The episode I was referring to was The Omega Glory.

So, here you go:

Brothers
Captive Pursuit
Equinox
First Contact
For The Uniform
Friday's Child
Patterns of Force
Star Trek Insurrection
The Apple
The Enterprise Incident
The episode where Worf's step-brother transports a village in the Holodeck
In a Mirror, Darkly
The Voyage Home
The Wrath of Khan
The Omega Glory
Justice
Where No Man Has Gone Before
Who Watches The Watchers

Go nuts.

The Enterprise Incident, In a Mirror, Darkly, The Voyage Home, The Wrath of Khan are all wrong.

We'll just assume my answer is correct.

Brannon Braga is a producer on 24. That goes a little way toward redeeming him.

I am surprised people know that the Voyage Home is wrong. That's a tricky one.

in a mirror darkly is incorrect. the empire had no prime directive.

First Contact is wrong too. The future was changed by the Borg (no Prime Directive) by the time they interfered with Earth's past.

Agreed. Also agreed on First Contact.

Good. I consider Brothers and Captive Pursuit to be wrong as well.

I don't see how Where No Man Has Gone Before is right either.

I don't either.

Isn't the Prime Directive just about not interfering with the natural evolution of a culture? Not necessarily about altering timelines, and such?

OK, I'd love to stay and debate every episode where the Prime Directive is mentioned, but I have a lovely half-human/half-Betazoid waiting for me, so I'll check in later.

I tend to agree, but even on the timeline theory, Voyage Home and First Contact fail.

Quit bringing up First Contact. It shouldn't even exist. Riker, Geordie, and Cochran are just red spots on the back of Phoenix.

Okay, I think we've reached some consensus.

WallyOPD: Brothers
kvrdave: Captive Pursuit
FatTony and Fist of Doom: First Contact
feenst: The Enterprise Incident
brainee: In a Mirror, Darkly
Jimmy James, the big train, Scrumtrulescent: The Voyage Home
Groucho: Where No Man Has Gone Before

are all wrong.

Pics or it didn't happen.

Luckily this wasn't a high-match round.

Uniques (-5)

JasonF: Equinox
reverie: For The Uniform
achau9598: Friday's Child
wendersfan: The Apple
wmansir: The episode where Worf's step-brother transports a village in the Holodeck
RKillgore: TOS episode with the Yangs and Kohms

Patterns of Force (3)

Red Dog
Damfino
The Bus

Star Trek: Insurrection (4)

Palaver
Nogura
gmanca
Tracer Bullet

Justice (2)

wishbone
Rockmjd23

I am off to memory prime.