Friday Night Lights -- "Jumping the Gun" -- 1/11/2007
#26
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2000
Posts: 852
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by creekdipper
Hope somebody answers Bluelight's question about the TMU choice. We missed an episode somewhere about the recruiting (mistakenly thought the writers' strike was delaying any new episodes for a while 'cause we thought they had run out of filmed episodes). What is the deal with the coach & Mom seemingly favoring TMU? Are they supposed to have better academics or something? Is it because it's closer to home than some of the other schools?
#27
Banned
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,249
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Sand Point
So the minute Street decides he doesn't want to coach football, he's more or less off the show now. I guess there's not a whole lot left tying him to the show.
Does that mean the minute Smash goes down with a serious injury, she's gonna pull a whipcream bikini on Matt?
Originally Posted by Bluelitespecial
I am kind of creeped out by Smash's girlfriend, because it feels like she is trying to latch onto him because he could be a potential NFL star. Just one question did Smash's mom want him to go to TMU, or was he just waiting to hear from them.
#28
Banned
Originally Posted by Septemberbaby
If you're interested in seeing the missed episode, this season's episodes are available on NBC.com
Incidentally, have they dropped the 'Halftime' recap of the show at 9:30 (EST) for those who come in late (or have ADD)? I can't remember any other shows doing this and noticed that it didn't seem to be there last episode. We sort of joked about it & said that they needed to have a second recap at the end of the show to remind those with short-term memory loss about what they had just viewed.
Maybe some referee can enlighten us as to what would actually have happened had the Coach incident taken place in a real game. Can the officials make a ruling base upon what seemed to be the likely outcome (that Dillon would have scored)? Or would they simply assess a penalty such as 15 yards from the point of the foul or half the distance to the goal or something like that? I mean, when defensive pass interference is called in the end zone, they don't just automatically award a TD. Also, although it's likely that Dillon would have scored (once again!) on the sweep, stranger things have happened in real life. Riggins could have stumbled & fallen or even fumbled the ball (this happened to a local school who lost a state championship when a running back created his own fumble right before he crossed the goal line for the winning score...he was untouched by the other team, but his knee came up & knocked the ball loose and it was recovered by the other team).
**Edit** Just read Red Dog's post re: the automatic TD ruling. I'm confident that Red Dog has officiating experience or the ol' rule book open, so that answers my question about the reality of the scenario as it played out on tv.
Last edited by creekdipper; 01-14-08 at 04:13 AM.
#29
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 1,021
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Columbus, OH
So, are we to assume the entire Larribee student body was attending class at Dillon until their school was repaired? I had thought they were just using the football facilities but we saw them more than a few times (in the cafeteria and the hallway) during school hours. Also, couldn't Larribee just use their middle schools field? Actually, couldn't they use the local park? That whole situation was so unbelievable for me that it took away from the show.
I got a good drinking game. Everytime coach says "let me tell you something" you take a drink.
I got a good drinking game. Everytime coach says "let me tell you something" you take a drink.
Last edited by BDLOU; 01-14-08 at 07:34 AM.
#30
DVD Talk God
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 133,162
Received 898 Likes
on
742 Posts
From: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Originally Posted by creekdipper
**Edit** Just read Red Dog's post re: the automatic TD ruling. I'm confident that Red Dog has officiating experience or the ol' rule book open, so that answers my question about the reality of the scenario as it played out on tv.
I can't speak to HS or college, but that is the NFL rule, so I assume it is the same.
http://www.nfl.com/rulebook/penaltysummaries
Touchdown Awarded (Palpably Unfair Act)
1. When Referee determines a palpably unfair act deprived a team of a touchdown. (Example: Player comes off bench and tackles runner apparently en route to touchdown.)
1. When Referee determines a palpably unfair act deprived a team of a touchdown. (Example: Player comes off bench and tackles runner apparently en route to touchdown.)
#31
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 259
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Red Dog
I can't speak to HS or college, but that is the NFL rule, so I assume it is the same.
http://www.nfl.com/rulebook/penaltysummaries
http://www.nfl.com/rulebook/penaltysummaries
#32
DVD Talk Godfather
Interesting football question: I knew about the automatic TD for outside interference, but I have no idea what happens with the clock. In a situation where the player is clearly going to score a TD, can you tackle the guy from off the field just to get a few precious seconds to have a final drive? I'm sure it'd be universally frowned upon, just wondering.
The weird thing about the Smash/TMU decision, was that I thought the moral of the story was to wait it out, not make a rash decision, and talk it over with mom. Instead, Smash just (verbally) commits without reading the fine print, making a rash, emotional decision. Maybe this comes back to bite him later in the show, but it seems like it resulted in a happy ending.
I also thought that Smash's gfriend was latching onto him and secretly wanted to recruit him somewhere specific, but she didn't seem to mind that he committed to TMU.
I have no problem with them jettisoning some of the extra characters, or even focusing on a few characters at a time.... that's much better than trying to fit everyone in and having the main plots go at a snail's pace. It's probably cheaper for them too, to not have every one of the main cast in every episode... I believe they did this with shows like Veronica Mars in the past too.
I also liked that they wrapped up the Coach vs. Riggins thing within one episode... I thought that would drag on for a while longer.
The weird thing about the Smash/TMU decision, was that I thought the moral of the story was to wait it out, not make a rash decision, and talk it over with mom. Instead, Smash just (verbally) commits without reading the fine print, making a rash, emotional decision. Maybe this comes back to bite him later in the show, but it seems like it resulted in a happy ending.
I also thought that Smash's gfriend was latching onto him and secretly wanted to recruit him somewhere specific, but she didn't seem to mind that he committed to TMU.
I have no problem with them jettisoning some of the extra characters, or even focusing on a few characters at a time.... that's much better than trying to fit everyone in and having the main plots go at a snail's pace. It's probably cheaper for them too, to not have every one of the main cast in every episode... I believe they did this with shows like Veronica Mars in the past too.
I also liked that they wrapped up the Coach vs. Riggins thing within one episode... I thought that would drag on for a while longer.
#33
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by creekdipper
I read a comment from a viewer in TV Guide asking what had happened to the show...seems that she was complaining that the show was being 'dumbed down' to appeal to a larger audience (which isn't working, according to the low ratings). While I know there's no 'moral victories' in cancellation (to borrow a sports phrase), it would still seem nobler to be remembered as a great show that will become a cult classic, cancelled-before-its-time favorite than to try too hard to please everybody and end up with the same fate.
Originally Posted by creekdipper
Taylor's advice to Smash regarding the TMU/Alabama choice was a little strange, I thought.
Originally Posted by BDLOU
So, are we to assume the entire Larribee student body was attending class at Dillon until their school was repaired? I had thought they were just using the football facilities but we saw them more than a few times (in the cafeteria and the hallway) during school hours. Also, couldn't Larribee just use their middle schools field? Actually, couldn't they use the local park?
Last edited by rfduncan; 01-15-08 at 02:46 PM.
#34
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 1,021
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Columbus, OH
[QUOTE=rfduncan]
I guess I'm OK with them using the facilities but is Dillon one of those rare high schools where they are half full and could accept the entire Larribee high school to attend class there as well? Or is it only football players that are attending class at Dillon? It's just a lazy premise to create conflict.
Originally Posted by creekdipper
I read a comment from a viewer in TV Guide asking what had happened to the show...seems that she was complaining that the show was being 'dumbed down' to appeal to a larger audience (which isn't working, according to the low ratings). While I know there's no 'moral victories' in cancellation (to borrow a sports phrase), it would still seem nobler to be remembered as a great show that will become a cult classic, cancelled-before-its-time favorite than to try too hard to please everybody and end up with the same fate.[/spoiler]
It is indeed a catch-22. I, for one, would re-watch S1 on DVD in a heartbeat. Doubt I'll buy this season...
You may recall that Taylor was on the coaching staff there just a little while ago, right? I think he's got a genuinely decent insider perspective to counsel Smash in that manner.
Well that is an awful lot of equipment to lug around to a local park, not to mention the additional training equipment on the field (unlikely there's a second set of all that kicking around Dillon).
It is indeed a catch-22. I, for one, would re-watch S1 on DVD in a heartbeat. Doubt I'll buy this season...
You may recall that Taylor was on the coaching staff there just a little while ago, right? I think he's got a genuinely decent insider perspective to counsel Smash in that manner.
Well that is an awful lot of equipment to lug around to a local park, not to mention the additional training equipment on the field (unlikely there's a second set of all that kicking around Dillon).
#35
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by TheBigDave
What the hell has happened to all these other storylines?
Street and the waitress
Street's new apartment
Anything with Lyla
Street and the waitress
Street's new apartment
Anything with Lyla
** DON'T CARE**
** DON'T CARE**
Lyla & Street should have never been back this season. They graduated(should have in Lyla's case) and moved on to college. Both Lyla and Riggin's should have been out of there. It was set up that Street & Riggins were the same age without explicitly saying so. It was just too convenient to ignore and slide by, and bring them back. Riggin's has turned into a decent character though so he gets a pass.
[QUOTE=BDLOU]
Originally Posted by rfduncan
I guess I'm OK with them using the facilities but is Dillon one of those rare high schools where they are half full and could accept the entire Larribee high school to attend class there as well? Or is it only football players that are attending class at Dillon? It's just a lazy premise to create conflict.
Originally Posted by creekdipper
Thought the title was kinda ironic since I commented to my wife that the show had really jumped the shark when the Larribee coach explained his sadism/ingratitude/boorishness/stupidity/etc. by confiding to Taylor about his wife's illness.Not saying that such an event couldn't cause behavioral changes, but his team didn't seem to notice any difference in him, so it's logical to conclude that he was always a jerk.
The only problem I had with the episode was the drug money. That to me was lazy writing and will, no doubt, provide a moronic side plot for another episode or two. UNLESS, after the pep-talk with Coach praising Tim for being so honest and trustworthy, he decides to return the money. That's the only reasonable ending to that story I want to see.
#36
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
** DON'T CARE**
** DON'T CARE**
** DON'T CARE**
** DON'T CARE**
** DON'T CARE**
I tend to agree with you.
Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
The only problem I had with the episode was the drug money. That to me was lazy writing and will, no doubt, provide a moronic side plot for another episode or two. UNLESS, after the pep-talk with Coach praising Tim for being so honest and trustworthy, he decides to return the money. That's the only reasonable ending to that story I want to see.
#38
Banned
Regarding the drug dealer, maybe Julie will get messed up on drugs at a party & Riggins will rescue her & take her home and put her in bed & Eric will come in & catch them &.....
Wait a minute.
Incidentally, I loved Lunatikk's suggestion for getting rid of the seniors. Then Eric can resurrect the program & the series can be retitled, "We Are Dillon!" (Apologies to Thundering Herd fans...not making light of the real-life tragedy, just Hollywood marketing schemes).
For Street fans, maybe he can return as a drug-dealing pimp...after all, he's got the perfect pimp name. And Lyla can be his top girl.
If Buddy weren't Lyla's dad, he could be Street's top john (especially since Mrs. Garrity has declined his offer to reconcile).
Just floating some alternative plots out there since it doesn't seem like anything is off the table for this season.
Wait a minute.
Incidentally, I loved Lunatikk's suggestion for getting rid of the seniors. Then Eric can resurrect the program & the series can be retitled, "We Are Dillon!" (Apologies to Thundering Herd fans...not making light of the real-life tragedy, just Hollywood marketing schemes).
For Street fans, maybe he can return as a drug-dealing pimp...after all, he's got the perfect pimp name. And Lyla can be his top girl.
If Buddy weren't Lyla's dad, he could be Street's top john (especially since Mrs. Garrity has declined his offer to reconcile).
Just floating some alternative plots out there since it doesn't seem like anything is off the table for this season.
Last edited by creekdipper; 01-15-08 at 05:59 PM.
#39
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
The only problem I had with the episode was the drug money. That to me was lazy writing and will, no doubt, provide a moronic side plot for another episode or two. UNLESS, after the pep-talk with Coach praising Tim for being so honest and trustworthy, he decides to return the money. That's the only reasonable ending to that story I want to see.
Dealer commits crime
Uses gun
Ditches gun
Police find gun
Dust gun for prints
Find Riggs prints
Made up story about how Riggs was arrested for something stupid like being drunk and printed so they were on file
Riggs arrested
Charged with crime
Kept in jail
Lyla visits him
They somehow kiss
Lyla vows to fight for him
Miraculously finds exculpatory evidence
Riggs is released at halftime of must win Panther game
Panthers come from behind
Riggs is hero
Street still angry about not playing quad rugby.
#40
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by DVD Josh
Mike, that side plot is REAL easy to spot:
Dealer commits crime
Uses gun
Ditches gun
Police find gun
Dust gun for prints
Find Riggs prints
Made up story about how Riggs was arrested for something stupid like being drunk and printed so they were on file
Riggs arrested
Charged with crime
Kept in jail
Lyla visits him
They somehow kiss
Lyla vows to fight for him
Miraculously finds exculpatory evidence
Riggs is released at halftime of must win Panther game
Panthers come from behind
Riggs is hero
Street still angry about not playing quad rugby.
Dealer commits crime
Uses gun
Ditches gun
Police find gun
Dust gun for prints
Find Riggs prints
Made up story about how Riggs was arrested for something stupid like being drunk and printed so they were on file
Riggs arrested
Charged with crime
Kept in jail
Lyla visits him
They somehow kiss
Lyla vows to fight for him
Miraculously finds exculpatory evidence
Riggs is released at halftime of must win Panther game
Panthers come from behind
Riggs is hero
Street still angry about not playing quad rugby.




