DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   How would you have ended Lost? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/574424-how-would-you-have-ended-lost.html)

Pizza 05-28-10 03:16 PM

How would you have ended Lost?
 
Be serious or funny.

I would have liked to have seen Jack be the big hero and survive and get Kate. And, no Jacob and a nameless brother.

Or, something like the movie "Passenger." i wonder if the producers saw that film and if they did, what they thought?

Tscott 05-28-10 04:03 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
Didn't we just do this a couple weeks ago? http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/573...-end-lost.html

Superman07 05-28-10 04:10 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 

Originally Posted by Tscott (Post 10183808)
Didn't we just do this a couple weeks ago? http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/573...-end-lost.html

Yes, but that was before we knew the ending. That was speculation, this is revision.

I'm okay with keeping the heaven/afterlife story line since it gives closure to the characters. However, I would have made Jack and Desmond's actions been the end of the island as well. That would have brought closure to that component of the story as well and given the Oceanic 815 a purpose beyond just another group to land on the island.

calhoun07 05-28-10 04:33 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
I would have ended it Jimmy Kimmel's way with it being Vincent's dream.

kstublen 05-28-10 04:58 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
I know technically Kate died but I'd have had her death appear on-screen. I always hated her character and each episode I hoped she'd kick the bucket, but knew she never would.

...and I'd probably have answered some of the questions fans wanted to know instead of just ignoring all of the mysteries built up over 6 seasons, but that's just me.

mhg83 05-28-10 05:13 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
Christian Shepard is revealed to be the devil and everyone goes to hell instead of Heaven. Their punishment is to be forced to watch Lost over and over again for all eternity.

Also the Dog pisses on Jacks face as the last shot of the Finale.

Jason 05-28-10 05:13 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
Assuming we're not going back and changing anything from the first five seasons, I would have done the following:

1) The "across the sea" storyline would have been the season-long flashback. Give the people building the donkey wheel guns and let them shoot at the outrigger. :)

2) LA-X would have aired at the same time as across the sea, and it would have been a self-contained episode which would truly be the alternate timeline created by jughead. Probably make this one a two hour episode. Less fanservice, and more "they're not any better off than if they were on the island".

3) The final episodes would have played out more or less the same way, but with more info on whitmore's group and desmond. Maybe some token dialog about the dharma initiative.

4) Kill kate.

Cardiff Giant11 05-28-10 05:22 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
Actually answering some questions about what the hell the smoke monster is (other than somehow being Jacob's brother) as well as the temple, and all the other unanswered questions. Not answering everything mind you but more than they did.

I also thought the purgatory thing was truly an alternate timeline and somehow by everyone remembering the island and coming together the timelines would merge. After that not sure but I really was hoping and expecting that.

hardercore 05-28-10 05:34 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
I'm fine with the finale how it was... if anything, I'd change parts of the past 120 episodes to raise fewer questions for people to bitch and moan about.

OscarBluth 05-28-10 07:31 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
Michael Scofield wakes up back in prison and it was all just a dream. Too bad, Snowflake! Now go get your insulin pills from Rockmond Dunbar. :lol:

Gilgamesh1082 05-28-10 07:49 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
http://i247.photobucket.com/albums/g...h1082/Lost.gif

Drexl 05-28-10 09:35 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
They would all be back on the plane, except this time they are waiting for someone to fulfull his destiny so that they can move on together.


Kevin M. Dean 05-28-10 10:28 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
The White Smoke Monster would have made an appearance.

redrum 05-28-10 10:30 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
Kate, Penny, and Juliette have a threesome in a tub of baby oil

HE Pennypacker 05-28-10 11:07 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
http://i247.photobucket.com/albums/g...h1082/Lost.gif

Patman 05-28-10 11:09 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
It would have been funny if they could have found the original kid actor who played the autistic son in St. Elsewhere, and have the same character, now an adult, looking at a snowglobe once again on a pull-out shot that starts in on the snowglobe and slow pulls out and reveals the son with a raised eyebrow.

PHMustang2000 05-28-10 11:21 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
They all get on a boat trying for escape and in the ocean they run into Tom Hanks who is upset that Wilson just floated away. They both all find a boat and is rescued.

RoyalTea 05-28-10 11:46 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 

Originally Posted by redrum (Post 10184224)
Kate, Penny, and Juliette have a threesome in a tub of baby oil

add in post-pregnancy, pre-crazy Claire and I'm in.

GuessWho 05-29-10 06:53 AM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
Russell got them all voted off.

calhoun07 05-29-10 11:57 AM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 

Originally Posted by RoyalTea (Post 10184300)
add in post-pregnancy, pre-crazy Claire and I'm in.

Add dark haired/gothed up Claire to that and even better! :up:

cornyt 05-29-10 12:50 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 

Originally Posted by HE Pennypacker (Post 10184261)

That is awesome.

arminius 05-29-10 04:59 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 

Originally Posted by HE Pennypacker (Post 10184261)

You know, the more I see this video the more I think it would have been the perfect ending instead of the pseudo-religious claptrap.

david2708 05-29-10 05:27 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
They all walk through the church doors into the light and find paradise is....another friggin' island. Sawyer lets out one of his famous frustrated expletives.....son of a bitch....... The End.

Dan 05-29-10 06:15 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
Ethan... on the plane.

dhmac 05-29-10 10:29 PM

Re: How would you have ended Lost?
 
Had it be revealed that everything (the plane crash, the conflict with the others, Jacob and MIB, and everything else) was actually orchestrated by Alvar Hanso as a large communal research project within the Dharma Initiative, which had not been defunct but was still very active the entire time.

(And this ending would also explain why the DI was still making supply drops!)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:21 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.