DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/552620-lost-whatever-happened-happened-4-1-09-a.html)

DJariya 04-01-09 03:24 AM

Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
<a href="http://s110.photobucket.com/albums/n104/djariya/?action=view&current=Lostcast.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://i110.photobucket.com/albums/n104/djariya/Lostcast.jpg" border="0" alt="Lost Cast"></a>

Synopsis:

Spoiler:


Kate tries to save Ben's life---and takes drastic measures to do so---when Jack refuses to help. Meanwhile, Kate begins to tell the truth about the lie in order to protect Aaron. Cassidy: Kim Dickens.


pinata242 04-01-09 09:24 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Preview of my review: LOVED IT!

Achtung 04-01-09 09:46 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Been a long time since I've been this excited about an episode of Lost. Mostly because of last week's ending... also because I'm now unemployed and have little else to look forward to. :p

rfduncan 04-01-09 09:55 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Oh yeah! :bdance:

dx23 04-01-09 10:07 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Can't wait!!!

Raul3 04-01-09 10:08 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 9361909)
preview of my review: Loved it!

qft

cdoug57 04-01-09 10:12 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Can't wait.

Doug

zuffy 04-01-09 10:15 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Can't wait! hehe

Spoiler:
I was listening to a podcast and I heard that Sawyer's old gf is back. Maybe Kate went to visit her and gave Aaron to her?

Merkin Muffley 04-01-09 10:24 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
With a title like that, it sounds like we might be getting into some time travel theory. In other words...nice try, Sayid. Now you've gone and done it.

cracksky 04-01-09 11:08 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
I really hope we get these answers (this episode):

1. What happens before and after Daniel is seen at the Orchid?
2. Does Daniel tell Charlotte not to come back to the island?
3. Does Daniel actually leave the island? Via time travel or submarine?
4. Have Daniel's theories about time travel changed since actually traveling?

One thing about Ben. Assuming Ben cannot die (because he didn't), what if, instead of a simple bullet, he was chopped up into bits with an axe or dissolved with acid. How then could he survive or be brought back by the island?

stevevt 04-01-09 11:26 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 

Originally Posted by cracksky (Post 9362270)
Assuming Ben cannot die (because he didn't), what if, instead of a simple bullet, he was chopped up into bits with an axe...

You mean your axe that just broke? Good luck with that.


Originally Posted by cracksky (Post 9362270)
...or dissolved with acid.

I assume you're talking about the cauldron of acid over there -- you know, the one Gilligan accidentally dumped a bunch of NaOH* into.

Etc.

*It's a strong base, according to Google.

The Bus 04-01-09 11:33 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
I'd heard a rumor that a few eps of Lost had been leaked online. As in, as-yet-unaired episodes. Any truth to that?

Raul3 04-01-09 11:35 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Reading the Game thread I was wondering something....

What if
Spoiler:

Aaron is Jacob? :jawdrop:

GenPion 04-01-09 11:49 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 

Originally Posted by Raul3 (Post 9362361)
Reading the Game thread I was wondering something....

What if
Spoiler:

Aaron is Jacob? :jawdrop:

Who knows. Anything is possible on Lost, right? I think Jacob will turn out to be
Spoiler:
The Island as an actual entity


So did some people already see this episode? That would be crazy if true...

madcougar 04-01-09 11:56 AM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 

Originally Posted by GenPion (Post 9362413)
Who knows. Anything is possible on Lost, right? I think Jacob will turn out to be
Spoiler:
The Island as an actual entity


Spoiler:
Hmmm... this reminds me of a character in Neil Gaiman's Sandman. So I guess what I'm saying is... it's been done.

Gizmo 04-01-09 12:04 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 

Originally Posted by The Bus (Post 9362354)
I'd heard a rumor that a few eps of Lost had been leaked online. As in, as-yet-unaired episodes. Any truth to that?

April Fools!!!!!!!!!11111111111

rfduncan 04-01-09 12:37 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Ugh. Its bad enough you all have that same avatar without posting all the spoilers. :lol:

d2cheer 04-01-09 01:00 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 

Originally Posted by rfduncan (Post 9362619)
Ugh. Its bad enough you all have that same avatar without posting all the spoilers. :lol:


So who is this hero that everyone appears to be worshipping with that very cool avatar???

GenPion 04-01-09 01:42 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 

Originally Posted by madcougar (Post 9362437)
Spoiler:
Hmmm... this reminds me of a character in Neil Gaiman's Sandman. So I guess what I'm saying is... it's been done.

I still think it will happen. We'll see.

PopcornTreeCt 04-01-09 02:26 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Please bring back Faraday and/or Desmond.

GenPion 04-01-09 04:13 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 

Originally Posted by PopcornTreeCt (Post 9362977)
Please bring back Faraday and/or Desmond.

Tonight or soon... I really hope so. I miss both those characters appearances. I'm sure they play a big role in the episodes to come though. There's no way they can't.

JuryDuty 04-01-09 04:56 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 

Originally Posted by Merkin Muffley (Post 9362108)
With a title like that, it sounds like we might be getting into some time travel theory. In other words...nice try, Sayid. Now you've gone and done it.

I think so, too. I think they're going to reaffirm the theory that they cannot change the past and anything that happened in the past due to them being there had already happened.

GenPion 04-01-09 07:09 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
I can't wait for Lost to start tonight!

But I guess I have to.

cracksky 04-01-09 07:52 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
This just popped into my head. What if they try to save Ben but he dies anyway then Smokie drags him away into the Temple and brings him back to life. Maybe we'll finally see inside that place.

The Bus 04-01-09 07:55 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 

Originally Posted by cracksky (Post 9363751)
This just popped into my head. What if they try to save Ben but he dies anyway then Smokie drags him away into the Temple and brings him back to life. Maybe we'll finally see inside that place.

We have already. It's

Spoiler:

one of the DHARMA stations... DUN DUN DUN!

The Bus 04-01-09 08:18 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Nice BTTF reference. :lol:

aktick 04-01-09 08:41 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Hurley and Miles have me :lol:.

"A-ha! You can't shoot me!"

Snowmaker 04-01-09 08:41 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Love the whole confusing time travel conversation. Glad to see the show can poke fun at itself. :lol:

dsa_shea 04-01-09 08:56 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Wouldn't Claire's mom have known that Claire was pregnant when she left for L.A. (the island)? Kate basically told her that Claire was pregnant when they crashed which Claire's mother should have known. Am I wrong here?

rfduncan 04-01-09 09:00 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Why can't more American television be this AWESOME?!?!?!? -eek-

RichC2 04-01-09 09:00 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 

Originally Posted by dsa_shea (Post 9363855)
Wouldn't Claire's mom have known that Claire was pregnant when she left for L.A. (the island)? Kate basically told her that Claire was pregnant when they crashed which Claire's mother should have known. Am I wrong here?

Yes, but the mom thought Claire and the baby died in the crash.


Originally Posted by rfduncan (Post 9363865)
Why can't more American television be this AWESOME?!?!?!? -eek-

I didn't like their "He'll lose his innocence" bit. Made me think morphine drip and hookers.

Sean O'Hara 04-01-09 09:02 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
I think that's the first time in his life that Ben's been scared.

DthRdrX 04-01-09 09:04 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Richard's awesome. He basically told that grunt to go tell Widmore and Ellie that he doesn't care what they say.

Odd though, I guess this means Widmore and Ellie are pretty close heh? How did she get as much, if not more, power than Richard? I wonder if she's Penny's mother?

ATX 04-01-09 09:05 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
wow

so Jacob rebirthed Ben and Richard didn't get permission from Widmore and Ellie hmm...

and Ben waking up to John was great

and Hurley and Miles crack me up

DthRdrX 04-01-09 09:08 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Well, Richard brought Ben to the Temple. We don't know what connection, if any, the Temple has with Jacob.

MoviePage 04-01-09 09:23 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 

Originally Posted by dsa_shea (Post 9363855)
Wouldn't Claire's mom have known that Claire was pregnant when she left for L.A. (the island)? Kate basically told her that Claire was pregnant when they crashed which Claire's mother should have known. Am I wrong here?

Claire's mom was in a car crash (with Claire) and as a result was in a coma when Claire left for L.A.

scorpion 04-01-09 09:26 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Hurley and Miles' conversation was the highlight of the night for me. rotflrotflrotfl

boogieman03 04-01-09 09:47 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Great conversation with Hurley & Miles.

Damn I love me some Kate, especially future Kate.

Timber 04-01-09 10:00 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
My wife and I have been having almost that exact Miles/Hurley conversation every week this season. She doesn't get it and I do but there are still some things I don't understand.


Was Ellie mentioned? I heard him say Charles but didn't hear Ellie.

Awesome episode, I'm not sure how they're going to top this season.

Shinobi 04-01-09 10:00 PM

Re: Lost -- "Whatever Happened, Happened" -- 4/1/09
 
Another fantastic episode. I liked that they're making Ben's dad a little more three-dimensional, instead of him being just a one-note jerk.

And yes, Kate looked amazing in the supermarket scenes. Loved the tight skirt and high heels. :drool:

I hope we see Smokey next week. The previews seemed to indicate that we may.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:12 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.