DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Are Sitcoms almost dead ? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/634433-sitcoms-almost-dead.html)

Astrofan 05-20-16 11:30 AM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
Schitt's Creek

PhantomStranger 05-20-16 01:11 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
I think animated comedies have taken up much of the space once occupied by sitcoms. What is dead is the family sitcom. ABC keeps trying, I guess.

Paff 05-20-16 01:34 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 

Originally Posted by PhantomStranger (Post 12807043)
I think animated comedies have taken up much of the space once occupied by sitcoms. What is dead is the family sitcom. ABC keeps trying, I guess.

And succeeding, considering how many family sitcoms they're running. I would have thought that Dr. Ken wouldn't make a full season let along a renewal, but apparently it does ok in that Friday night slot with Last Man Standing. Throw in The Middle, Modern Family, Fresh Off the Boat, The Goldbergs, and Blackish, and that's a lot of family sitcoms. If they weren't performing, they'd change it up.

DJariya 05-20-16 01:43 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
The genre is hardly dead. A bunch of network sitcoms were greenlit for next season.

Humor is extremely subjective, so I can't say that all network sitcoms suck. Some people love The Big Bang Theory and New Girl and some hate them.

There are a lot of good family sitcoms like Fresh off the Boat, The Goldbergs and The Middle. Modern Family is still fun even though it's starting to show it's each now.

I admit I like 2 Broke Girls even though most find it to be a dumb sitcom. I like that Kat and Beth have great chemistry and play off each other well even with the stupidest jokes and puns.

Double_Oh_7 05-20-16 02:09 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 

Originally Posted by PhantomStranger (Post 12807043)
I think animated comedies have taken up much of the space once occupied by sitcoms. What is dead is the family sitcom. ABC keeps trying, I guess.

ABC has the best TV comedy line-up in a long time, since Must See TV. I just wish they would try a little variety and not have every one of them be about a family.

Albert71292 05-20-16 02:28 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
Last sitcom I remember watching on a regular basis on the networks was "3rd Rock From The Sun". The current batch are unwatchable to me.

james2025a 05-20-16 02:30 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
I tend to despise sit-coms. Anything with a idiot/laughter track tends to be horrible. Shows like King of Queens, Two and a Half Men and The Big Bang Theory are shows written by idiots and watched by idiots. Watching paint dry would provide more originality and better laughs.

Good riddance to them all i say.

Koby 05-20-16 02:34 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
The Great Indoors looks like it could be a good one. It premieres this fall.

Other than that, there hasn't been any good comedy in years since TBBT went downhill.

Astrofan 05-20-16 02:56 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 

Originally Posted by james2025a (Post 12807110)
I tend to despise sit-coms. Anything with a idiot/laughter track tends to be horrible. Shows like King of Queens, Two and a Half Men and The Big Bang Theory are shows written by idiots and watched by idiots. Watching paint dry would provide more originality and better laughs.

Good riddance to them all i say.

FWIW two of three you list don't use laugh tracks.

Original Desmond 05-20-16 05:32 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
The reason i like having some sitcoms in my lineup is you want some shows you don't need to concentrate 100 percent, you can do other things while watching

Xiroteus 05-20-16 08:47 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
Been so long since I touched a sitcom, just no hook or catch. And most are rarely funny.

Troy Stiffler 05-20-16 10:20 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
Multi-camera sitcoms are almost dead. Maybe someone will reinvent or make one to knock our socks off. But I don't think I watch any of them right now.

Single camera sitcoms are alive and well and some of the best entertainment around right now. I think they are considered sitcoms ... ?

My Horace and Pete's format (multi-camera, shot like a stage play) will gain some traction.

Josh-da-man 05-20-16 10:31 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 

Originally Posted by Troy Stiffler (Post 12807394)
Multi-camera sitcoms are almost dead.

This.

writer106 05-20-16 11:43 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
I also agree with Troy Stiffler on multi-camera sitcoms. Most people I know have grown to dislike that format.

writer106 05-20-16 11:51 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 

Originally Posted by Double_Oh_7 (Post 12807085)
ABC has the best TV comedy line-up in a long time, since Must See TV. I just wish they would try a little variety and not have every one of them be about a family.

ABC tried in the 2014-15 season to have non family sitcoms with Manhattan Love Story and Selfie. I remember Selfie started off awful but improved. I liked the leads on Manhattan Love Story and a few people in the supporting cast were good, IIRC it had worse ratings than Selfie. I think Selfie and Manhattan Love Story could have worked well as basic cable sitcoms. I think ABC will try again to have non- family sitcom later on.

Hailey G 05-21-16 06:00 AM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
I liked Selfie a lot (that may have something to do with liking Karen Gillian a lot, but it wasn't just her, I had fun with the show), but the title was awful.

Nick Danger 05-21-16 06:28 AM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 

Originally Posted by james2025a (Post 12807110)
I tend to despise sit-coms. Anything with a idiot/laughter track tends to be horrible. Shows like King of Queens, Two and a Half Men and The Big Bang Theory are shows written by idiots and watched by idiots. Watching paint dry would provide more originality and better laughs.

Good riddance to them all i say.

Idiots is the most important demographic for television. How many shows engage your intellect? How many of those get good ratings? TLC figured out that there weren't enough people who wanted to learn math to make them rich. A lot more people want to see Honey Boo Boo.

JuryDuty 05-21-16 12:06 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
I don't think it's dead, but it's not alive like it used to be. "Back in the day," it seemed like night-after-night-after-night of sitcoms. But now enjoyable sitcoms seem few and far between.

This last season I pretty much watched only Modern Family, Brooklyn Nine-Nine and The Grinder, the latter of which was cancelled.

I have pretty much no interest in a sitcom with a laugh track because they're written for quick laughs, not building comedy (like Arrested Development).

That said, I still enjoy older shows with laugh tracks because they work--like Everybody Loves Raymond, Seinfeld or even Three's Company. But all those are usually a half an hour of a wind-up to a hilarious pay-off at the end. But that's just not the way most sitcoms are written anymore.

MLBFan24 05-21-16 01:41 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
Love Brooklyn Nine-Nine

Almost getting tired of Modern Family. Almost. Still watching it, but same storylines over and over (oh look, a misunderstanding between the characters)

Fuller House surprised me. It was actually good.

RichC2 05-21-16 01:53 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 

Originally Posted by Double_Oh_7 (Post 12807085)
ABC has the best TV comedy line-up in a long time, since Must See TV. I just wish they would try a little variety and not have every one of them be about a family.

ABC tried a lot of stuff in that Wednesday line-up. What we have now is after 5 - 6 years of weeding out the lower rated shows (Happy Endings, Selfie, Super Fun Night, etc; ) and it seems like family is what stuck.

But while The Goldbergs, Black-ish and The Middle are all family shows for families. Modern Family always seemed more like a family show geared slighty more toward adults, so the whole line-up feels a little off.

PhantomStranger 05-21-16 02:28 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
ABC's strategy with sitcoms is usually targeting very specific niche demos that aren't served very well by network television. They are specifically made for certain advertisers wanting to hit demos like urban, African-American audiences that live in the bigger coastal cities.

sven 05-21-16 04:38 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 

Originally Posted by Original Desmond (Post 12806680)
Well fellas name a good one then lol !

Brooklyn Nine Nine is my favorite airing right now.

Original Desmond 05-21-16 05:00 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
but when we look at the new lineups, it's full of TV shows based on movies (and not comedy movies)

Are there any must see new sitcoms on the schedule ?

I guess the difference is a premise can sell an action/thriller/horror/mystery/procedural type show

But for sitcoms it is all about cast chemistry

PhantomStranger 05-22-16 12:42 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 
A great premise can usually sell a genre show on its own, which is why you usually get virtual no-names cast as superheroes on television. Comedies are all about the writing and talent, which is why network sitcoms always attempt to place one big name in the cast.

Double_Oh_7 05-22-16 01:11 PM

Re: Are Sitcoms almost dead ?
 

Originally Posted by Troy Stiffler (Post 12807394)
Multi-camera sitcoms are almost dead. Maybe someone will reinvent or make one to knock our socks off. But I don't think I watch any of them right now.

Single camera sitcoms are alive and well and some of the best entertainment around right now. I think they are considered sitcoms ... ?

I will never understand the snooty attitude toward multi-camera sitcoms. What difference does it make how many cameras/what format a comedy uses as long as its funny. The writing is what matters. I couldn't give a shit how they film it.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:47 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.