I just remembered that we had one of these threads last year, so I thought I'd start one for this year.

Here are my rankings (I will update as I see more):

A+:
Battlestar Galactica
The Shield
Breaking Bad
Lost
Big Love

A:
Sarah Connor Chronicles
Fringe
Friday Night Lights
Chuck
Mad Men
Dollhouse
Life
Reaper
Damages
Scrubs
Psych

A-:
Supernatural
24
Life on Mars
Southland
Dexter
Pushing Daisies
House
30 Rock

B+:
HIMYM
It's Always Sunny
The Sarah Silverman Program
The Office
Burn Notice

B:
True Blood
Weeds
Parks and Recreation
Flight of the Conchords
Party Down
Prison Break

B-:
In Treatment
CSI
The Closer
Entourage

C:
United States of Tara

D:
Heroes

F:
Bones

HAVEN'T SEEN:
Ashes to Ashes
Better Off Ted
Harper's Island
Kings
Reno 911
The Unusuals

Cream of the Crop:

Terminator: TSCC A-

Good:

FRINGE B
Dollhouse B
HOUSE B-

Meh:

The Office C+
LOST C

At Least It's Not Smallville:

Smallville Presents Television Abominations:

Smallville F

Haven't Seen:
24
Reaper
Survivor
Parks & Recreation
Harper's Island
Pushing Daisies

PLUS some more that won't be seen until DVD/BD!

Saving Grace was good.

Good:

Friday Night Lights
Chuck
Fringe

A
B
Lost
30 Rock

B-
Damages

C
D
F

A. Chuck, Better Off Ted
B. Lost, Scrubs, 30 Rock
C. The Office
D.
F. Heroes (F stands for "fuck this show")

Haven't watched yet: Parks & Recreation

Heroes B+

30 Rock B

Parks & Recreation A-

I will rate SNL and Simpsons later once the finales air.

I only watch 5 shows and feel inferior now.


can I rate the Super Bowl since it was a finale for football season?

would that be a threadcap?

C because the Steelers now have 6 trophies and lead all the franchises

Holy shit. Please tell me you DVR all of these shows to watch on rainy days.

Anyway, uh, Battlestar Galactica & Lost were great, while Damages was slightly disappointing yet still highly entertaining. Oh, and Nip/Tuck blew.

Only the ones that I have seen so far. I think it's a little hokey to do A+, A or A-......A, B, C etc is easier to judge these by.


A:
CSI: NY
Battlestar Galactica
The Shield
Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles
Burn Notice
Chuck
Friday Night Lights
Sons of Anarchy
Prison Break

B:
The Unit
The Amazing Race
Leverage
Life
House
Fringe
Boston Legal

C:
Nip/Tuck
Heroes

D:


F:

Incorrect. The Unusuals still has 4 more episodes left. It returns May 27th.

Better off Ted has 13 episodes in the can, but only 7 have aired. The remaining 6 are going to sit and gather dust on the shelf unless it gets a 2nd season.

With much of this year's TV wrapping up, I would love to see das make another of his top 50 episodes threads.

Ok, thanks. I didn't know The Unusuals had a few more to go. I knew BOT had 13 episodes done, but I wasn't sure if any official announcement had been made regarding its fate (my fingers are still crossed for it to get picked up, easily my favorite new show this season).