What i mean by that are what shows in your canon of shows you watch are the ones you want to watch either live or ASAP (meaning the day after from DVR) and get the most enjoyment out of?

Game of Thrones
Mad Men
New Girl
Orphan Black
Orange is the New Black
Parks and Recreation
Hannibal
Nurse Jackie

The Walking Dead
Game of Thrones
Bates Motel
Orphan Black
Homeland

Grimm
Archer
Fargo
Vikings
Suits
Ray Donovan

Game of Thrones
The Good Wife
The Walking Dead I can usually wait a few days

Vikings
Fargo
Hannibal

Game of Thrones and The Walking Dead... Both I watch the night they're on otherwise it's just too darn hard to avoid spoilers the next morning.

Fargo
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia
The Big Bang Theory
Parks and Recreation

... and I see myself blowing thru Season 2 of Orange is the New Black right after it hits Netflix.

Hannibal is a clear #1....the wait between Fridays is excruciating.

Mad Men
The Blacklist
Masters of Sex (when it comes back)
Community
Parenthood

Hannibal
Game of Thrones
The Blacklist
Grimm
Pardon the Interruption

After removing ones that ended within the last few weeks I current watch these with the most important in red with green as the second tier. Sometimes it's likely giving one show a 100 and another a 90. I enjoy each one overall otherwise I would not watch them. Some of these can wrap up and end their story sooner than later like Under The Dome, that really should have been one maxi series and done. Even Revolution needs to do something else for the next season.

CW - Arrow
CW - Supernatural
NBC - Grimm
AMC - Walking Dead
CW - Beauty And The Beast
ABC - Agents Of Shield
CW - Originals
CW - Tomorrow People
NBC - Revolution
ABC - Once Upon A Time
CW - Vampire Diaries
CBS - Elementary
FOX - Sleepy Hallow
SYFY - Haven
LIFE - Witches Of East End
BBC - Doctor Who
TNT - Falling Skies
MTV - Teen Wolf
SYFY - Warehouse 13
SYFY - Defiance
CBS - Under The Dome
SYFY - Continuum
BBC - Sherlock
SYFY - Bitten

NIC - Legend Of Korra

Arrow
Person of Interest
The Good Wife
Teen Wolf

Can't believe i forgot The Black List.

Saturday Night Live
Shark Tank
The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon

Game of Thrones
Walking Dead
Agents of SHIELD (the last few episodes, anyway)

Better Call Saul- still have mixed feelings on it but I'll watch it.
Halt and Catch Fire- looks like it has potential to be interesting, hopefully AMC doesn't screw it up.
Louie- just started watching the series on Amazon Prime and fell in love with it.
Orange is the New Black- haven't started this series yet but might give it a try.

Seasons already in progress:
Bates Motel
Fargo
Mad Men

Of the shows currently on:

Game of Thrones
Mad Men
Veep
Jeopardy

Monday Night RAW
Justified
Orange is the New Black
Brooklyn 99
The Big Bang Theory
Elementary
Game of Thrones
AFV (don't judge me!)
Nurse Jackie
Game of Thrones
Bar Rescue

Parks and Rec
Community
Brooklyn 9-9
Haven
That Metal Show (don't ask me why, but I love this stupid show)
Hannibal
Bates Motel
Orphan Black

Game of Thrones
Archer
Walking Dead
Arrow
Agents of Shield
Community
Vikings
Fargo
and those new Mickey Mouse shorts, whenever they air I Youtube it the next day

In the fall:
Sons of Anarchy
Boardwalk Empire

The Blacklist
Grimm
The Walking Dead
Person of Interest
24: Live Another Day (well, coming soon)

I'm not sure how shows that haven't even made their debut yet can qualify as "must watch that you get the most enjoyment out of", but maybe that's just me.

Nearly guaranted same day watches other than sporting events...

Sunday - Amazing Race (largely to avoid spoilers)
HBO's tent pole show (for the most part)
AMC - Walking Dead/Talking Dead and Mad Men - though I have been known to push Mad Men to Mondays when it's airing at the same time as Game of Thrones to avoid "quality television overload"

Monday
N/A

Tuesday
Brooklyn Nine-Nine made it's way to same day status rather quickly

Wednesday
Survivor (largely to avoid spoilers)

Thursday - Saturday
N/A

Lots of other shows that I like and watch, but I fall behind. Given how fantastic the show is, it's hard to fathom that I'm three weeks behind on Hannibal, but I travel a lot for my job, and Hannibal isn't exactly a show I can sit down and watch while I'm enjoying breakfast.

The shows I watch the same night they air:

Game of Thrones
Person of Interest
Arrow

These I watch either the night they air or the next day:

Blacklist
Lost Girl
Tomorrow People
Supernatural
Scandal
Elementary
Grimm
Bitten
Agents of Shield

Orange is the new black

and how great is that theme song by Regina Spektor??

01. House Of Cards
02. Mr.Selfridge
03. Banshee
04. Hannibal
05. Game Of Thrones
06. The Big Bang Theory
07. The Amazing Race
08. Mad Men
09. Vikings
10. Downton Abbey

Castle is the only show I watch live.

The others I have bought the season on Vudu and watch them a few days after they air when they are available.

Game of Thrones
Vikings
Fargo
The Walking Dead
Boardwalk Empire

(DVR only - I watch nothing live)