DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/565261-heroes-thanksgiving-11-23-09-a.html)

DJariya 11-23-09 01:48 PM

Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
<a href="http://s110.photobucket.com/albums/n104/djariya/?action=view&current=Heroes.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://i110.photobucket.com/albums/n104/djariya/Heroes.jpg" border="0" alt="Heroes"></a>

Synopsis:

Spoiler:


The Thanksgiving holiday prompts Noah to arrange an unusual gathering, while the Petrellis are caught off guard by a surprise dinner guest. Meanwhile, Hiro is held captive by Samuel as Lydia seeks answers.



1 more new episode left, then the show returns on January 4 with 2 back to back episodes.

Goldberg74 11-23-09 03:31 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
Can wait!





;)

Giantrobo 11-23-09 10:56 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
HRG movin' on to a hot young Piece of Ass :up:
The whole Patrelli thing :down: WHO CARES ANYMORE!!!
The Carnies :up:

Xiroteus 11-24-09 12:15 AM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
I enjoyed it, Hiro really needs to teleport Samuel to the arctic and (at least pretend) he will leave them there unless he gets back Charlie back and then he can return and take Samuel back to land. Would it work? Who knows, Samuel knows Hiro could kill him without trying, that will not get Hiro any information nore is Hiro one to act in such a manner.

Baron Of Hell 11-24-09 03:46 AM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
It was ok episode. I think maybe they should have left Sylar out of this season and just focused on the dark carnival. Not that Sylar story isn't interesting we just don't need him as the big bad every season. The cast is huge with to many side stories going on. Wost still they are adding new characters to show that is already packed.

auto 11-24-09 06:39 AM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
We could probably just have one thread for the entire season should they give this show another.

Luds 11-24-09 07:50 AM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
Decent show, I did enjoy the Bennett family reunion, but the whole Sylar thing is just beyond boring and repetitive at this point. He should have been killed in the season 3 finale and be done with it.

The writers just don't get it. KILL PEOPLE OFF YOU IDIOTS! Again this season they had a chance with Parkman, there was no reason to bring him back, it would have made sense to kill him and Sylar's mind at the same time, leaving fake Nathan alone in Sylar's body without this whole good/bad switching crap.

The carny stuff is getting more and more interesting now that the other characters know that evil dude killed his older brother.

Snowmaker 11-24-09 08:06 AM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
If I hear Hiro whine one more time about Charlie.....

He needs to just forget about her already, or maybe he did with that mind wipe. Who is Watson and why did he teleport off to save him after that?

gmanca 11-24-09 08:39 AM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
I don't think it was a mind wipe; that dude has used his powers to restore people memories. Unless it's a Holmes reference and Ando is in trouble, I don't think Watson has been introduced.

Gizmo 11-24-09 10:32 AM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 

Originally Posted by auto (Post 9852866)
We could probably just have one thread for the entire season should they give this show another.

I think news will hit soon if it gets another season or not. They only have a few episodes out of the 19 not 'shot' and NBC will announce if it's the final season or getting renewed shortly.
I see it going 3 ways:
1. It get's renewed
2. It gets canned, but gets an additional 3-6 (maybe 9?) more episode order to finish out the series
3. Gets a final season but it premieres in the summer (faster syndication) and will go with the whole "NBC is new year round" deal with Friday Night Lights and (possibly) Chuck.

Yesterday and next week ratings will be the indicator for NBC. Maybe just last nights.

Brodie Corleone 11-24-09 12:21 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
Why doesn't Hiro just go back in time and prevent Samuel from taking Charlie?

If Hiro doesn't want to go back in time for whatever reason, why doesn't he go to the future to see if he even ends up finding Charlie?

SteelWill 11-24-09 12:30 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
Are you guys who want Hiro to do something smart not remembering what show this is?

Heck, I'll play along. I likes Samuel's idea of hacking pieces off him until he talks. Then Hiro goes back in time, tells himself where Charlie is, and doesn't have to do anything to Samuel.

Super X 11-24-09 12:33 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
Charlie is probably hanging out with Peter's Irish girlfriend whom he left in the future and subsequently forgot about.

GoVegan 11-24-09 12:36 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
I was hoping Hiro would freeze time and chop off one of Samuel's fingers and repeat until he got the result he wanted. That what I was hoping for. What I was expecting was Hiro saying "Give back Charlie!" Sadly I was right.

Gizmo 11-24-09 01:22 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
What happened to Ando?

Joeboo835 11-24-09 02:00 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 

Originally Posted by GizmoDVD (Post 9853557)
What happened to Ando?

Bangin' Hiro's sister. I know I would be.

Bandoman 11-24-09 02:19 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
I don't know why HRG's ex-wife was huffy about him having a date at Thanksgiving dinner when she brought her obnoxious bf with her.

Hiro should transport Samuel somewhere/womewhen remote and inaccessible and tell him that he will be let free when Charlie is safe. Fuck the waiting around shit.

Raul3 11-24-09 02:20 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
I actually liked this episode. A lot better than last week that was really laughable and not in a good way.

I liked the Casablanca reference. I loved the dinner at Claire's dad. And I actually liked when Sylar came back, that look, that smile, that being badass.

Next week episode looks really good too.

Dan1boy 11-24-09 03:07 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
Such a shame that this season is the best since season one. They really blew it the last few years.

Dave99 11-24-09 04:14 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 

Originally Posted by Bandoman (Post 9853661)
Hiro should transport Samuel somewhere/womewhen remote and inaccessible and tell him that he will be let free when Charlie is safe. Fuck the waiting around shit.

That's what I was thinking. Drop his ass off at a penguin colony in antartica or something.

Timber 11-24-09 04:59 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
So I'm confused. Why has Samuel been collecting people with "abilities" if he hadn't seen the recording yet?

zuffy 11-24-09 05:21 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
What is the girl's name that played Lydia's daughter Amanda?

pelenor 11-24-09 06:41 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
Charlie is playing a germaphobe high school counselor in another timeline.

shadowhawk2020 11-24-09 06:58 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 
Why does Hiro never return a few seconds after he left? That way it doesn't look like he was gone long. Why wouldn't he go back and stop the other time traveler from taking her?

Time travel and TV should not be done.

PopcornTreeCt 11-24-09 07:31 PM

Re: Heroes -- "Thanksgiving" -- 11/23/09
 

Originally Posted by Timber (Post 9853948)
So I'm confused. Why has Samuel been collecting people with "abilities" if he hadn't seen the recording yet?

Exactly.

This was supposed to be a "redemption" season for the show but it's just as awful as the other seasons.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:21 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.