DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/626950-game-thrones-s5e07-gift-5-24-15-a.html)

dhmac 05-27-15 08:23 AM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by windom (Post 12491620)
Can someone refresh my memory? For some reason, I thought that Sam had lost the dragonglass knife. I seem to remember him dropping it after killing the white walker and just leaving it there. I could be completely wrong though...

This scene from Season 2 ( LINK ) shows just how much dragonglass was found.

(But I wonder what happened to that horn thing that was found there as well?)

dhmac 05-27-15 09:20 AM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by ytrez (Post 12492431)
Cersei can't comprehend that the high sparrow has true faith and assumed, like her, he is out for power. She gave him power, putting the high sparrow and his flock in the place of the disgraced High Septon. Then she did away with the decree which disarmed the religious troops, hiving the high sparrow even more power. Then she provided the means for him to take down the Tyrells, etc. Having given him so much power, in her head, Cersei thinks he's now beholden to her, having gotten what he wants. She can't comprehend that what he wants is compliance with the laws of the Seven. It's because of this that she couldn't see it coming.

Yep. Cersei thinks only politically and assumed the High Sparrow was her political ally and that he was loyal to her for giving him power. She doesn't understand that he's a religious fanatic and probably attributes his rise to power entirely to his piety in the Faith of the Seven, so to him it was a gift from the Seven and he gives no credit for it to Cersei at all. And he has said no one is exempt from the laws of the Seven, which are really his own interpretations of those laws. When people get a "little" religious, they tend to look inward and apply its rules to themselves. But if they keep going down that path and get a "lotta" religious, then they typically want to apply its rules to everyone else with no exceptions. That's what Cersei didn't understand.

Aphex Twin 05-27-15 11:55 AM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 
Daenerys Targaryen and Tyrion Lannister

Spoiler:
Is it obvious to everyone that Daenerys and Tyrion will get married and that something bad will happen during the wedding?

dhmac 05-27-15 02:46 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 
About halfway through episode 1 of this season, there's an interesting scene (in hindsight) during the funeral for Tywin in which Lancel wearing the monk-like sparrow garb first appears.

Lancel expresses sympathies to Cersei for her loss, but then his father Kevan Lannister walks up and talks to Cersei in front of Lancel.

Kevan: "I apologize for my son's appearance."

Cersei: "That's quite all right."

(Lancel walks away)

Kevan: "They call themselves 'Sparrows'... bloody fanatics. Religion has its place, of course, to a certain point. They never would have come to the capital when Tywin was alive."

Cersei: "I'm sure he'll grow out of it, whatever it is."


This scene shows that Kevan understood what the Sparrows were from the get-go, something which Cersei never truly got until they locked her up. And it makes me think that Kevan will be returning to King's Landing before the season is out.

superdeluxe 05-27-15 02:49 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by dhmac (Post 12492894)
About halfway through episode 1 of this season, there's an interesting scene (in hindsight) during the funeral for Tywin in which Lancel wearing the monk-like sparrow garb first appears.

Lancel expresses sympathies to Cersei for her loss, but then his father Kevan Lannister walks up and talks to Cersei in front of Lancel.

Kevan: "I apologize for my son's appearance."

Cersei: "That's quite all right."

(Lancel walks away)

Kevan: "They call themselves 'Sparrows'... bloody fanatics. Religion has its place, of course, to a certain point. They never would have come to the capital when Tywin was alive."

Cersei: "I'm sure he'll grow out of it, whatever it is."


This scene shows that Kevan understood what the Sparrows were from the get-go, something which Cersei never truly got until they locked her up. And it makes me think that Kevan will be returning to King's Landing before the season is out.

At this point, seems like Tommen might need to call on his Great Uncle.

dhmac 05-27-15 03:58 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 
HBO put the Cersei and High Sparrow scene online. As Cersei's realization of what's going on starts to sink in, Lena Headey does a marvelously subtle job of acting without talking.

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/fbvnPanLmfY" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

(NOTE: avoid the subtitles with this because they are a computer-generated mess... well, unless you want a laugh that is)

LurkerDan 05-27-15 05:02 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 
interesting. I don't recall her saying "I am the queen!" She obviously has lost sight of the fact that a) she is not the queen anymore and in fact had a hand in throwing the queen in the same jail she's headed for, and b) that she is responsible for the fact that a queen (or queen mother) can be thrown in jail by the High Sparrow.

And yes, this isn't the first scene where she has displayed some excellent acting chops.

davidh777 05-27-15 05:09 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by LurkerDan (Post 12493026)
interesting. I don't recall her saying "I am the queen!" She obviously has lost sight of the fact that a) she is not the queen anymore and in fact had a hand in throwing the queen in the same jail she's headed for, and b) that she is responsible for the fact that a queen (or queen mother) can be thrown in jail by the High Sparrow.

And yes, this isn't the first scene where she has displayed some excellent acting chops.

Yeah, I noticed her reaction of delusional-grandeur-under-stress.

Hey, Cersei, you were totally the queen until you decided that that wasn't good enough for you!

dhmac 05-27-15 05:29 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think Cersei has ever called herself the Queen Mother (or if she has, she probably did it while grimacing). Everyone else does call her that and it is actually the best title she has left, but I don't think she likes it. Being the "Queen Mother and nothing more" as Kevan said earlier this season is not enough for Cersei - she still wants to be the Queen.

arminius 05-27-15 05:54 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 
I don't know if episode titles are considered spoilers so:

Spoiler:
E8 Hardhome-Sounds like this will be a Jon and north of the wall episode, can't wait.
E9 The Dance of Dragons-A Dany episode? I love it when a plan comes together.

creekdipper 05-27-15 06:07 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 
It will be interesting to see how they handle a certain upcoming scene which had to be moved from some location over religious objections (and shielded from view by gawkers).

(Even though it's been talked about months ago in Entertainment Weekly, if that seems too spoilery, I'll delete).

Defiant1 05-27-15 06:40 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by dhmac (Post 12493054)
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think Cersei has ever called herself the Queen Mother (or if she has, she probably did it while grimacing). Everyone else does call her that and it is actually the best title she has left, but I don't think she likes it. Being the "Queen Mother and nothing more" as Kevan said earlier this season is not enough for Cersei - she still wants to be the Queen.

Until the most recent episode, Cersei has had more power than ever this season. I'm not sure why the show hasn't been referring to her as Queen Regent as they did back in Season 2. Just like with underage Joffrey, Cersei has been heading up the Small Council. Under Tommen, she was Hand of the King in all but name.

As the wife of the ruling king, Margaery is Queen Consort and as the de facto ruler of Westeros, Cersei should be Queen Regent.

arminius 05-27-15 06:52 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by creekdipper (Post 12493087)
It will be interesting to see how they handle a certain upcoming scene which had to be moved from some location over religious objections (and shielded from view by gawkers).

(Even though it's been talked about months ago in Entertainment Weekly, if that seems too spoilery, I'll delete).

I sort of understand the objection but
Spoiler:
it's nudity as penance and not sexual at all. I can understand sexuality being verboten in this kind of situation but the sheer horror of the nude human body that some cultures have just does not make sense to me. As in movie ratings I don't get how ultra-violence is okey dokey but show a boob and the world stops. Almost everyone is naked under their clothes. It should not be a big deal.

dhmac 05-27-15 07:15 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by Defiant1 (Post 12493111)
Until the most recent episode, Cersei has had more power than ever this season. I'm not sure why the show hasn't been referring to her as Queen Regent as they did back in Season 2. Just like with underage Joffrey, Cersei has been heading up the Small Council. Under Tommen, she was Hand of the King in all but name.

As the wife of the ruling king, Margaery is Queen Consort and as the de facto ruler of Westeros, Cersei should be Queen Regent.

Yeah, I'm still trying to figure out how their system works. As I understand it, the Hand of the King leads the Small Council meetings if the King isn't there personally.

So Ned as Hand of the King lead them in Season 1, Tyrion as acting Hand of the King sometimes lead them in Season 2, and Tywin lead them in Seasons 3 & 4. With Tywin's death, there is not a current Hand of the King, so Cersei is heading them up as the King's representative as she claims, which would make it seem that she's still the Queen Regent and ruling in Tommen's stead.

But the fact that Kevan disputed her authority and said she's the "Queen Mother and nothing more" suggests that she is no longer the Queen Regent which makes me think Tommen is now of age (whatever age that is) and is the King in title and in power. As to why King Tommen hasn't simply designated Cersei as the Hand of the King, I guess women are not allowed to have that role. And that may explain why there is not a Hand of the King right now: Cersei will be losing all power she still has once that happens, so she keeps Tommen from designating anyone for that role.

Philzilla 05-27-15 07:19 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by dhmac (Post 12492969)
HBO put the Cersei and High Sparrow scene online. As Cersei's realization of what's going on starts to sink in, Lena Headey does a marvelously subtle job of acting without talking.
Spoiler:

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/fbvnPanLmfY" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

(NOTE: avoid the subtitles with this because they are a computer-generated mess... well, unless you want a laugh that is)

Yeah that's a terrific scene, she's doing some great eye acting. She held me entranced, watching her reactions, as that played out.

fujishig 05-27-15 07:52 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 
Queen Regent rules while their kid is underaged, but by the time the King takes a Queen (and the marriage is consummated) I'd think the regent bit is done for. Remember what set off Cersei was Margaery trying to get Tommen to send his mother back to Casterly Rock (plus the fear that Margaery is the younger girl from the prophecy).

brainee 05-27-15 08:12 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by arminius (Post 12493120)
I sort of understand the objection but
Spoiler:
it's nudity as penance and not sexual at all. I can understand sexuality being verboten in this kind of situation but the sheer horror of the nude human body that some cultures have just does not make sense to me. As in movie ratings I don't get how ultra-violence is okey dokey but show a boob and the world stops. Almost everyone is naked under their clothes. It should not be a big deal.

Spoiler:
I'm not familiar with the controversy. But could it be less over the nudity, and more because of how similar the whole scene could appear to Jesus' walk with the cross? Not that there aren't too many more similarities between Cersei and Jesus :D

Josh-da-man 05-27-15 08:17 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by dhmac (Post 12493138)
As to why King Tommen hasn't simply designated Cersei as the Hand of the King, I guess women are not allowed to have that role. And that may explain why there is not a Hand of the King right now: Cersei will be losing all power she still has once that happens, so she keeps Tommen from designating anyone for that role.

I suspect that folks aren't exactly lining up to be The Hand of the King considering the fates of the last four.

dhmac 05-27-15 09:20 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by Josh-da-man (Post 12493193)
I suspect that folks aren't exactly lining up to be The Hand of the King considering the fates of the last four.

The last four? Tywin, Ned, Jon Arryn, and who else?

(I'm not counting Tyrion because he was only temporarily appointed as acting Hand of the King in his father's stead and also he is still alive and far away from his family, so a win-win on his fate at this point)

Defiant1 05-27-15 09:23 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 
Tywin was the Hand before Jon so does he count twice?

dhmac 05-27-15 09:50 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by The Infidel (Post 12491791)
By the way, I couldn't help but notice this time around that nobody is saying that Ramsay didn't rape Sansa. :lol:

If the social justice warriors start applying their single-minded political correctness to "Game of Thrones" again, I'll just link to this video:

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/v7m5VcpMCtU" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Aphex Twin 05-27-15 09:55 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 
Do you think we'll get an episode this season where it's just one single battle from beginning to end?

EctoCooler 05-28-15 03:22 AM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by Aphex Twin (Post 12493259)
Do you think we'll get an episode this season where it's just one single battle from beginning to end?

Spoiler:
Well, we will be getting the largest battle yet on the show in terms of scale. That's been confirmed. How much screentime it actually takes up during the episode remains to be seen. Rewatching the Blackwater episode recently, the actual fighting only took up about 20 - 25 minutes.

dhmac 05-28-15 05:19 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 

Originally Posted by Aphex Twin (Post 12493259)
Do you think we'll get an episode this season where it's just one single battle from beginning to end?

All I know is the director listed for episode 9 this season is NOT Neil Marshall, who has been the big battle director of the show so far, directing both the 2nd season Battle of Blackwater episode and last season's Battle of Castle Black episode.

Instead this season's episode 9 lists David Nutter as the director and, in Season 3, he directed the Red Wedding episode. He also directed a few episodes of HBO's WWII miniseries Band of Brothers and The Pacific, so that shows he does have some past experience directing battle scenes.

aktick 05-28-15 05:35 PM

Re: Game of Thrones (S5E07) -- "The Gift" -- 5/24/15
 
Reading those ep titles, 9 I'm guessing will indeed be epic. Not that that's a big surprise given past seasons...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:24 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.