBFan24; 10-29-21 at 10:59 PM.
#53
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
I just finished binging this and I actually liked it more than Season 2. I do have to say, the most important aspect of the show to me is Penn Badgley's narration. I dont think he is a great actor overall and Victoria Pedratti is much better but his narration skills blow hers away for some reason. It is like he is a better VO actor then he is in person where the opposite is true for her. The episode where Love was the narrator showed how much of a difference there is.
Although I do wonder if that is a specific actor/director choice since he is a sociopath, his internal monologue can be full of emotion and interesting inflections but his outward persona does not allow for that type of emoting.
I know a lot of people were hoping the show would continue with Love as the main character/narrator and I have to say I don't think it would work solely due to the VO aspect.
Although I do wonder if that is a specific actor/director choice since he is a sociopath, his internal monologue can be full of emotion and interesting inflections but his outward persona does not allow for that type of emoting.
I know a lot of people were hoping the show would continue with Love as the main character/narrator and I have to say I don't think it would work solely due to the VO aspect.
#54
DVD Talk God
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley

Listen to this clip and then you'll understand why I posted this here. Hilarious.
#56
Moderator
Thread Starter
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
Yea I saw that earlier and couldn’t believe that wasn’t a joke. 

#59
Moderator
Thread Starter
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
#60
DVD Talk Legend
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
Never watched season three yet. Maybe eventually I’ll get around to it. I liked season one more than season two personally.
#61
Moderator
Thread Starter
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
New year, new country, new persona - and yet Joe can’t seem to shake off his past. YOU S4 part 1 comes to Netflix on February 9th.
The following users liked this post:
devilshalo (01-09-23)
#62
Moderator
Thread Starter
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
Part 1 of Season 4 drops tomorrow.
#63
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
I really liked season 1, 2 and 3 were ok'ish. This new season to me sucks.
#64
DVD Talk God
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
Apparently Badgley told the showrunner that he will no longer do sex scenes on the series. And she agreed to his request.
#65
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
Weird, since he definitely filmed sex scenes for this season that were in the first 5 episodes. Knocked those out this weekend.
This show is trash and I'm embarrassed I watch it, but damn if it isn't entertaining
This show is trash and I'm embarrassed I watch it, but damn if it isn't entertaining
#66
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
Season 4A was really good. I liked the departure from love obsession to murder mystery.
Nice change to the series, but keeping the same “killer” theme. And I like the England location setting.
This new season has the ad break fade outs. Weird to see on Netflix shows haha. I have the ad free plan, so it doesn’t matter to me.
Nice change to the series, but keeping the same “killer” theme. And I like the England location setting.
This new season has the ad break fade outs. Weird to see on Netflix shows haha. I have the ad free plan, so it doesn’t matter to me.
Last edited by MLBFan24; 02-14-23 at 09:18 PM.
#67
Moderator
Thread Starter
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
#68
DVD Talk Legend
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
I have to say, I quite enjoyed the first half of the season.
It's always nice to see Charlotte Ritchie, and Ed Speleers is usually good, as well.
It's always nice to see Charlotte Ritchie, and Ed Speleers is usually good, as well.
#70
Moderator
Thread Starter
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
The second half of the season is now up.
#71
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
I'm not sure how I feel about s4 on a whole at first I hated it and then started to like it once part 2 came out and then started to hated it again.
I did like Kate's character a lot. Can't say I've seen the actress before but she is very pretty.
I did like Kate's character a lot. Can't say I've seen the actress before but she is very pretty.
#72
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
I liked season 4. After watching the first half, I kept telling my friends (who also watch the show) that I was glad this season wasn't about him being a stalker 
Excellent twist in the second half of season 4. That twist never even crossed my mind.
Good cameos in episode 4.9.
I'd be ok with the show retiring. The finale seemed like a series finale. I don't need a season 5.

Excellent twist in the second half of season 4. That twist never even crossed my mind.
Good cameos in episode 4.9.
I'd be ok with the show retiring. The finale seemed like a series finale. I don't need a season 5.
#73
DVD Talk Legend
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
I enjoyed the season. I was initially pissed with what I 'thought' was the twist, but was much relieved that it wasn't the actual twist.
I'm happy to watch more of this, except that if it continues
Spoiler:
#74
Re: You (now on Netflix) C: Berlanti, Gamble, S: Penn Badgley
Look for her in the current show 'Ghosts' from the UK, as well as in a show called "Fresh Meat," which is where I first saw her. Both are really good. She's been in lots of other stuff, as well.
I enjoyed the season. I was initially pissed with what I 'thought' was the twist, but was much relieved that it wasn't the actual twist.
I'm happy to watch more of this, except that if it continues
I enjoyed the season. I was initially pissed with what I 'thought' was the twist, but was much relieved that it wasn't the actual twist.
I'm happy to watch more of this, except that if it continues
Spoiler: