Just got an email that Tivo is again available on DirecTV in HD. Anyone have this?

I used to have TiVo in SD on Directv and loved it. I've Direct HD DVR for long though that i'm not sure it's worth going back to TiVo anymore. Any thoughts by Diectv users?

I doubt anyone has it yet as it just came out today. It is also $5 extra a month and it doesn't have all the functionality of the DirecTV hddvr.

I wish I could go back to Tivo as I liked their interface better than the Directv DVRs, but I'm under a 2 year contract after upgrading my equipment in 2010, so I can't do anything until next summer at the earliest.

I gave up my TiVo this past January when I got DirecTV, and honestly... I don't miss it. The DirecTV DVR is fine.

It makes me sad, but it's the way it is.

I have a SD DirecTIVO and besides the obvious difference SD vs. HD, I think the DTV HDDVR is far more user friendly.

Fwiw the new hd interface for the DirecTV hddvrs is hitting soon.

Really? I did not know this. Is there a place where we can check it out?

Is it actually rolling out finally? I know they were talking early November on DBSTalk a few people were getting it already, and by the end of November most would have it. I'm sure they ran into issues and wanted to be sure it was working right...

From what I've seen, it looks very nice. The biggest gripe seems to be it still only shows 1.5 hours in the guide.

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/wmYCc0mpvtw" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Should make their supposed HBOGo-esque HBO On Demand a lot easier to implement than before.

A friend of mine was one of the testers. I didn't see the big deal about it, but I didn't really spend much time checking it out.

Thanks. Looks okay I guess, but I'm not blown away. Then again it's hard to know without being able to play around with it.

I think the main thing is it will be much faster, supposedly. No more clunky guide and menu changes. Plus a little cleaner look, I guess.

Sounds like it will be a few MONTHS before every market gets it.

I wouldn't mind having the TiVo peanut remote control back.

Somehow I completely missed this news, until I saw an offer from weaknees for it. So anyone have the new Tivo yet? Also, does the $199 have to be accompanied by a contract renewal?

I'm still not sure why DirecTV did this deal with Tivo. They just came out with a new HD DVR of their own (5 channels at the same time or something like that), and the Tivo doesn't even have all of the features of their old DVRs. Unless there's something I'm missing (and I was a huge Tivo fan back in the day), why would someone pay the extra five bucks a month for this? The interface?

Last week all of my Directv DVRs got a software upgrade and they changed the color and appearances of the menus and the menus look exactly like the picture aktick posted.

No more of the ugly light blue and yellow menus on your Directv DVR.

it is alot faster too. like the change.

It's not out for everyone. They are rolling it out slowly to different markets. I'm too lazy to link it, but if you do some research on DBSTalk.com, there's a post that shows when you can expect it if you don't already have it.

A few years ago, I would have been all over this. But now, I have no desire to go away from the DTV HD DVR's. Once they finally added the true dual buffers to them, that greatly lessened my desire to go back to a TiVo. Throw in Whole Home, and it's a wrap.

Weird, given how much of a TiVo fan I was in the beginning (I won a free Sony one from them when Tivo first came out). Had the decal in the window of my SUV, paid the $900 for the first HD-TiVo on DTV, and all that. Now...... "meh"

I guess the Bay Area was one of those lucky markets.

So is Los Angeles... it was a pretty dramatic change when I turned it on for the first time after the change, but they did a great job... nicer looking, and seamless upgrade. With that and the new DVR they announced at pretty much the same time as the Tivo, are they trying to bury it, or did they just look to get something out the door and plan to have a full-featured Tivo out later?

Heady times indeed - I bought one of the very first Dtivo's for 900 and sold it almost straight away for 1800 as I was travelling

I got the TIVO receiver for another room and I am not impressed.

TIVO was good in 2006 but now it seems outdated plus the guide covers the entire screen so you can't see anything or browse the guide while watching TV at the same time.

Also you don't get the pictures of movie posters or pictures in general when you tape a movie or TV show on the TIVO.

No 3D or Whole Room Service or Youtube.

Directv HD DVR is leaps and bounds over the TIVO model and supposedly it won the PC Magazine readers choice award according to Directv.com.

Directv will introduce HMC DVR or the home video center DVR where you can record 5 shows at once similar to the Dish Network Hopper later this year.

http://www.directv.com/DTVAPP/conten...y/hmc_receiver

The hmc dvr (hr34) is already out everywhere, and iirc. I have it and love it.

I used to have a Tivo Series 2 and loved it too death. When I switched to Directv from cable last year I thought I was going to miss it. I haven't missed it one bit. Directv's DVRs are very easy to use, I haven't missed any shows and my wife knows how to use it without any help from me!

We've got the HD34 (got it during the Viacom dispute) and love it. Always missed the Tivo and they were going to give me that instead (since I threatened to go back to Tivo) but the no "whole home" thing is what got me. The interface on DTV has improved SO MUCH since we first got rid of our DirecTivo that I don't think I'll ever go back. I do hate the glaring blue lights (we've got a Tom Servo in front of 1 and a Crow in front of the other, thanks MST3K collector's editions LOL).