Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

Dany not really thinking?!?!?!?! The shock of it all!!!!!!!!

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

She sends the slaves into the desert and they eat the sand which is there. Maybe I should have spoilered that.

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

They're going to be pissed when they find out their promised 40 acres is north of the wall, and their mules won't stop saying "Hodor."

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

I don't listen to hip-hop

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

Yeah. I'm pretty sure I know why they're sort of dragging this out and not revealing who Theon's captor is. And it does tie into some other things that are going on.

This is sort of a divergence from the books and there's a running plot thread from season two that they've been holding really close to their vests. I expect all of this to be revealed by the end of the season. There's a mystery from season two that a lot of people haven't really picked up on... I've only seen it mentioned once here recently.

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

^If that mystery concerns Winterfell, then I'll chalk that up to a) too much going on, b) not caring or c) being told by book readers (at least in regards to Who, Why is another story).

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

I don't recall if you said what your suspicions are in previous threads, but could you post it and put it in spoilers? I'm curious!

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

It's a big plot point. Theon said he didn't torch Winterfell and kill everyone there. They are trying to use the scenes with Theon to keep it fresh in everybody's mind....two big questions are a) who is Theon's captor, and b) if Theon didn't sack Winterfell, who did and why?

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

Okay... (and trying not to reveal too much)...

The identity of Theon's captor is:



As for my suspicion as to why they're withholding the identity of Theon's captor and that "mystery that not too many people have picked up on" it is because

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

It's been sometime since I've watched season 2 but after Theon took Winterfell and ended up getting himself surrounded and whoever it was kept constantly playing a horn all the time...just like this guy who's torturing him does? Did they ever say who it was who was surrounding Theon at Winterfell? It makes me think they would also responsible for sacking the city as well.

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

One of Robb's allies' bastard son and his men sent to take back Winterfell. Can't remember which ally. Robb wanted to do it himself, but he had battles to fight and was talked out of it.

I always just figured it was him who was torturing Theon, but honestly couldn't give a fuck either way.

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

I really want to see what Josh-da-man is talking about but I'm not going to. Must...resist...
:grumble:

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

Thanks, I know some spoilers from the books to understand what you're talking about, but I had thought your description plays out similarly in the books. Which part diverges, if you don't mind me asking for more spoilers?

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

This is breaking my heart :sad: I know people can't help themselves but I'm sure this stuff is better suited to PM to keep the temptation or accidents away from those who aren't asking. If PMs aren't good enough, there's the spoiler thread.

It's just playing with fire this way.

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

Yeah, I'd say those who haven't read, seriously don't give into the temptation. It'll play out soon enough.

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

Keep resisting.

I've had certain book events spoiled for me since season 1, needless to say I was not amused. My hope is that the TV people made some changes, if only to mess with the book folk.

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

Yah, the temptation's passed. Whew.

Well, GRRM was actually credited as the writer for the last episode, so if there's anyone who'd be an authority to change certain events from the book, it'd be him. :)

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

:lol:

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

Why would it break your heart? The more temptation the better :)

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

The main points of divergence with the books are

(Last spoiler post. Even if someone peeks, I'm trying my best to keep this stuff vague.)

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

Cool, thanks, didn't know that. There's been enough questions and material in spoiler tags for this show, so I don't really see the big deal about this in particular being in spoiler tags here since it was Josh's personal guess at how things played out differently. Oh well.

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

If it makes you feel any better, I didn't drop any any huge spoilers. Just the name of Theon's torturer and who he's aligned with (which sort of puts it in spoiler territory). Fairly minor stuff, though there are implications to knowing his identity and agenda. At any rate, I don't see the series sitting on this stuff much longer.

The problem with putting this stuff in a spoiler thread... for someone who just wants a bit of minor information... is that the spoiler threads are filled with bigger spoilers.

For some reason it seems like Theon's storyline is driving people nuts. Everywhere, not just here. I'm thinking, my God, it's like three minutes per episode, and you watched a guy get his dick cut off and you're bored with that storyline?

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

Yes. Yes I am. It's gone from Torture Porn to Torture/Porn, but that's not a huge improvement.

There's only two ways torture scenes would be interesting to me :
1) If I had a rooting interest in the torture victim's well-being (James Bond in Casino Royale, Mel Gibson in just about every movie pre-arrest
2) if I were actively pulling for the torturers because the info being obtained was vitally important and/or the torture victim was someone so loathesome I wanted it for him (Zero Dark Thirty)
3) Jack Bauer -- He's 50% 1) and 50% 2).

This is neither and it's a slog to watch. I don't need to see him getting tortured every week to know that his character is still tied to a giant X in a musterious dungeon and getting tortured every week.

Why waste even three minutes a week on a storyline that's going nowhere and not advancing at all. Now he doesn't have a pinkie or a penis, great. I can't really imagine getting told that later couldn't have sufficed.

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

And I had to laugh that my wife, who read book 3 and is fighting every urge to spoil things for me, chose the beginning of this week's Theon scene to run out of the room and call for me to "let her know when it's over". She's only done that once before : when Jamie struck up a conversation with Locke. I'm getting the distinct feeling whenever she runs from the room, something awful is about to happen. :)

Re: Game of Thrones -- "The Bear and the Maiden Fair" -- 5/12/13
 

Some random thoughts about the current ep.

- Was I the only one that wanted Jon to say "you know nothing Ygritte" during the windmill scene?
- I don't see how Theon is a ladies man/has a "Podrick" ;)? His earlier scene(s) with Roz and I think Tyrion made me think the opposite. Certainly not something that would be reach the ears of his torturer. Sloppy writing to justify his punishment.
- As much as I enjoyed the porn dialogue for Theon's scene, I'm starting to join the haters of his subplot. I think I would rather watch Shireen teach the Onion Knight to read.
- They do seem to be doing their best to turn Jamie into being the likable Lannister.
- Is there still a war going on? There's been 1 marriage and like 5 marriage arrangements since Robb marched south from Winterfell.

And all this talk about Winterfell's razing now has me thinking, what happened to the other ironborn? Not just the men that Theon was with but the army his sister was leading.