The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
#26
Banned by request
Re: The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
Can we get rid of Alison Pill? She's by far the worst character on the show. I'd love to see more of Lisa, though.
#27
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
Weird, except for her boobs, there's actually not much attractive about her. Not saying she's ugly or anything, just absolutely average looking (she could stand to lose a few pounds as well). She is certainly far more likable than Pill's character though, who needs a punch in the face.
#28
Re: The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
Maggie needs to relax. Demanding Jim to break up with the girl? I know there's that underlying sexual tension between them, but Jim just needs to tell her "I'm your fucking boss. Shut up." once in a while.
#29
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
Alison Pill straddles the line between cute ugly and ugly ugly, but she's starting to lean in the direction of the latter. I take the brunette any day of the week - and she's looks just fine weight-wise.
#30
DVD Talk God
Thread Starter
Re: The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
Solid episode. Really enjoyed how the events with Bin Laden's news played out.
The stuff on the plane with Don, Sloan and Elliot was hilarious.
Unexpected surprise to see Salli Richardson-Whitfield as the DC anchor. One minor nit pick about that whole scene with her and Mac. As someone who works in a television control room, some of that scene didn't make sense from a technical standpoint. They have a live feed of her from DC up, yet Mac needs to call her on the phone to speak with her? As far as I know, the audio people would connect her audio line into the control room and the Producer should be able to speak to her directly through a headset.
And I don't know what Slop is smoking, but Kelen Coleman (Lisa) is hot. Yes, she has a little more meat on her bones, but she's by no means fat or overweight. She's tall, has a pretty face and beautiful long hair. And of course, she has great tits. I know they are leading towards something between Jim and Maggie, but he's a fucking idiot if he passes on Lisa to go for that crazy, mousy and neurotic woman.
Really liked at the end how they transitioned from Will's lead-in to the actual video of Obama's speech.
The stuff on the plane with Don, Sloan and Elliot was hilarious.
Unexpected surprise to see Salli Richardson-Whitfield as the DC anchor. One minor nit pick about that whole scene with her and Mac. As someone who works in a television control room, some of that scene didn't make sense from a technical standpoint. They have a live feed of her from DC up, yet Mac needs to call her on the phone to speak with her? As far as I know, the audio people would connect her audio line into the control room and the Producer should be able to speak to her directly through a headset.
And I don't know what Slop is smoking, but Kelen Coleman (Lisa) is hot. Yes, she has a little more meat on her bones, but she's by no means fat or overweight. She's tall, has a pretty face and beautiful long hair. And of course, she has great tits. I know they are leading towards something between Jim and Maggie, but he's a fucking idiot if he passes on Lisa to go for that crazy, mousy and neurotic woman.
Really liked at the end how they transitioned from Will's lead-in to the actual video of Obama's speech.
#31
Banned by request
Re: The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
I was glad that Jim asked Lisa out for real at the end of the episode. I was going to be pissed if they wrote her out completely.
#32
Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Alabama
Posts: 94
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
Alison pill Should go the way of Moira Kelly. And Dev Patel's character needs to stop talking about UFO and bigfoot.
Otherwise good show. Love Sam Watterson in everything he does.
Otherwise good show. Love Sam Watterson in everything he does.
#34
DVD Talk Hero
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: In the straps of boots
Posts: 28,051
Received 1,198 Likes
on
847 Posts
Re: The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
Alison Pill reminds me of Kristen Bell in a way.
I was watching this episode in a hotel room, and the feed cut out a few times. I really liked it, but to me, the best episode has been the Gabby Giffords one. I hate that Coldplay song, but it worked well in that context.
I was watching this episode in a hotel room, and the feed cut out a few times. I really liked it, but to me, the best episode has been the Gabby Giffords one. I hate that Coldplay song, but it worked well in that context.
#36
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
But that said, I really like this show although I disagree with most of what it seems to stand for. But it's very funny and entertaining and even moving when it needs to be.
#38
Senior Member
Re: The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
Finally watched this tonight. While I understand the criticisms that this show brings on itself, I think this episode did a pretty amazing job of putting me back in the mindset of when I heard about Bin Laden's death.
I was totally mesmerized from the moment Will got the go ahead to report it and the transition to the President's announcement as it faded over the credits. And yeah, the reveals to the airline pilots and bodyguard were touching to me too. Sorkin knows his melodrama and does it very well, and I guess I'm a sucker for it. A great episode in my mind for sure. But I've enjoyed this from the first ep, faults and all.
Oh, I think Allison Pill is cute as hell in this, even as neurotic as her character is!
I was totally mesmerized from the moment Will got the go ahead to report it and the transition to the President's announcement as it faded over the credits. And yeah, the reveals to the airline pilots and bodyguard were touching to me too. Sorkin knows his melodrama and does it very well, and I guess I'm a sucker for it. A great episode in my mind for sure. But I've enjoyed this from the first ep, faults and all.
Oh, I think Allison Pill is cute as hell in this, even as neurotic as her character is!
#39
Moderator
Re: The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
The Cato Institute posted a response to Newsroom:
http://www.cato-at-liberty.org/free-...rst-amendment/
<iframe width="640" height="360" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/in2g06TBsK4" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
http://www.cato-at-liberty.org/free-...rst-amendment/
<iframe width="640" height="360" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/in2g06TBsK4" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
#40
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: The Newsroom -- "5/1" -- 8/05/12
My take on Maggie switches episode-to-episode. In the first episode she was sweet and great. In the second, she was psychotic. Since then, she's gone back and forth. I get the idea she's the one character that Sorkin (or maybe the actress) isn't exactly sure how to play. I agree that her interaction with Jim is a bit over the top, but I see what Sorkin is trying to do. It's essentially the Jim and Pam characters from The Office, but Maggie is way more intense than Pam.
That said, I find her forgivable given the quality and enjoyment of this show. I'll put up with her crazy moments so long as this show sticks around for a long time.
That said, I find her forgivable given the quality and enjoyment of this show. I'll put up with her crazy moments so long as this show sticks around for a long time.