2 answers left. Which nut-job is the most popular?

Maverick


William "Sugar-tits" Wallace

Standings

01 → Imprint : -48
02 → Merkin Muffley : -43
03 → lvbob : -38
04 → Kal Varnsen : -31
05 → Rockmjd23 : -29
06 → bmoney1023 : -28
07 → dvdhook : -26
07 → The Bus : -26
09 → sauce07 : -24
10 → the big train : -23
11 → Watoozyman : -22
12 → kenbuzz : -17
12 → macnorton : -17
14 → maxfisher : -16
15 → Scrumtrulescent : -14
16 → Red Dog : -13
17 → pinata242 : -12
18 → dhmac : -11
19 → Goat3001 : -10
20 → wishbone : -8
21 → achau9598 : -5
22 → Damfino : -4
23 → Thor Simpson : 6
24 → DVDChris : 10
25 → reverie : 16

Ok, ladies(?) and gentle(?)men. This is where I need to take a break for a bit and for good reason. This next question is going to be a clusterfuck.

Question 18. R: South Park is not without permanent casualties. Name one. (No redshirts or passerbys allowed. It doesn't have to be a signficant, recurring character, but it should have some impact overall).

No, you know what? Fuck that. Let's do this.

But I want to tell you all right now that my rulings are based on research and episode viewing. My answers are final unless you can use the lunch hour to convince me otherwise. Without further ado...

There ain't no comin' back! This is the really real world!

<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/3h7rNYJ424w&hl=en&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/3h7rNYJ424w&hl=en&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>

Question 18. R: South Park is not without permanent casualties. Name one. (No redshirts or passerbys allowed. It doesn't have to be a signficant, recurring character, but it should have some impact overall).

First up, the acceptable answers.

Ms. Crabtree (3)
Damfino
DVDChris
Rockmjd23

Really? I thought it was fairly straight forward. The key words being 'Permanent casualties'. I think I know what might be coming!

Ms. Choksondik (2)
Kal Varnsen
Scrumtrulescent

Dr. Marvin Monroe!

Mrs. Tenorman (2)
pinata242
Red Dog


Also, I received the following answer from Watoozyman, but never got clarification. Since it's more than 1 character I have to disqualify it:
Mr/Mrs. Tennorman

Unfortunately I don't know what it's worth yet.

Along with "Bleeding Gums" Murphy he was never a popular character.

We have 1 acceptable unique and it is currently worth a whopping -10 points. That may change based on upcoming debates, but right now the cheese stands alone.


Dr. Katz (-10)
wishbone

It's Mr/Mrs. Tenorman chili though.

Now for the would-be-unique-but-for-the-question results.

Yeah, but it's more than one casualty. And other people picked a specific one.

Hokeyboy's anus is quivering in anticipation.

Gregory Yardale - I can find no reference to him actually dying, but I didn't watch the movie to confirm.
sauce07


Kurt Russell - He went through the portal and got raped. No confirmation that he actually died from what I saw.
lvbob


Mitch Connor - He said he took a cyanide pill and "blew away", but then Cartman admitted to Kyle that it was all a ruse. Therefore Mitch Connor never existed.
kenbuzz


Mr. Twig - He was repaired and he and Garrison mutually parted ways when Mr. Hat showed back up.
macnorton


Saddam Hussein - He's been seen mostly in the afterlife, true, but he did reappear as the guy controlling the Prime Minister of Canada and was captured on Earth. I daresay that's not permanent.
Merkin Muffley


Steven Spielberg - He died when the re-cut RotLA was shown, but he came back in The China Probrem and didn't die.
bmoney1023

And in what I believe is a Reverse Sheep first, the most popular answer is incorrect.

Chef
achau9598
dhmac
dvdhook
Goat3001
Imprint
maxfisher
reverie
the big train
The Bus
Thor Simpson

Mitch Conner... fooled you kinda!

I watched this episode twice last night. He was brought back with a pulse and resurrected as "Darth Chef".

As of right now Chef is incorrect.

Bus, I need a ruling on what that does for scoring. Is it still "most popular + 1"? Making it (and all the other incorrects) worth 11?