mrpayroll

Am I blind and not seeing a thread about this show that started last Thursday?

There were a couple of funny comedians (the one with the big nose was the funniest).

I hate what they've done with the format though. The first season will always be the best, because they got to live together and we saw the funny things that happened.

Bring back Dave Mordal.

Chris

Charlie Goose

You're not blind, it's just that nobody cares enough about the show. Past winners haven't exactly gone on to greater fame.

Although the hillbilly from last season was in the recent Harold & Kumar movie.

I don't know if I'll get into the show again this season.

Charlie Goose

Well, they went from 12 finalists to 10 last night.

Iliza Schlesinger definitely had better material than the Ku girl, and I guess everyone knew it since Ku was challenged by I think 5 others.

That God's Pottery duo is either hit or miss, but those guys stayed in character throughout the whole thing. I wonder if they kept it up when the camera was off too. I'm guessing it was a miss with the crowd, since they had the lowest amount of votes.

Not that ANYONE cares!

wishbone

Iliza has the goods to go pretty far -- and her standup is pretty solid too!

innocentfreak

Iliza was definitely the best of the three and hope she stays around even just for the eye candy. I am a fan of Sean Cullen's from back in his Corky and the Juice Pig days so I will at least keep watching while he is on there.

Patman

Thank goodness Iliza made it through, she's funny to me, reminds me of Tea Leoni in her "Flying Blind" days in the 90's. She sort of goes out of her way to not wear tight-fitting tops, but she'd be rocking in a bikini, as would Sean Cullen...

mdc3000

I'm watching this season, but was pretty pissed that Dan Cummins didn't make the top 12... I don't think Ron G is that funny, so I'm surprised he made it...

Glad Ku and God's Pottery went home, Iliza was WAY funnier. My favourites so far are Sean Cullen, Jim Tavare and Paul Foot.

mrpayroll

We lost the eye when Ku left.

But, she wasn't the funniest.

Chris

That'sAllFolks

I TOTALLY agree. To me, Dan Cummins material was among the best (even though his delivery reminded me of another comic that I can't put my finger on - maybe Mitch Hedberg a little). He was way better than the guy who kept talking about "what stays in Vegas ... " I was really surprised he went on to the finals.

I think Ron G was on last year and went on to the final 10 where he was eliminated. I was surpised then as I am now that he went on at all.

I haven't watched Thurs episode yet, but it doesn't surpise me about God's Pottery. You can only take that act so far. I did think Ku might go on a little further. I thought she had better material than Iliza in the semi-finals, but her delivery was not quite as good. But I haven't watched the most recent episode.

What has surprised me is that many of the comics had really good material in the showcase or semi-final rounds, but when they went forward, their material was definately poorer. I guess they have a few really good bits, but when it comes down to it, they will never be a George Carlin or Mitch Hedberg.

I

Charlie Goose

You may be thinking of Ralph Harris.

That'sAllFolks

Thanks, now I remember!

Charlie Goose

So, during the Bed Bath & Beyond prop comedy immunity challenge last night, it was funny how most of the comics crapped all over prop comedy, even after most of them bombed. Carrot Top might not get a lot of respect from "real" comedians, but the guy sells out Vegas every night. And I think he's pretty funny. He definitely picked the right winner in that challenge, the fellow who used props to spoof movies.

Unfortunately, I dozed off toward the end. Who were the 3 on the line, and who stayed?

acubfaninmd

^paul foot, papa cj, iliza

iliza stayed

Charlie Goose

Thanks.

She's going to be awful proud of herself, having knocked off 4 people.

Patman

I was just hoping for more wet t-shirt action (mainly of Iliza) from the carwash sequence. Papa CJ just crapped the bed in the middle of his routine, and Paul was just too nervous and less likable, while Iliza is very relatable and likable, and performs with a good energy level.

Groucho

I like Iliza. It's always refreshing to see a female comic that doesn't focus on relationships and periods. I'm not sure what Foot and CJ were thinking when they picked her, considering her performance last week.

wishbone

She has good observational material -- especially for the young adult crowd -- and she is not afraid to interject physicality and voice work into her stand-up. Even if she does not win I think she will do well for herself.

Barings

Yes, Iliza is the only eye candy left since Esther Ku was eliminated last week. I'll be the first to admit her performances in both eliminations were clearly better than everyone else, but I'm not quite sure how I feel about her. I can't tell if it's the editing or her being the only girl in the house and having to face elimination twice, but there seems to be an undercurrent of insecurity and meanness when she's not performing.

I could see Papa CJ rehashing his material a mile away, but what happened in the middle of his routine. Also Paul Foot seemed like he completely lost it. He was actually my favorite comic of the three based on his dry humour during the Las Vegas auditions.

Barings

Is this show pretty much dead in the water? Looks like the producers were smart to have double (and triple) eliminations each week.

I don't have an opinion on their routines since I'll watch over the weekend, but it looks like the voting may have closed shortly after the airing of the show.

mdc3000

It's because of the Olympics that they sped up the format, no other reason.... I think on the 'reality' bits, Sean Cullen is easily the funniest, but on stage, he's in trouble. I love the Girls Next Door but think they should have picked Iliza - her joke about Cybergirl was hilarious...as a GND fan, I loved all her in references to playboy etc... I'm not sure who I'm rooting for right now, but I can't stand Ron G... he was sort of funny last night, but most of the time...not so much.

Patman

Is Kendra sort of mentally deficient, her laugh was just strange.

Groucho

Not an actual spoiler, but I put it in tags because there's a lot of white space:

JasonF

I like Iliza and Jim Tavare. Louis Ramey isn't bad -- I wouldn't go out of my way to see him, but if I were flipping channels and came across him doing a set, I'd watch. The impressionist guy would be killer if he had some jokes to go with his voices. The guy who looks like Jim from the Office has potential. Ron G, Sean Cullen, and Adam Hunter do absolutely nothing for me.

DRG

Agree totally. Ron G just stretches one-note jokes out... I can't even imagine how repetitive he would be in a half hour set. Whereas Iliza took a chance with untested material, but she had to... the tv voters wouldn't be very forgiving if she'd just repeated the same stuff she did the past two weeks. And her untested 'third-tier' stuff was still better than most of the other contestants' material.

I think Sean Cullen is hilarious offstage, but his humor just doesn't translate to a stage act. And I think eating up your whole routine with a song is a bad idea unless the song absolutely kills, which it didn't.

mrpayroll

It's pretty sad what America accepts as funny these days. Each season seems to get worse and I haven't laughed much this season.

Maybe next year I will get smart and not watch until the finale. I really miss the comics from Season 1 and the format with us watching them live together and have fun.... at Dat Phans expense.

Of course he got the last laugh!

Chris