Doctor Who Season 3 (BBC) General Discussion Thread
#153
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
A very nice nod to the Doctors of the past in John Smith's journal. 
It's been so long since I've seen the Doctor use "John Smith" (other than this season premiere), I had forgotten it was used all the time by early Doctors.
Completely wild and unlikely, yet interesting, scenario: what if the kid who stole the pocketwatch (and gains all the knowledge and who knows what else of the Doctor) can't handle the overload of what he's gained and "grows up" to be a new Master?

It's been so long since I've seen the Doctor use "John Smith" (other than this season premiere), I had forgotten it was used all the time by early Doctors.
Completely wild and unlikely, yet interesting, scenario: what if the kid who stole the pocketwatch (and gains all the knowledge and who knows what else of the Doctor) can't handle the overload of what he's gained and "grows up" to be a new Master?
#154
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 344
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Michigan
Originally Posted by Chew
A very nice nod to the Doctors of the past in John Smith's journal. 
It's been so long since I've seen the Doctor use "John Smith" (other than this season premiere), I had forgotten it was used all the time by early Doctors.
Completely wild and unlikely, yet interesting, scenario: what if the kid who stole the pocketwatch (and gains all the knowledge and who knows what else of the Doctor) can't handle the overload of what he's gained and "grows up" to be a new Master?

It's been so long since I've seen the Doctor use "John Smith" (other than this season premiere), I had forgotten it was used all the time by early Doctors.
Completely wild and unlikely, yet interesting, scenario: what if the kid who stole the pocketwatch (and gains all the knowledge and who knows what else of the Doctor) can't handle the overload of what he's gained and "grows up" to be a new Master?
#155
Moderator
Originally Posted by Chew
It's been so long since I've seen the Doctor use "John Smith" (other than this season premiere), I had forgotten it was used all the time by early Doctors.
#157
DVD Talk Legend
What a wonderful new episode. Human Nature instantly jumps to #1 in my personal ranking. I don't know how much they've rewritten from the book, but it fits just perfectly into this season with this doctor. Offers some really great Martha bits, and Tennant does a terrific job, getting to show some fresh range with what is essentially a whole new character.
I hope Part Two isn't a let-down. Part Two's have been weak in this overall series, but with this being a book adaptation, we have reason to hope the 2nd half of the adaptation is as solid as the first...
Great acting by all the supporting cast, too. Yeah, it'll be interesting to see how the kid with the watch handles all that knowledge.
I hope Part Two isn't a let-down. Part Two's have been weak in this overall series, but with this being a book adaptation, we have reason to hope the 2nd half of the adaptation is as solid as the first...
Great acting by all the supporting cast, too. Yeah, it'll be interesting to see how the kid with the watch handles all that knowledge.
#158
DVD Talk Limited Edition
I really enjoyed this ep as well. Very interesting and it's great to see the Doctor not be "the Doctor" for a change.
I've been waiting for Martha to get some time to shine and she's been really holding her own in these last few episodes.
And another somewhat noobish Doctor Who question. Could someone provide a bit more information on the Doctor's reincarnations? Are there only a limited amount of times he can come back? Are the forms he takes what other time lords looked like? And if he can always come back, doesn't that kind of take away from his danger since his essence can't really die?
I've been waiting for Martha to get some time to shine and she's been really holding her own in these last few episodes.
And another somewhat noobish Doctor Who question. Could someone provide a bit more information on the Doctor's reincarnations? Are there only a limited amount of times he can come back? Are the forms he takes what other time lords looked like? And if he can always come back, doesn't that kind of take away from his danger since his essence can't really die?
Last edited by boredsilly; 05-30-07 at 08:16 AM.
#159
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 1,707
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Florida
Originally Posted by boredsilly
And another somewhat noobish Doctor Who question. Could someone provide a bit more information on the Doctor's reincarnations? Are there only a limited amount of times he can come back? Are the forms he takes what other time lords looked like? And if he can always come back, doesn't that kind of take away from his danger since his essence can't really die?
Every Time Lord has 13 regenerations. Then he's dead for good. So whenever he has a life threating injury... gets poisoned, body gets old, ect, he can change his form. However, if his body is completely destroyed, like caught in a nuke explosion, gets his head cut off or something like that, he's dead. It's not magic.
Here's how each Doctor in the past has "died"...
1st to 2nd - Old Age
2nd to 3rd - forced to give up a life by the Time Lords
3rd to 4th - biten by alien spider
4th to 5th - falls off a radio tower
5th to 6th - poisoned
6th to 7th - hits his head on the TARDIS controls (yeah, lame)
7th to 8th - gunshot wounds
8th to 9th - never explained
9th to 10th - oh... you know... Rose and the time energy or whatever.
... I need to get out more... lol
#160
Cool New Member
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 44
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The Doctor can regenerate twelve times. After that, there's no more (unless of course the writers say so). His appearance is completely different that his other incarnations. His personality is quite different each time as well, although he maintains a strong sense of justice, an insatiable curiosity, and a deep affection for humans.
Even though he can die and come back, regeneration is not something the Doctor takes lightly, as the process might not work. Even if it does, he is a completely different person, so that incarnation of him would 'die'. When he occasionally mentions his previous incarnations, it's usually wistful and sad, like he's remembering the death of an old friend.
Even though he can die and come back, regeneration is not something the Doctor takes lightly, as the process might not work. Even if it does, he is a completely different person, so that incarnation of him would 'die'. When he occasionally mentions his previous incarnations, it's usually wistful and sad, like he's remembering the death of an old friend.
#162
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by turborobb
Every Time Lord has 13 regenerations. Then he's dead for good. So whenever he has a life threating injury... gets poisoned, body gets old, ect, he can change his form. However, if his body is completely destroyed, like caught in a nuke explosion, gets his head cut off or something like that, he's dead. It's not magic.
Here's how each Doctor in the past has "died"...
1st to 2nd - Old Age
2nd to 3rd - forced to give up a life by the Time Lords
3rd to 4th - biten by alien spider
4th to 5th - falls off a radio tower
5th to 6th - poisoned
6th to 7th - hits his head on the TARDIS controls (yeah, lame)
7th to 8th - gunshot wounds
8th to 9th - never explained
9th to 10th - oh... you know... Rose and the time energy or whatever.
... I need to get out more... lol
Here's how each Doctor in the past has "died"...
1st to 2nd - Old Age
2nd to 3rd - forced to give up a life by the Time Lords
3rd to 4th - biten by alien spider
4th to 5th - falls off a radio tower
5th to 6th - poisoned
6th to 7th - hits his head on the TARDIS controls (yeah, lame)
7th to 8th - gunshot wounds
8th to 9th - never explained
9th to 10th - oh... you know... Rose and the time energy or whatever.
... I need to get out more... lol
#163
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Ok, thanks guys. There are still aspects about the Who mythos that I'm not quite sure about, but this thread has helped me out quite a bit.
Now I'm curious to see what they do to explain away the 12-13 generations business when that comes around if at all.
Now I'm curious to see what they do to explain away the 12-13 generations business when that comes around if at all.
#164
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by boredsilly
Ok, thanks guys. There are still aspects about the Who mythos that I'm not quite sure about, but this thread has helped me out quite a bit.
Now I'm curious to see what they do to explain away the 12-13 generations business when that comes around if at all.
Now I'm curious to see what they do to explain away the 12-13 generations business when that comes around if at all.
#165
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by boredsilly
Now I'm curious to see what they do to explain away the 12-13 generations business when that comes around if at all.
#166
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by riley_dude
It's been years so maybe someone can correct me if I am wrong but The Master ended up stealing a body when he ran out of Regenerations.

Release date: 06/05/07.
#168
Moderator
Originally Posted by boredsilly
Now I'm curious to see what they do to explain away the 12-13 generations business when that comes around if at all.
#170
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 10,800
Received 84 Likes
on
51 Posts
From: Building attractions one theme park at a time.
Originally Posted by Groucho
I'm curious to see if they remember "The Valeyard" (basically an evil version of the Doctor that somehow appears between his 12th and 13th regenerations).
BWAAA HAAA HAAA!!!!
The Valeyard is an amalgamation of the darker sides of the Doctor's nature. He somehow comes into being between the Doctor's 12th and "final incarnation" (Notice, they didn't say "13th incarnation").
Originally Posted by riley_dude
I think what happened with the 6th to 7th Regeneration was because they fired Colin Baker and couldn't get him back for a regeneration so they just had someone with a Wig on face down on the floor. 

Originally Posted by turborobb
3rd to 4th - biten by alien spider
Just a quick geek correction: The Third Doctor regenerated because his cells were destroyed by the radiation in the Spider Queen's crystal cave. Basically, radiation poisoning.
Last edited by The Valeyard; 05-30-07 at 02:49 PM.
#175
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 2,751
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: In a Academy Award nominated film
Originally Posted by riley_dude
Just saw Human Nature. Probably the best of this season. Can't wait for the second part.
after what he did to the family.



