DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/634388-major-characters-killed-off-screen-without-participation-actor.html)

TheMovieman 05-17-16 11:06 PM

Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
I was thinking about this with the last couple episodes of "NCIS" where Ziva was killed in an explosion off-screen. Another one that came to mind was "Criminal Minds" where Gideon was murdered with a stand-in serving as the body (under a sheet).

What other instances has this occurred?

DJariya 05-17-16 11:09 PM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Julie Finlay on CSI

Her death was mentioned in passing on the 2 hour finale

CD was murdered off screen in Walker Texas Ranger.

Danny Sorensen was also murdered off screen on NYPD Blue when Rick Schroeder left the show.

writer106 05-17-16 11:15 PM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Nicole Chapman on Fame

The Cow 05-17-16 11:18 PM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Henry Blake - M*A*S*H

DJariya 05-17-16 11:24 PM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Going back even further Jim Davis (Jock Ewing) was killed off on Dallas after he died in real life.

Lynne Thigpen died of a brain hemorrhage while working on The District. They didn't kill her off, but made her character die of the same fate. I remember they shut down filming for a couple of months after it happened.

On Army Wives, Kim Delaney's character Claudia Joy died offscreen when she wasn't asked back to the show. It was following her alcohol issues.

windom 05-17-16 11:30 PM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
While not technically "killed", Colin Baker's Doctor on Doctor Who should count. I think they just had Sylvester McCoy wear a wig to represent Colin's Doctor before the regeneration started.

Decker 05-17-16 11:39 PM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Most famous, by far, is Charlie Sheen on Two and a Half Men. Twice, actually.

Decker 05-17-16 11:41 PM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 

Originally Posted by The Cow (Post 12804687)
Henry Blake - M*A*S*H

That was off-screen, but it was on the same episode he said goodbye and was done with his consent.

Cardsfan111 05-17-16 11:43 PM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
James Evans - Good Times

Paff 05-17-16 11:53 PM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Are we counting when the actor dies in real life? Because I imagine there'd be a ton of those...

DJariya 05-17-16 11:56 PM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Almost forgot, Larry Hagman (JR Ewing) was murdered off camera on the TNT reboot of Dallas after he died of cancer in real life.

Crocker Jarmen 05-18-16 12:07 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
When the actress playing Livia died inbetween seasons of The Sopranos, they had her character die off-screen, but not before using her in one last scene by using old footage to CGI her head on another actresses body. Even 15 years ago this looked terrible.


TheMovieman 05-18-16 12:09 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 

Originally Posted by Paff (Post 12804706)
Are we counting when the actor dies in real life? Because I imagine there'd be a ton of those...

Many examples already, but it falls within the parameters.

Double_Oh_7 05-18-16 12:22 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 12804699)
That was off-screen, but it was on the same episode he said goodbye and was done with his consent.

No, it wasn't. Only a very few people knew they were going to kill off Henry, McLean was not one of them.

GatorDeb 05-18-16 12:57 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Private Practice:

Spoiler:
Pete at the end of Season five because they wanted to cut costs. Actor was not happy about it. Show only lasted a shortened season six more.

Josh-da-man 05-18-16 02:14 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 

Originally Posted by windom (Post 12804697)
While not technically "killed", Colin Baker's Doctor on Doctor Who should count. I think they just had Sylvester McCoy wear a wig to represent Colin's Doctor before the regeneration started.

That was the first one I thought of.

There was sort of a behind-the-scenes war that ended up with Colin Baker being fired between seasons. He was (rightly) pissed off and refused to return for a regeneration scene.

Paff 05-18-16 02:20 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Sgt. Phil Esterhaus on Hill Street Blues, and Coach on Cheers, due to the deaths of the actors portraying them. I never watched Newsradio. How did they deal with the death of Phil Hartman?

mwbmis 05-18-16 07:10 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 

Originally Posted by Paff (Post 12804740)
Sgt. Phil Esterhaus on Hill Street Blues, and Coach on Cheers, due to the deaths of the actors portraying them. I never watched Newsradio. How did they deal with the death of Phil Hartman?

Phil was murdered during summer hiatus. The first episode of the fifth had the characters coming back from his funeral. They even brought back Khandi Alexander for that show.

TheBigDave 05-18-16 07:57 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
I seem to recall one of the DA's from Law & Order just disappeared out of the blue. They said her character had been kidnapped and beaten to death.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexandra_Borgia

dfmaverick2 05-18-16 08:35 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Howard's mom on Big Bang Theory...although, she was never really "on" screen except for a computer generated shot from a satellite.

HN 05-18-16 09:17 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 

Originally Posted by dfmaverick2 (Post 12804806)
Howard's mom on Big Bang Theory...although, she was never really "on" screen except for a computer generated shot from a satellite.

you get a few glimpses in this scene, too:


Coral 05-18-16 09:21 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Peter Gregory on Silicon Valley. Christopher Evan Welch died during production of the 5th episode and was written off as being away on some business trip. The second season started with them relaying that he was killed while on safari.

DWilson 05-18-16 09:45 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Back in the '70s, Susan Saint James left "McMillan and Wife", which simply became "McMillan". At one point during the first episode, McMillan's sidekick (John Schuck) drops a line (I'm paraphrasing) commenting on how well McMillan (Rock Hudson) is doing since Mrs. McMillan died in that plane crash six months ago.

DRG 05-18-16 10:19 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 
Biggest one I can think of was Valerie Harper from her self-titled sitcom Valerie. She demanded more money once the show became a hit, contract talks fell through, and she walked off the show. Rather than recast her character (also named Valerie) they simply killed her character off and resumed the show as Valerie's Family, and later The Hogan Family.

milo bloom 05-18-16 10:43 AM

Re: Major Characters Killed Off-Screen and/or without the participation of actor
 

Originally Posted by DRG (Post 12804918)
Biggest one I can think of was Valerie Harper from her self-titled sitcom Valerie. She demanded more money once the show became a hit, contract talks fell through, and she walked off the show. Rather than recast her character (also named Valerie) they simply killed her character off and resumed the show as Valerie's Family, and later The Hogan Family.

I seem to recall the reason given in the show was that a checkout aisle candy stand fell on her and killed her.

Pretty tacky way to treat her, regardless of behind the scenes drama.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:33 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.