DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   New Andromeda Strain-Mini-Series A&E (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/532118-new-andromeda-strain-mini-series-e.html)

whotony 06-01-08 10:19 PM

did you really just say "ending was fail"

Neitzl 06-01-08 10:58 PM


Originally Posted by whotony
did you really just say "ending was fail"


Actually, I'm surprised it wasn't described as "epic fail".

I know this, because Tyler knows this.

btw, what a horrible waste of time this was for me. I also can not believe Ridley Scott had anything to do with this. Tony Scott, perhaps, but not Ridley.

Bill Needle 06-01-08 11:43 PM

This reminded me of all of those horrible TV movie-of-the-weeks from the '70s, and not in a good way. It was filled with more cliches than you could shake a stick at, pointless dalogue and characters, phony drama, too many plot holes to count, c-list actors giving d-list performances, and so on and so on... The entire self-destruct of the lab sequence was one giant cringingly bad and amateurish presentation in every imaginable way. The scene where what's his name is being guided by what's her name to the deactivation panel should be submitted to The Hague as a possible crime against humanity.

al_bundy 06-02-08 07:30 AM

watched maybe 20 minutes of it

i read the book years ago and it was pretty good. for the movie the producers and writers decided they needed to tell us again how they hate Bush.

jack999 06-02-08 07:51 AM


Originally Posted by al_bundy
watched maybe 20 minutes of it

i read the book years ago and it was pretty good. for the movie the producers and writers decided they needed to tell us again how they hate Bush.

I presume you are talking about the A&E production and I don't get at all where this movie is anti Bush (and I hate Bush). Movies have had their conspiracy plots long before Bush.

One plot point I missed was why was Andromeda sent back from the future?

Rocketdog2000 06-02-08 01:21 PM


Originally Posted by jack999
One plot point I missed was why was Andromeda sent back from the future?

Oh, it ended up being a rip from Star Trek 4:The Voyage Home, where what they needed to fight/cure the threat in the future could only still be found in the past - because of course, by that time (the future) we stupid humans had unwittingly trashed our natural resources in the pursuit of other gains.

In this case, it was the strip mining of the volcanic ocean vents, which is where the "Bacterium Inferno" was to be found -the only thing that seemed to kill Andromeda. They (presumably our future population), sent it back to the current time because it still existed in our time. We hadn't yet - but were on the course to- destroy it with the mining. Oh, that silly little bacteria couldn't possibly be of some important future use - we need those mineral ores now more than anything else.

Bandoman 06-02-08 02:59 PM


Originally Posted by Bill Needle
The scene where what's his name is being guided by what's her name to the deactivation panel should be submitted to The Hague as a possible crime against humanity.

rotfl :up:

GradVT06 06-02-08 03:09 PM


Originally Posted by Rocketdog2000
Oh, it ended up being a rip from Star Trek 4:The Voyage Home, where what they needed to fight/cure the threat in the future could only still be found in the past - because of course, by that time (the future) we stupid humans had unwittingly trashed our natural resources in the pursuit of other gains.

In this case, it was the strip mining of the volcanic ocean vents, which is where the "Bacterium Inferno" was to be found -the only thing that seemed to kill Andromeda. They (presumably our future population), sent it back to the current time because it still existed in our time. We hadn't yet - but were on the course to- destroy it with the mining. Oh, that silly little bacteria couldn't possibly be of some important future use - we need those mineral ores now more than anything else.

I suppose they could have sent a videotape from the future explaining this, completely with video footage, historical records indicating what will happen (ie, exact scores of ballgames, xxxx will die on xxxxx day, etc) along with a sample of the virus so it could be contained and tested in the past (ie, present day). But no, that would have made for a better movie than this.

Rocketdog2000 06-02-08 06:13 PM


Originally Posted by GradVT06
I suppose they could have sent a videotape from the future explaining this, completely with video footage, historical records indicating what will happen (ie, exact scores of ballgames, xxxx will die on xxxxx day, etc) along with a sample of the virus so it could be contained and tested in the past (ie, present day). But no, that would have made for a better movie than this.

1- Too simple of a solution, and it takes away most of the mystery aspect.

2- Who's to say they are even still using videotape in the future? Or, maybe vidoetape wouldn't have survive the journey. It's also possible that whatever they are using to record data on in the future - like the casing used to send back the Andromeda sample, perhaps - wouldn't work in the here and now. Remember, they said the technology used design and build that was way ahead of where we were at now, where it's only in the theoretical stage.

Again, this whole tangent they went off on to try and explain where Andromeda came form just made the story worse, and not better, or more interesting in my book. Yet another reason why the original is superior.

Brian Shannon 06-04-08 07:21 AM

Just got around to watching the first 2hr part last night.

All I can say is, WOW!

How could they take such a great story and make that piece of :crap: ?

I guess I will watch the second two hours for laughs but this was a really, really bad show.

AGuyNamedMike 06-04-08 11:03 AM

I agree that this low-rent rehash would've been better left unmade. It's a shame too, as I dug the cast mostly and think a different story with this crew would've been pretty good cheesy fun.

DJariya 06-06-08 04:19 AM

This miniseries was a big disappointment. I wonder if anyone actually bought the DVD that just came out a week after it aired.

The thumb scene with Daniel Dae Kim was hilarously bad TV.

I was honestly bored for most of the 4 hours as the core actors were just sitting in that damn basement.

I did not understand the final scene where Justin Louis and Andre Braugher were killed. What the hell was that about??

ultimaton 06-06-08 06:38 AM


Originally Posted by Bill Needle
It was filled with more cliches than you could shake a stick at

Spot on. I was honestly surprised they showed enough "restraint" not to have the super computer go rogue and attempt to kill everyone with surgical lasers, etc.

God this was a royal P.O.S.

sandman642 06-06-08 02:59 PM

I finally got around to taking a look at this last night...I lasted maybe an hour before I hit the DELETE button. Not good.

And was I the only one singing "Car Wash" while the Wildfire team was going through their bubbly decontamination?

Pistol Pete 06-22-08 08:46 PM


Originally Posted by atxbomber
Spot on. I was honestly surprised they showed enough "restraint" not to have the super computer go rogue and attempt to kill everyone with surgical lasers, etc.

God this was a royal P.O.S.

Minor book spoiler:
Spoiler:

To be fair in the book there were automated tranquilizer guns in the core. As the hero climbed the core he was hit with darts. He fought sleep as he struggled to turn off the autodestruct.

Also in the book the air was evacuated from the facility 30 seconds or so before the explosion to "increase the efficiency".


I did miss the robo-doc in this version. Instead of a musical montage of people taking showers they could have shown the interaction between the scientists and the automated medical robot. That was one of the more prescient parts of the book, particularly the speech recognition problems.

mikehunt 08-26-08 06:38 PM

just got around to watching it
wasn't bad, but the unshielded reactor was a joke
and there was a lot of extra political shit that did nothing for the plot

mikehunt 08-26-08 06:45 PM


Originally Posted by DJariya (Post 8730341)
I did not understand the final scene where Justin Louis and Andre Braugher were killed. What the hell was that about??

all part of the stupid conspiracy theory shit they threw into the movie

mikehunt 08-26-08 06:56 PM

I thought Rick Schroeder didn't want to be called Ricky anymore?
yet he's in the credits as Ricky

bboisvert 08-27-08 03:46 PM


Originally Posted by mikehunt (Post 8898029)
I thought Rick Schroeder didn't want to be called Ricky anymore?
yet he's in the credits as Ricky

Apparently, now that he's actually starting to look old, Ricky isn't quite as unappealing as it once was. ;)

I don't know the answer, but I noticed that too.


Man, this thread just brought up bad memories of this mini. I have no clue why I sat through the whole thing... I guess I was just *hoping* it would get better. It didn't. :mad:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:01 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.