Original Desmond

And remember to Spoiler tag as necessary

ok

The Office - B-
Supernatural - A
Smallville - C-
My Name is Earl - C+

JPRaup

These are the only shows I watch/will watch:

The Office - A
30 Rock - B+
Scrubs - F (I know it wasn't supposed to be the season finale, but it was an awful episode in general)
Dexter - B+
It's Always Sunny in Philly - A-
Lost -

Aegean2007

Damages - A
Curb Your Enthusiasm - A
Dexter - B+
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia - A-
Heroes - C
Life - B+
Pushing Daisies - A-
Chuck - A-
Friday Night Lights - A-
Prison Break - B+
The Sarah Connor Chronicles - A-
Ashes to Ashes - A
South Park (mid-season) - A-
30 Rock - A
Scrubs - D
Survivor - B+
House Part I - A
My Name is Earl - B
The Office - A+
Lost Part I - A
CSI - B
SNL - C (Japanese Office - A)
Aliens in America - B+
How I Met Your Mother - A-
House Part II - A+
Reaper - B+
Ugly Betty - B
Lost Parts II and III - A++
Battlestar Galactica (mid-season) - A+

The Best:
Drama - Lost, Runner-up - House and Battlestar Galactica
Comedy - The Office

MechanicalMan

30 Rock - B
The Simpsons - B
King of the Hill - B
House - B
SNL - B-
American Dad - C+
The Office - C
Reaper - C-
ER - D

Lost (This will get an "A")

zekeburger1979

The Office - A+
My Name is Earl - A
Scrubs - C-
House Part I- A
Heroes - A
Life - A
House Part II - A+
The Simpsons B+
How I Met Your Mother - A-

Others I plan on watching:
The Big Bang Theory


I realize it looks like I'm easy on the shows, but I was very impressed with the season finales. Each show had episodes during the course of the season that weren't great, but almost all of the shows finished strongly.

DJariya

Heroes: B-
Supernatural: A
Smallville: C-
Jericho (Series Finale): B-
Lost Part I: A
Brothers & Sisters: B-
House Part I: A
House Part II: B+
Shark (Series Finale): B+
Moonlight (Series Finale): B-
Bones: B-
CSI: B+
CSI: Miami: B-
CSI: NY: B- (last year's was better)
Lost Part II: A+++++
Grey's Anatomy: B+
One Tree Hill: C+
Gossip Girl: B+
Without a Trace: C
Criminal Minds: A-
Desperate Housewives: A

hardercore

The Office: B+
Lost (Part One): A
Desperate Housewives: A-
Grey's Anatomy: B
Lost (Part Two): A+

DarkestPhoenix

The Office - A
Lost - (Will likely be an A...so many forces converging...)
Smallville - D- (I'm feeling generous)
Battlestar Galactica - (Is next week the finale?)
My Name is Earl - B
Heroes - C

Arthur Dent

HOUSE A
LOST A
Curb Your Enthusiasm A-
Pushing Daisies B+
The Office B+
Law & Order B
Reaper B-
Survivor C+
Smallville F

Hrm, feels like I watch a lot more TV. Everything else I pretty much wait to watch on DVD, I guess.

Original Desmond

gotta add

Jericho B
Heroes B-

Original Desmond

bump it up

SuperBatMan

Smallville- D
The Office- B
Lost- C(so far)

hdtv00

Bones- A+
Smallville- F
The Office- B+
Jericho- B
House- B+
How I Met Your Mother-
The Big Bang Theory
ER

RichC2

30 Rock - B+
Damages - B
The Simpsons - D+
LOST (Part I) - B+
LOST (Part II) -
How I Met Your Mother - B
House (Part I) - B+
House (Part II) - A-

rfduncan

You mean the episode that aired back in November?

I think the best one I saw was Reaper. Totally an A.

GradVT06

Damages- A
Big Bang Theory- B
How I Met Your Mother- B
House- B+
NCIS- A+
Criminal Minds- A
Lost-
Numb3rs- A

B.A.

The Office and Reaper are the only ones that I remember being top-notch.

Damfino

The Office: A+
Battlestar Galactica: A
Lost: A
Everybody Hates Chris: B+
My Name is Earl: B
30 Rock: B
Heroes: B
How I Met Your Mother: B-
Desperate Housewives: B-
Saturday Night Live: D+
Scrubs: F- (good show, but I really hated this episode. I'm glad I'm not alone)

FatTony

30 Rock: A
The Office: B+
Heroes: C
Scrubs: F- (and that's being generous)
Lost: (if part 1 was any indication, this will likely get an A at minimum)

Typing this out, I just realized I hardly watch any TV anymore.

pridesticks06

Same here. And I forgot about Heroes

The Office: A-
Heroes: C+ (And I can hardly even remember it to be honest)
The Big Bang Theory: B
How I Met Your Mother: B+

That's all I really watch anymore.

DJariya

Just caught up with the Bones, CSI: Miami and Criminal Minds finales tonight. Updated my post.

Original Desmond

How i met your mother B-
One Tree hill C+
Paradise Hotel C

zekeburger1979

Updated my list with House, The Simpsons and How I Met Your Mother. All that's left is The Big Bang Theory.

Deadpool

Supernatural - A+
The Office - A
House - B
Heroes - C-
Smallville - D

Arthur Dent

I finally got around to Smallville and Reaper and updated my post accordingly. Smallville was terrible, as expected, while Reaper was good.