The Prisoner (AMC miniseries) -- "Arrival" -- 11/15/09
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Limited Edition
The Prisoner (AMC miniseries) -- "Arrival" -- 11/15/09

Synopsis:
Spoiler:
This is a remake of the classic British series, set to run six episodes. Looks pretty good from the previews (which AMC has been showing like crazy the last couple of weeks).
#2
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Prisoner (AMC miniseries) -- "Arrival" -- 11/15/09
It's been getting bad reviews, but I'll still tune in. Not setting my expectations high, since I'm not expecting it to match the quality of the original.
#4
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Prisoner (AMC miniseries) -- "Arrival" -- 11/15/09
I recently watched the orignal for the first time, after watching the entire run of Danger Man over the last several months. I enjoyed the beginning, but I have to believe they will not follow the original's ending. I've read the ending was very rushed or maybe McGoohan was heavily medicated, but either way I don't think such nonsense would fly today.
One thing that bothers me from the description above:
I've also read that they are tweaking the theme of the original:
One thing that bothers me from the description above:
Spoiler:
I've also read that they are tweaking the theme of the original:
Spoiler:
#5
DVD Talk God
Re: The Prisoner (AMC miniseries) -- "Arrival" -- 11/15/09
I'll definitely be checking this out. It looks like it has the production value of a major feature film.
The 2nd episode airing tonight is "Harmony"
Synopsis:
Looks like it's 6 episodes over the next 3 nights.
The 2nd episode airing tonight is "Harmony"
Synopsis:
Spoiler:
Looks like it's 6 episodes over the next 3 nights.
#8
Re: The Prisoner (AMC miniseries) -- "Arrival" -- 11/15/09
Yeah I didn't think it was bad. The fact that it's all airing over 3 nights makes it easier to jump into even if it does end up being crap.
But all I really expect of The Prisoner is a bit of a mind fuck, and this was, so I'm happy for now.
But all I really expect of The Prisoner is a bit of a mind fuck, and this was, so I'm happy for now.
#10
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#11
Re: The Prisoner (AMC miniseries) -- "Arrival" -- 11/15/09
The apparitions of 2 towers in the desert, a not so thinly veiled incorporation of the World Trade Center into the story.
#13
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Prisoner (AMC miniseries) -- "Arrival" -- 11/15/09
As a long-time fan of the original, I was disappointed in the first two episodes. The quality of the writing and the dialogue are not remotely comparable to the classic version. They also seem to have changed the inherent characterization of 6. The new 6 is apparently not as clever or well-planned as the original. It seems the main new element added to the story is the idea of terrorism and how its possibility would affect the populace. A very derivative idea from current times, considering the 60's show is one of the most groundbreaking shows of all-time with its subversive themes.
#14
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Prisoner (AMC miniseries) -- "Arrival" -- 11/15/09
I've only watched the first ep so far. Sightly disappointed for the reason I stated in my spoiler above, that by having everyone be brainwashed/have amnesia they take away a lot from the original, especially from Number 6. I still don't know exactly where they are going though, so I can't really judge.
#16
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The Prisoner (AMC miniseries) -- "Arrival" -- 11/15/09
As a long-time fan of the original, I was disappointed in the first two episodes. The quality of the writing and the dialogue are not remotely comparable to the classic version. They also seem to have changed the inherent characterization of 6. The new 6 is apparently not as clever or well-planned as the original. It seems the main new element added to the story is the idea of terrorism and how its possibility would affect the populace. A very derivative idea from current times, considering the 60's show is one of the most groundbreaking shows of all-time with its subversive themes.
I love Ian McKellan and think he makes a fine No. 2, but at the same time, I miss the revolving door of No. 2s. I'll stick with it since there are only a couple more nights. At least it's not a total loss; the original probably wouldn't have been released on Blu-ray this soon had it not been for this remake.
#17
#18
Member
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 111
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Prisoner (AMC miniseries) -- "Arrival" -- 11/15/09
God help these people if Patrick McGoohan comes back from the dead. For those who have never seen the original, this has done a huge disservice to the original.
Starting the show off with a teaser that looked like Planet Of The Apes Visit Iraq was just silly. Providing a backstory with disjointed flashbacks did nothing to help matters. Demonstrating that an intelligence operative is one step removed from a graffiti artist was just bizarre. 2 comes off as a well paid drug pusher. Is the logo for the Village someone giving us the finger?
This is what everyone feared and their fears were correct. It's easy to see that for the next five years those involved with this fiasco will hear one question repeated over and over, "What were you thinking?".
Starting the show off with a teaser that looked like Planet Of The Apes Visit Iraq was just silly. Providing a backstory with disjointed flashbacks did nothing to help matters. Demonstrating that an intelligence operative is one step removed from a graffiti artist was just bizarre. 2 comes off as a well paid drug pusher. Is the logo for the Village someone giving us the finger?
This is what everyone feared and their fears were correct. It's easy to see that for the next five years those involved with this fiasco will hear one question repeated over and over, "What were you thinking?".




