DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Heroes -- "Powerless" -- 12.03.2007 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/518991-heroes-powerless-12-03-2007-a.html)

Snowmaker 12-03-07 09:06 PM


Originally Posted by Goldberg74
So... now the question that plagues us is...

WHO SHOT NP?

Looked like HRG to me. That was probably the deal he made.

Too bad Peter didn't think to give Nathan some of his blood.

dpz301 12-03-07 09:07 PM


Originally Posted by TheNightFlier
So my guess is
Spoiler:
HRG
shot Nathan.

Spoiler:
strong possibility since he was used to stop claire too. probably made some sort of deal to get out and is 'under' bob's control.

Rogue588 12-03-07 09:09 PM

I'll have to go back and watch it again, but it looked like "future" Pete (or the one with the black jacket) was walking out of the press conference when Matt looked up..

Bah. Whatever. This ep was kinda weak. Hiro leaving Adam buried alive guarantees he'll be back after he finishes clawing his way to the top. Does anyone really care that Monica was rescued? For that matter, does anyone really care that Nikki is presumed dead?

Goldberg74 12-03-07 09:09 PM

I tried to make it as quick as I could...

http://img249.imageshack.us/img249/2...oshotnpne9.jpg

bluetoast 12-03-07 09:16 PM


Originally Posted by Rogue588
I'll have to go back and watch it again, but it looked like "future" Pete (or the one with the black jacket) was walking out of the press conference when Matt looked up..

People on GameFAQs are theorizing that it's HRG who did the shooting, as part of his deal with the company.

Oh yeah and Bob really is an idiot when it comes to password security. Come on, "Midas"? At least that led to Elle saving the gang though.

Jimmy James 12-03-07 09:17 PM

That episode probably got us as close to where we were at the end of the first season as possible. Let's hope they do better the second time around.

I'm not saying this season stank, but it is definitely the lesser of the two seasons the way it stacks up now. I guess NBC left the door open for starting with more episodes this season by just saying the show would be back in 2008.

I think it is pretty likely HRG shot Nathan, but I'd honestly prefer a more creative outcome. Perhaps Peter brought Nathan back from the future and Nathan killed himself. Yeah, I like that. :)

Rogue588 12-03-07 09:19 PM


Originally Posted by Jimmy James
Perhaps Peter brought Nathan back from the future and Nathan killed himself. Yeah, I like that. :)

:lol: Now that would be original.

Oh wait...no it wouldn't.

But, yeah, I would expect Kring & Co. to have it be Noah. It just looked to me like Peter. :shrug:

Also, now that the virus is "destroyed", where does that leave Pete's Irish lass?

PopcornTreeCt 12-03-07 09:23 PM

Great ending. I doubt Nikki and Nathan will end up dead. Sad to see it end.

Some more thoughts...Is Bob the entire company?

And I was really hope to see Elle fry her father but alas we'll have to wait till next season.

Snowmaker 12-03-07 09:25 PM


Originally Posted by Rogue588
Hiro leaving Adam buried alive guarantees he'll be back after he finishes clawing his way to the top. Does anyone really care that Monica was rescued? For that matter, does anyone really care that Nikki is presumed dead?

Doesn't Adam at least need oxygen to live?

And we knew Monica (AKA Black Black Cat) would survive. The picture of her on the cover of the comic book (that Isaac seems to somehow still create) shows her with that dagger we saw in the vault.

Jimmy James 12-03-07 09:26 PM


Originally Posted by Rogue588
:lol: Now that would be original.

Oh wait...no it wouldn't.

It wouldn't be original, but it would give us a glimpse into how the show regards time travel. Would future Nathan disappear? Die? Would he even be able to accomplish the goal?


Also, now that the virus is "destroyed", where does that leave Pete's Irish lass?
That's the really funny part about all of this to me -- I imagine she's just gone. Say what you will about Adam, but unleashing the virus was the most likely way for Peter to achieve his stated goal of finding and saving his Irish girlfriend.

I imagine we'll never hear about her again.

wildcatlh 12-03-07 09:26 PM

Did anyone else notice... when Peter destroyed the virus, the Company symbol was visible in the ashes in his hand?

Goldberg74 12-03-07 09:27 PM

1. What happens when Adam runs out of air?

2. Is the effect of the blood temporary? If they get hurt again, will it not cure them again? Is it not enough of a transfusion?

3. Sylar : Spinach Can :: Magneto : Chess Piece

Snowmaker 12-03-07 09:28 PM


Originally Posted by Goldberg74
3. Sylar : Spinach Can

Yeah, the Popeye theme started going through my head.

bluetoast 12-03-07 09:28 PM


Originally Posted by wildcatlh
Did anyone else notice... when Peter destroyed the virus, the Company symbol was visible in the ashes in his hand?

Yeah, and I felt it was the worst usage of the symbol yet. I can accept how it coincidentally appears all over the place throughout the world, but it magically appears when Peter uses nuclear radiation on a vial?

vegasbaby 12-03-07 09:29 PM


Originally Posted by Geddlo
Is that Hitler's brain in the jar?

No. It was Abby Normal's brain.

Snowmaker 12-03-07 09:34 PM


Originally Posted by vegasbaby
No. It was Abby Normal's brain.

http://img212.imageshack.us/img212/8...achmentxn2.jpg

vegasbaby 12-03-07 09:38 PM

That's IGOR (Not EEgor).

JuryDuty 12-03-07 09:58 PM


Originally Posted by Goldberg74
1. What happens when Adam runs out of air?

2. Is the effect of the blood temporary? If they get hurt again, will it not cure them again? Is it not enough of a transfusion?

3. Sylar : Spinach Can :: Magneto : Chess Piece

All my thoughts exactly. Though I was thinking for #1--What happens when Adam starves of hunger or thirst?

7Keys 12-03-07 10:03 PM

Peter's Sly Stallone mouth was distracting during the final scene with Nathan.

Overall, the season was mostly boring, too many characters, too many bad storylines, too many plot holes (even in the couple of good storylines), and very predictible at times. So, thumbs down.

Patman 12-03-07 10:07 PM

Way to bungle yourself into a rescue, Elle. What a hero you are becoming.

Sean O'Hara 12-03-07 10:09 PM

Way to go Nathan. You want to expose the truth about super-heroes to the world, so you began with a long, rambling preamble that makes no sense to anyone watching. Why not fly in, have Peter materialize beside you, and Parkman ... uh, make Cokie Roberts do a pole dance.

And really, how dead can he be. Peter just has to cut himself and dribble some blood in his mouth.

dvd182 12-03-07 10:21 PM

The body walking away at the end looked a little too slender to be Noah.

Also, what was up with the incredibly soft halves of the picture whenever they did an over the shoulder interview shot, mostly in the Company compound at the beginning, but later on as well. It was really out of focus and didn't look good at all.

About Adam's death being similiar to the ending of another show:
Spoiler:
Alias.


Edit: Well, "death" in an "he's out of the way, for the time being" sense.

bluetoast 12-03-07 10:24 PM


Originally Posted by Sean O'Hara
Way to go Nathan. You want to expose the truth about super-heroes to the world, so you began with a long, rambling preamble that makes no sense to anyone watching. Why not fly in, have Peter materialize beside you, and Parkman ... uh, make Cokie Roberts do a pole dance.

Now this is what should have happened!

Doughboy 12-03-07 10:25 PM


Originally Posted by Rogue588
Also, now that the virus is "destroyed", where does that leave Pete's Irish lass?

She's asleep on her front porch waiting to be woken by Marty....errrr, Peter. ;)



Originally Posted by JuryDuty
All my thoughts exactly. Though I was thinking for #1--What happens when Adam starves of hunger or thirst?

I guess it's like when Angel got buried at sea by Conner at the end of Season 3. He can't die, but he'll sure be suffering in the meantime.


As for the episode itself, it was alright. But again, there were massive plotholes. Why was Peter still refusing to read Adam's mind? Why didn't Hiro tell Peter about Adam trying to release the virus back in the late 70's? Why didn't Peter walk through the safe? How exactly is the public still unaware of the existence of gifted people at this point?

I'm also not too keen on the idea of Sylar being the big bad yet again. I hope the ending of this episode is a red herring, cuz his character is completely played out by now. Just kill him already.

dvd182 12-03-07 10:38 PM


Originally Posted by Doughboy
I hope the ending of this episode is a red herring

It is. He will have an accomplice.

http://pics.livejournal.com/evilgrins/pic/002hzdxe

Patman 12-03-07 11:01 PM

No! Not Mr. Muggles! Why? Why?

musick 12-03-07 11:29 PM


Originally Posted by Goldberg74
3. Sylar : Spinach Can :: Magneto : Chess Piece

totally was channeling the Magneto moment but the same could be said for much of the series, not like Pete didn't just do it to the vault moments earlier

I did like the symbolism of the spinach can
spinach = power = Sylar's powers returning to him
now if he makes a comment next season about gladly paying someone Tuesday for a hamburger today then that season will get a thumbs down from me as well

Liver&Onions 12-04-07 12:07 AM


Originally Posted by dvd182
The body walking away at the end looked a little too slender to be Noah.

Also, what was up with the incredibly soft halves of the picture whenever they did an over the shoulder interview shot, mostly in the Company compound at the beginning, but later on as well. It was really out of focus and didn't look good at all.

I seem to remember that in season 1 as well. I find it distracting as well, but I think they feel it gives a comic book vibe or something.

:up: on the episode from me. As cheered when both heroes fell. One out of joy, the other because it caught me off guard and thus became out of joy as well.

asianxcore 12-04-07 12:08 AM


Originally Posted by Goldberg74
3. Sylar : Spinach Can :: Magneto : Chess Piece

True

I do think it's sort of annoying that the writers managed to end Volume 1 and Volume 2 with a Sylar cliff-hanger.

I really liked how they handled the "death" of Kensei/Adam. It could've been overtly flashy with a battle between Hiro or Peter, but it actually turned out to be pretty cool.

Also I was hoping that Maya would die or at least be able to focus her power to a single target. Unfortunately none of those things happened in this episode :)

I was starting to get into the show again. As the OP stated though, it's too bad so much time was wasted to finally get the show on it's feet.

For anyone looking to pick up the Heroes graphic novel, only pick it up if you are a HUGE fan of the show. I picked it up for $30 over the weekend and it barely touches on any of the main character storylines. The only backgrounds we get more information are with Hana (ability to speak through internet from Season 1), a little background (generic) information on Eden and more information on how Linderman and Pa Patrelli know each other. It's definitely worth a read but just be careful before dropping $30.

Sir_Fireboard 12-04-07 12:20 AM


The body walking away at the end looked a little too slender to be Noah.
That's what I thought. It didn't even occur to me that it could've been HRG. But then again, HRG is my favourite character, so I could be being a bit in denial about him possibly having killed Nathan.

Speaking of which, I knew he'd get shot when he was giving that speech. If he stays dead then the writers have big balls, because Nathan's a huge character and one that I thought would be safe.


About Adam's death being similiar to the ending of another show:
I didn't make that connection, but good point.

Shazam 12-04-07 12:23 AM


Originally Posted by dvd182
Also, what was up with the incredibly soft halves of the picture whenever they did an over the shoulder interview shot, mostly in the Company compound at the beginning, but later on as well. It was really out of focus and didn't look good at all.

I can't remember for the life of me what it's called, but it's a specific filming technique. It's used all over ST:TMP.

Anyhoo, I can't believe they brought Sylar back. That sucks giant donkey balls.

Oh, and I cheered when Niki died. The only thing that would've made that scene better is to have had Mika and Monica die with her.

slop101 12-04-07 12:36 AM


Originally Posted by Goldberg74
1. What happens when Adam runs out of air?

2. Is the effect of the blood temporary? If they get hurt again, will it not cure them again? Is it not enough of a transfusion?

3. Sylar : Spinach Can :: Magneto : Chess Piece

Dude, you're putting way more thought into the show than even the writers have.

Shazam 12-04-07 12:39 AM


Originally Posted by Geddlo
Is that Hitler's brain in the jar?

No, that was the brain of the only writer on the show that questioned this season's plot.

shyguy1083 12-04-07 12:43 AM

so technically the only person to die is nikki, yes? i assumed that the two heroes falling = nikki and maya. even though technically maya got resurrected, she did "die" for a short period of time.

and i know it's debatable, but i don't think nathan counts because he should be able to heal since he got adam's blood, right? i know someone earlier questioned whether the tranfusion would be a one-time thing or whether it would last, so i guess the writers have to come up with an answer for that. but i'm assuming it will fall under the latter because i doubt they would kill nathan off.

overall, i thought the ep was pretty good. the whole destroying the virus was kinda anti-climatic. i would've enjoyed a good fight scene between hiro/adam again. i know it technically wasn't intended as a season finale, so perhaps they were storing up the budget for the actual season finale, but i want a big blow-out brawl at SOME point in the show. the little uses of powers here and there are cool, but not really enough.

riley_dude 12-04-07 12:59 AM

They should have killed Sylar. To keep him on just to have him on is a waste. Bring on someone knew instead of us having to deal with him all over again.
Didn't really care for the whole Nathan clip thing but sad to see him go.
Pretty good finale but not great.

CKMorpheus 12-04-07 01:10 AM

I must say it was a better finale than the first season, but man oh man, sometimes you just wanna reach into the TV and slap those characters.

Big Boy Laroux 12-04-07 01:28 AM


Originally Posted by Snowmaker
Doesn't Adam at least need oxygen to live?

i thought the same thing. lack of oxygen would be a pretty serious problem for the brain.

mwbmis 12-04-07 01:41 AM


Originally Posted by shyguy1083
so technically the only person to die is nikki, yes? i assumed that the two heroes falling = nikki and maya. even though technically maya got resurrected, she did "die" for a short period of time.

and i know it's debatable, but i don't think nathan counts because he should be able to heal since he got adam's blood, right? i know someone earlier questioned whether the tranfusion would be a one-time thing or whether it would last, so i guess the writers have to come up with an answer for that. but i'm assuming it will fall under the latter because i doubt they would kill nathan off.

overall, i thought the ep was pretty good. the whole destroying the virus was kinda anti-climatic. i would've enjoyed a good fight scene between hiro/adam again. i know it technically wasn't intended as a season finale, so perhaps they were storing up the budget for the actual season finale, but i want a big blow-out brawl at SOME point in the show. the little uses of powers here and there are cool, but not really enough.

Honestly, I think they left it open ended enough so that there might be no "Heroes" dead. We actually didn't see Nicki still in the building when it blew up, and there are way too many Nathan lives possibilities.

All told it was kind of a waste of a year. Granted the writer's strike didn't help, but it was set up to a whole lot of nothing. Sylar was lame. The two banditos ended up going nowhere. Claire was lame. Peter spent most of the season acting like a moron. The show did get better as the season when along though so I'll keep up with it whenever it comes back.

A-aron 12-04-07 05:25 AM

what hump?

rfduncan 12-04-07 08:05 AM


Originally Posted by Sean O'Hara
And really, how dead can he be. Peter just has to cut himself and dribble some blood in his mouth.

Might have something to do with the cut healing before said "dribble" could occur? :hscratch:


Originally Posted by asianxcore
I do think it's sort of annoying that the writers managed to end Volume 1 and Volume 2 with a Sylar cliff-hanger.

Kind of agree. And while on the subject, in the flashback "Four Months Ago" episode, did we ever find out how Sylar got away from the plaza and ended up in South America? Perhaps it wasn't as important or relevant as the other facts revealed in that episode to tie things together, but who helped him? Maybe I just missed that. Was it the Company as well? :hscratch:

I'm satisfied with this episode if this is the last one until next fall. It wasn't a spectacular arc, but I'd watch the entire thing again if they end up showing the complete "volume" in repeats come January...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:19 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.