View Poll Results: After watching tonight's finale, overall what did you think of season 5?
Did not enjoy season 5. Worst season of the series (I'm in the minority)



0
0%
Don't have cable and won't spend money to buy the episodes, will wait until the BD/DVD



0
0%
Voters: 83. You may not vote on this poll
Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
#76
Banned
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 3,503
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
I stand corrected. 
You've pointed out another thing that was disappointing about Don this season. For more than half the season he wasn't a shark and didn't seem to have any fire in him whatsoever, whether it be because he was "happy" with Megan or what, he seemed even more dead inside than when he was a drunken wreck last season. I'm hoping now that he cares again he'll go back to being a more dynamic character next season instead of walking out of meetings going "I don't care" and having them all machinate behind his back.

I don't watch the show to see Don be a womanizer. He is a womanizer, and I accept that, but I don't watch the show for it. Him being a shark with the clients, on the other hand, is Great Stuff (tm). So much of "sales" is personality and I love seeing Don work his magic.
That whole, "You're not happy with dominant market share... you want total market share," presentation was exquisite to watch -- worthy of being in a top tier movie. It might or might not work, but the very way he turns up his nose at the concept of being happy with dominant market share makes him the immediate favorite for the Brass Cojones Of The Year award.
That whole, "You're not happy with dominant market share... you want total market share," presentation was exquisite to watch -- worthy of being in a top tier movie. It might or might not work, but the very way he turns up his nose at the concept of being happy with dominant market share makes him the immediate favorite for the Brass Cojones Of The Year award.
Last edited by Dragon Tattoo; 06-12-12 at 04:00 PM.
#77
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
I believe Don will cheat at the end of the episode/season because he kind of "lost respect" for Megan. First she's all whiny because Don said no to her idea for starring in the commercial, then she's like a child, all grateful and 'appeased,' and how can a man possibly respect a woman like that? He thought he had a business-minded, responsible woman, but instead he really just has a tempermental girl. He's already got one - Sally. He don't need another.
#78
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
Loved this exchange.
Pete: "I've got things to do. Don, you have my proxy."
Don: "We can do that?"
Pete: "I've got things to do. Don, you have my proxy."
Don: "We can do that?"
#79
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#80
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
I believe Don will cheat at the end of the episode/season because he kind of "lost respect" for Megan. First she's all whiny because Don said no to her idea for starring in the commercial, then she's like a child, all grateful and 'appeased,' and how can a man possibly respect a woman like that? He thought he had a business-minded, responsible woman, but instead he really just has a tempermental girl. He's already got one - Sally. He don't need another.
#81
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
#82
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
First I was hoping that people would realize my comment was tongue-in-cheek. Second yes, people's opinion can be wrong--I refer you to the support for slavery once upon a time in this country. There are many other examples I could give you.
Last edited by Astrofan; 06-13-12 at 12:35 PM.
#83
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
#84
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
IMO Mad Men is at its best when Draper is on the prowl.
That's what we all want to see...
But, thanks for the grammar correction.
#85
Banned
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 3,503
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
Supporting something isn't an opinion. And a belief isn't exactly the same thing, either, even when unmerited. I suggest you go look at a dictionary.
#87
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
A pretty good read recapping the whole season: http://www.grantland.com/story/_/id/...ure-don-draper
#88
Senior Member
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 926
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
I may be reading too much into the image of the partners of SCDP all standing in front of the window, but I thought it was interesting how all the "new" partners (Pete, Don, and Joanie) are on one side of the empty window and the "old" partners (Sterling and Cooper) were on the other.
#89
Thread Starter
DVD Talk God
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12

Great season and great finale. It was definitely worth the wait.
I agree with the previous comments when Don was walking away it symbolized that he didn't get what he wanted out of his relationship with Megan.
I loved his reaction when the blonde girl at the bar asked if he was alone.The shot in the empty office with everyone was really cool. But, I must have missed the setup for that. When did they decide to move to a new office?
at Pete getting his ass kicked. I have to wonder if Pete's fling with Rory Gilmore will come back into the storyline next season with Trudy finding out.If Jessica Pare does return next season, I have to assume it will be as a recurring guest star. Despite some of your nitpicks about her teeth/mouth, I think she's a really stunning woman and has the look for the time period. I would like to see her come back and bring some closure to her relationship with Don. That black and white demo reel of her that Don was viewing was really gorgeous.
I have to assume that season 6 will probably premiere in Spring 2013.
#90
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
#91
DVD Talk Hero
#92
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
i haven't heard anyone mention this, but wasn't the girl who came up to Don at the end, Megan's friend from whom she stole the commercial idea?
#93
Thread Starter
DVD Talk God
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
#94
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#95
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 553
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
I don't follow. Why would she not come back? She's still Don's wife. Anybody who is involved with Don on a day-to-day basis is going to be a big part of the show, IMO.
#96
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2003
Posts: 688
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
I've seen this mentioned in a bunch of places and it amazes me. They were both blonde but beyond that, they looked (and sounded) extremely different.
#97
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
I was rooting for Pete on the train! Not only did I want Pete to come off the better in his fight against that a-hole, but I also wanted him to kick the ass of that fucking snooty-ass bitch train conductor.
As bad as Pete is, I think the other guy is worse.
As bad as Pete is, I think the other guy is worse.
#98
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
#99
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
If Pete can't even beat Lane in an impromptu fight there's no way he's going to beat the train guy in anything.
#100
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Mad Men -- Season Finale -- "The Phantom" -- 6/10/12
Just finished Season 5, as I should be done Season 6 and 7.1 in the next 2 weeks so I can start watching the final 7 episodes live.
I have to say that while I liked Season 5, I think it was the weakest of the 5 seasons so far that i have watched. I don't want that to come off as negative, as Season 5 was great, but compared to the other 4 seasons, it just wasn't AS great. Season 5 started off slow, IMO, but really picked up in the 2nd half and ended with a bang.
Please no spoilers, as I am just thinking out loud here in my observations:
-I'm interested to see where the show goes with Peggy at a rival firm, as there has to be a way she is wooed back to work for Don?
-With Betty still on the show (limited role), I'm sure she will have one last fling with Don, but her character will never be happy even if she actually finds true happiness.
-Pete is an interesting character because he is very successful at his job, but he seems to be miserable outside the firm more then any other character on the show.
-I have really come to like Joan's characters since Season 3. I thought she was just some bitchy bimbo in the first 2 seasons, but they really developed her character well. (No pun intended)
-I'm sure Don/Meghan are probably headed for splits-ville simply because that will make the show more interesting.
I have to say that while I liked Season 5, I think it was the weakest of the 5 seasons so far that i have watched. I don't want that to come off as negative, as Season 5 was great, but compared to the other 4 seasons, it just wasn't AS great. Season 5 started off slow, IMO, but really picked up in the 2nd half and ended with a bang.
Please no spoilers, as I am just thinking out loud here in my observations:
-I'm interested to see where the show goes with Peggy at a rival firm, as there has to be a way she is wooed back to work for Don?
-With Betty still on the show (limited role), I'm sure she will have one last fling with Don, but her character will never be happy even if she actually finds true happiness.
-Pete is an interesting character because he is very successful at his job, but he seems to be miserable outside the firm more then any other character on the show.
-I have really come to like Joan's characters since Season 3. I thought she was just some bitchy bimbo in the first 2 seasons, but they really developed her character well. (No pun intended)
-I'm sure Don/Meghan are probably headed for splits-ville simply because that will make the show more interesting.















