Jericho---"Oversight"---3/4/08
#26
DVD Talk God
Originally Posted by Jimmy James
I just went back and looked at the map of the 25 sites. They make far too little sense if you think about it. You don't need to nuke Chicago and then waste one of your 25 on Indianapolis. You don't need to nuke both Columbus and Pittsburgh, particularly when you are also hitting Detroit. Worse than those geographic issues is the lack of any bombs in a contiguous 8 state belt from Virginia (which, I grant, would feel a heavy impact from the DC nuke) down to Louisiana. If nothing else, you ditch Indy and bomb Memphis just to contaminate more area.
That may be crap, but it was a thought.
And....that was a great episode. Pisses me off that people would rather watch crappy dancing, people opening boxes, crappy singing, etc. over good original programming.
#29
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 1,385
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Philadelphia
Hey, all. I'm new to these threads, as I just got caught up on Jericho last weekend. Fantastic show (which is going to be all the more frustrating if they cancel it again after I've invested the time), but still and all, I'm glad I put in the effort.
I will miss the "Town on its own, post-apocalypse, surviving against threats internal and external" aspect, but I am digging the "Two Americas" conspiracy angle, and Hawkins continues to just get more and more badass.
Random thoughts:
Stanley rejoining the rebellion and going all "Hulk Smash" on Ravenwood will be fun.
Is Mrs. Greene no longer on the show?
I have never, and will never be able to buy Dale as the John Connor of the "Visitors."
This show could just be about Jake and Hawkins, with no one else in the town, and I'd still watch it.
As someone else stated - It seems hitting the East Coast was more of a priority. Plus, look at it from this vantage point... While Pittsburgh isn't a very politically important US city, it's still a HUGE producer of Steel for the country... a manufacturing necessity should a war suddenly break out between east and west...
Washington and Philadelphia are symbolic victories (both capitals at one point, both symbols of the birth of the US) As for Indianapolis, well again - as stated previously - that's a city in the west, but not a very important one... nuke it to keep up appearances... as for the belt of states you mentioned... notice a lot of farmland has been left unsullied? This new government is going to need a bread basket, afterall...
Or maybe I'm just looking way too far into this.
Anyway, great show, and I really hope it doesn't get canceled... the peanuts thing probably won't work again, right?
-Doc
I will miss the "Town on its own, post-apocalypse, surviving against threats internal and external" aspect, but I am digging the "Two Americas" conspiracy angle, and Hawkins continues to just get more and more badass.
Random thoughts:
Stanley rejoining the rebellion and going all "Hulk Smash" on Ravenwood will be fun.
Is Mrs. Greene no longer on the show?
I have never, and will never be able to buy Dale as the John Connor of the "Visitors."
This show could just be about Jake and Hawkins, with no one else in the town, and I'd still watch it.
Originally Posted by Jimmy James
I just went back and looked at the map of the 25 sites. They make far too little sense if you think about it. You don't need to nuke Chicago and then waste one of your 25 on Indianapolis. You don't need to nuke both Columbus and Pittsburgh, particularly when you are also hitting Detroit. Worse than those geographic issues is the lack of any bombs in a contiguous 8 state belt from Virginia (which, I grant, would feel a heavy impact from the DC nuke) down to Louisiana. If nothing else, you ditch Indy and bomb Memphis just to contaminate more area.
Washington and Philadelphia are symbolic victories (both capitals at one point, both symbols of the birth of the US) As for Indianapolis, well again - as stated previously - that's a city in the west, but not a very important one... nuke it to keep up appearances... as for the belt of states you mentioned... notice a lot of farmland has been left unsullied? This new government is going to need a bread basket, afterall...
Or maybe I'm just looking way too far into this.
Anyway, great show, and I really hope it doesn't get canceled... the peanuts thing probably won't work again, right?
-Doc
Last edited by Doc MacGyver; 03-07-08 at 12:41 PM.
#31
DVD Talk God
Originally Posted by GizmoDVD
They killed Deaf girl? This show has been canceled.
#32
Guest
Originally Posted by Seantn
I would guess so. It's been averaging the same amount of viewers that it had when they canceled it initially last May.
I really really doubt this will be picked up for another season. Even though they said last night that there are only 3 episodes left this season.
And as sad as the death of the deaf girl was, it will be the rallying point for the town to start fighting back against the corporation / government. The tide has turned.
Chris
#33
DVD Talk Special Edition
it's on at freakin' 10pm...what did they really expect?
great show..love it love it...what a tragedy if it's canceled again...aargh, just wanna rip my hair out and scream to America: WHAT THE F IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE????
great show..love it love it...what a tragedy if it's canceled again...aargh, just wanna rip my hair out and scream to America: WHAT THE F IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE????
#34
DVD Talk Limited Edition
You have to wonder what reaction Cass from JFC will have. She was friends with Bonnie, and she knows the whole thing about Mimi. Or maybe D.B. Sweeney will try to bump her off too.
It's sad that they've made the show so entertaining that I'll actually miss it now. Even though it did get better towards the end of last year I still wouldn't have missed it if hadn't come back. Damn them!
It's sad that they've made the show so entertaining that I'll actually miss it now. Even though it did get better towards the end of last year I still wouldn't have missed it if hadn't come back. Damn them!
#36
DVD Talk God
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 133,147
Received 896 Likes
on
740 Posts
From: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Originally Posted by mwbmis
It's sad that they've made the show so entertaining that I'll actually miss it now. Even though it did get better towards the end of last year I still wouldn't have missed it if hadn't come back. Damn them!
That's the way I feel. I didn't care about the initial cancellation because, frankly, the 1st season wasn't good, and I thought the nerdish nuts campaign was ridiculous. I would have never missed it. Then they brought it back, refocused the show in a very entertaining way, and threw it in a shitty timeslot so it would underperform to justify its ultimate execution just to fuck with me.
#37
Thread Starter
DVD Talk God
The problem is that most of the hardcore fans who sent in the nuts don't have the Nielsen box. I've visited the CBS forum for Jericho and noone there has the box.
#38
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 6,457
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Southside Virginia
It's not a problem involving who has the box. It's statistical modeling. It's not perfect, but it's better than any other system for how much it costs.
The problem is that the public as a whole chooses to watch dreck.
The problem is that the public as a whole chooses to watch dreck.
#39
Thread Starter
DVD Talk God
So what about the 3-5M additional Americans who are indeed watching the show live, but don't own the box. The 5.88M viewers that Nielsen estimated could easily be much more. The system is flawed.....estimating mass viewership from such a small population stinks and hoses alot of good shows like this.
I just read the new press release that said over 1.5M more Americans watched the season premiere of Jericho via DVR which increased viewership to over 8M.
I just read the new press release that said over 1.5M more Americans watched the season premiere of Jericho via DVR which increased viewership to over 8M.
#42
Thread Starter
DVD Talk God
Originally Posted by Red Dog
What is 1.5M DVR viewers added on compared to other shows? Also, why would a network care bout DVR people who are likely skipping commercials?
For all we know, there could be 5M more people watching Jericho on a Bunny ears antenna TV.
It's pretty much if you don't have this fucking box, your viewership and support of the show means jack shit. It also doesn't help when alot of posters in these forums have such a negative attitude to supporting new programs that they refuse to watch it and say...."I'll wait for the DVD and watch season 2."
Last edited by DJariya; 03-05-08 at 08:25 PM.
#43
Member
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 97
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Long Island, NY
How come no mention of other bombs around the world? I thought China was hit as well? There was a reference made about 700 million screaming china men and Jake asked I thought it was a billion and the reply was not anymore.
#44
DVD Talk God
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 133,147
Received 896 Likes
on
740 Posts
From: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Originally Posted by DJariya
The point I am trying to make is there is significantly more people in the United States watching this show than what the Nielsen system leads us to believe and they aren't able to account all of them. I know that the DVR figures mean jack shit to CBS because they aren't watching the commercials.
For all we know, there could be 5M more people watching Jericho on a Bunny ears antenna TV.
It's pretty much if you don't have this fucking box, your viewership and support of the show means jack shit. It also doesn't help when alot of posters in these forums have such a negative attitude to supporting new programs that they refuse to watch it and say...."I'll wait for the DVD and watch season 2."
For all we know, there could be 5M more people watching Jericho on a Bunny ears antenna TV.
It's pretty much if you don't have this fucking box, your viewership and support of the show means jack shit. It also doesn't help when alot of posters in these forums have such a negative attitude to supporting new programs that they refuse to watch it and say...."I'll wait for the DVD and watch season 2."
1) How do you know?
2) Wouldn't this apply to any show? You could make the argument you're making about any show.
#45
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 6,457
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Southside Virginia
Originally Posted by DVD Mike2
How come no mention of other bombs around the world? I thought China was hit as well? There was a reference made about 700 million screaming china men and Jake asked I thought it was a billion and the reply was not anymore.
I do wish they'd give us a little more on the aid drop from China, though.
#46
Member
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 97
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Long Island, NY
If the new government is looking for the bomb to wipe out any evidence that is was an inside job. How do they explain the bomb that did not go off in NYC? The police stopped them from setting it off according to one episode.
#47
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 6,457
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Southside Virginia
Originally Posted by DVD Mike2
If the new government is looking for the bomb to wipe out any evidence that is was an inside job. How do they explain the bomb that did not go off in NYC? The police stopped them from setting it off according to one episode.
#48
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,897
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Orange County, CA
Originally Posted by DVD Mike2
How come no mention of other bombs around the world? I thought China was hit as well? There was a reference made about 700 million screaming china men and Jake asked I thought it was a billion and the reply was not anymore.
#49
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Great episode. Interesting that CBS is touting these upcoming episodes as the last of the season, not the series. I have high doubts that it would return, but hey, weirder things have happened.
#50
Senior Member
Originally Posted by Jimmy James
If I remember right, that line of bull came from the fake army folks who came in on the tank. They were full of shit, and you shouldn't believe anything they said.
I do wish they'd give us a little more on the aid drop from China, though.
I do wish they'd give us a little more on the aid drop from China, though.



