DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Mulitple TV cameos- same show/different characters? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/492513-mulitple-tv-cameos-same-show-different-characters.html)

Tommy_Harn 02-14-07 11:34 AM

Mulitple TV cameos- same show/different characters?
 
While watching "Seinfeld" DVD's and TBS re-runs over the past couple weeks, my wife and I noticed that Christa Miller (Jordan on "Scrubs") appeared in the show twice, playing different characters. She plays the woman who confronts George for touching her after his interview to be a bra salesman, and, IIRC, one of Jerry's girlfriends. Technically, they could be the same character. However, IMDB lists two different character names:

- The Doodle (1995) TV Episode .... Paula
- The Sniffing Accountant (1993) TV Episode .... Ellen

Did this happen other times during Seinfeld's run (other than with the use of Larry David's voice)? Did/Does it happen with other shows?

And, does it bother you when shows do this?

Turd Ferguson 02-14-07 11:44 AM

Garrett Dillahunt did it in "Deadwood". He played Wild Bill's killer and George Hearst's agent. I think he did a damn fine job on both.

Dr. Henry Jones, Jr. 02-14-07 11:44 AM

many, many times on Law & Order. Sometimes with a guest star who later becomes a series regular. Ice-T was first a drug dealer and then a cop. The police captain on the regular show was a witness or something before. I just remember she was a real bitch.

MrX 02-14-07 11:49 AM

Jerry Orbach was a defense attorney before he was Lennie

Diane Neal played a woman who raped a male stripper with 2 of her friends on SVU before she was Casey Novak

McHawkson 02-14-07 12:12 PM

James Cromwell has multi characters in Star Trek TNG series - so does another actor/actress.

Harry Morgan (well known as Col. Potter in MASH), he first appeared in MASH as Major General Steele 2 years before he joined MASH as main character as Potter.

Red Dog 02-14-07 12:17 PM


Originally Posted by MrX
Jerry Orbach was a defense attorney before he was Lennie

Diane Neal played a woman who raped a male stripper with 2 of her friends on SVU before she was Casey Novak


Annie Parisse played a stripper in a previous episode before her run as ADA Borgia on L&O.

For Law & Order, it's actually harder to find repeat guest-stars who play the same character. :lol:

Doughboy 02-14-07 12:19 PM

Would you count Shawn Ashmore appearing in Smallville as a freak of the week before his twin brother Aaron was cast as Jimmy Olson in Season 6?:)

Red Dog 02-14-07 12:21 PM

Star Trek TOS -

William Campbell: The superbeing (brat) Trelane and Klingon Captain Koloth (in TOS and DS9).

Mark Lenard: Romulan Commander in Balance of Terror and Sarek in Journey to Babel (and 3 of the movies and a couple episodes in TNG). He also played the Klington captain at the beginning of ST:TMP.

GuessWho 02-14-07 02:04 PM

THE BRADY BUNCH:

The prospecter that locked them up in the ghost town and Mike's boss who played pool against bobby were both played by Gilligan's Island's Thurston Howell.

RobCA 02-14-07 02:17 PM

June Gable had a recurring role on Friends as Joey's agent, Estelle, and
she also played a nurse in the season 1 episode, "The One with the Birth".

Rob

dcprules 02-14-07 03:57 PM

What about Paul Rudd on Friends? I think he was another character for an episode or two prior to when he came on regularly as Phoebe's eventual husband.

dvd182 02-14-07 04:12 PM

The college TA on Veronica Mars played the janitor in the season before.

chowderhead 02-14-07 04:24 PM

There was a thread on this a long time ago.
Anyway, as I recall,

Ted McGinley played the imaginary husband of Peggy, Norman Jablonsky in the It's a wonderful Life parody episode on Married with Children. He came back a few years later as Jefferson D'Arcy.

Giovanni Ribisi played someone who dropped a condom in Phoebe's guitar case in The One with the Baby on the Bus on Friends and then came back to play Phoebe's half brother.

KingFunk 02-14-07 04:27 PM

Jon Lovitz played 3 separate characters on "NewsRadio". The first being "Fred" whom Bill McNeal befriends in a mental institution(Season 3). He returned in Season 4 to play a suicidal man who threatens to jump off the WNYX building. Finally, he shows up as Max Lewis, Bill McNeal's replacement, to finish out the show in season 5.

Nabalab 02-14-07 06:28 PM

Rachel Dratch on "30 Rock" immediately came to mind.

GoldenJCJ 02-14-07 08:26 PM


Originally Posted by McHawkson
Harry Morgan (well known as Col. Potter in MASH), he first appeared in MASH as Major General Steele 2 years before he joined MASH as main character as Potter.

and let's not forget Mako who played about a half dozen characters throughout the years...everything from Korean to Chinese to American.

dstrauss 02-14-07 08:50 PM

Wayne Alexander played a number of different characters on Babylon 5, and there are probably half a dozen actors who have played multiple aliens/creatures on the various Trek and Whedon-verse series.

nateman 02-14-07 09:08 PM

This isn’t exactly on topic but munch from Law & Order: SVU plays the same character as he did on Homicide: life on the street, Ned Beatty & Michael Michele who also starred on Homicide appeared as guest stars on L&0:svu as different people which fucks everything up.
The episode was directed by former ER cast member Eric La Salle who played Michael Michele’s love intrest on ER starting in Season 6 of ER.



wiki,
He has recently directed and made a cameo in an episode of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit.
Eric also made a guest starring role in without a trac (it was a really good episode)


Ted McGinley played the imaginary husband of Peggy, Norman Jablonsky in the It's a wonderful Life parody episode on Married with Children. He came back a few years later as Jefferson D'Arcy.
i guess they thought fans wouldn't remember at the time, i saw that on the dvds cause i did start watching MWC on tv till season 7.

Giantrobo 02-14-07 09:36 PM


Originally Posted by McHawkson
James Cromwell has multi characters in Star Trek TNG series - so does another actor/actress.

Not Cameos but following have played different characters in multiple TREK shows and movies. I'msure there are more actors who've don this on Star Trek shows but I think these are the big ones. If you dig deeper some have even done different character voicework for videos games. I guess teh cool thing about these is the fact that they didn't just play different humans, they played different races. :lol:

<b>Majel Barrett</b>
Computer Voice
Christine Chapel
Deanna Troi's Mother

<b>Jeffery Combs</b>
Commander Shran
Weyoun

<b>Gary Graham</b>
Vulcan Ambassador Soval
Tanis

<b>Tony Todd</b>
Adult Jake Sisko
Kurn

1998Nole 02-14-07 11:05 PM

Adam Goldberg
Friends-as Eddie-Chandler's crazy roomate when Joey moved out
Joey-as Jimmy-Joey's best Friend from High School

JZ1276 02-15-07 12:18 AM

Joe Gannascoli in Sopranos
S1 - Guy in the pastry shop
s2 or s3-s06-Vito

Drexl 02-15-07 07:39 AM

It happened another time on Seinfeld. Suzanne Snyder was a neo nazi in the limo in one episode, and then later Jerry's date (the woman who wanted him to eat the pie) in "The Pie."

Chew 02-15-07 08:03 AM


Originally Posted by Giantrobo
<b>Jeffery Combs</b>
Commander Shran
Weyoun

Just because I'm a big fan of Combs' Trek work, here's a bunch more:

Krem
Penk
Brunt
Tiron
Officer Mulkahey

I think Vaughn Armstrong even beats out Combs for the number of Trek characters he's played.

Tscott 02-15-07 12:22 PM

Frank Adamo appeared on 24 episodes of the Dick Van Dyke Show, each time as a different character. A few of his more memorable rolls were as Usher, Dry Cleaning Man, Delivery Man, Partygoer and Headwaiter. He was Dick Van Dyke's assistant and stand-in.

Bill Idelson played Herman Glimscher, Sally's boyfriend, on five episodes of the Dick Van Dyke Show, then played the bellhop in the 4th season episode "Never Bathe on a Sunday".

Lucy Lawless played a different character on Hercules before she was cast for the 3 episode arc that would launch her into Xena.

Sean Gunn, who plays Kirk on Gilmore girls was "Mick" the handyman, then an unnamed delivery man in early episodes. I think it was his 3rd appearance where he got the name Kirk.

GuruTwo 02-15-07 02:09 PM

A lot of this goes on in the Ten Thirteen shows but the "big one" is that Nicholas Lea played a one-off character in "Gender Bender" in the first season of "The X-Files" prior to appearing as Alex Krycek in seasons 2-9.

Giantrobo 02-15-07 06:14 PM


Originally Posted by Chew
Just because I'm a big fan of Combs' Trek work, here's a bunch more:

Krem
Penk
Brunt
Tiron
Officer Mulkahey

I think Vaughn Armstrong even beats out Combs for the number of Trek characters he's played.



Cool! I knew he did tons of stuff but I was too lazy to look for everything he did. :lol:

devilshalo 02-15-07 07:43 PM

Vito Scotti - Gilligan's Island

mikehunt 02-15-07 08:21 PM


Originally Posted by Giantrobo
Not Cameos but following have played different characters in multiple TREK shows and movies. I'msure there are more actors who've don this on Star Trek shows but I think these are the big ones. If you dig deeper some have even done different character voicework for videos games. I guess teh cool thing about these is the fact that they didn't just play different humans, they played different races. :lol:

<b>Majel Barrett</b>
Computer Voice
Christine Chapel
Deanna Troi's Mother
<b><u>Capt. Pike's first officer</u></b>

<b>Jeffery Combs</b>
Commander Shran
Weyoun
<b><u>Brunt</u></b>
<b><u>I think the announcer in the Voyager episode with The Rock</u></b>

<b>Gary Graham</b>
Vulcan Ambassador Soval
Tanis

<b>Tony Todd</b>
Adult Jake Sisko
Kurn

added a couple roles

Kurtwood Smith also had a role on Voyager and was the president in ST6
Renee notgonnatrytospellhislastname played Colonel West in ST6 and Odo
Michael Dorn played what is assumed to be Worf's grandfather or great grandfather in ST6
Patricia Tallman had a few ST roles
Tim Russ played what looked to be a regular human, I think on the Enterprise B in Generations and was one of the terrorists stealing trilithium in an episode of TNG

Almost any long lasting show ends up with lots of these as the directors and producers end up liking a particular actor so they keep bringing them back
At least in ST they can make them different aliens and hide in.
Cromwell for example played a lot of roles that I didn't immdediately recognize as being him

TheStoicPaisano 02-15-07 09:53 PM

Archie Kao played a casino security guy (or whatever you call the guys who watch the eye-in-the-sky feeds) before moving into the video tech spot at CSI.

I remember the character's name being on his shirt in his debut episode, and it certainly wasn't Johnson, which is his name at CSI.

Eplicon 02-15-07 10:24 PM

Anne Baxter appeared in the '60s Batman series, first as a magician named Zelda, and in the third season, played Olga, Queen of the Cossacks.

Ron Glass appeared on "Sanford and Son" as a card shark who swindles Lamont, and later as an ex-con. Another is Margueritte Ray, who played Fred's cousin's wife and also a prospective tenant for the Sanford Arms apartment. The show tended to re-use a lot of the same actors in various bit parts.

brainee 02-15-07 11:00 PM

Jeffrey Tambor had several roles on Three's Company (he's credited with 4 different characters, one of which joined the spin-off "The Ropers" cast). Three's Company did this a lot. Not all are well-known, but you see the same faces pop up over and over again.

Rene O'Connor was one character in Hercules, then became Gabrielle when Xena was spun off from it.

josepotato 02-16-07 07:06 PM

Nero Wolfe is the best example I can think of.

Red Dog 02-16-07 07:10 PM


Originally Posted by brainee
Jeffrey Tambor had several roles on Three's Company (he's credited with 4 different characters, one of which joined the spin-off "The Ropers" cast). Three's Company did this a lot. Not all are well-known, but you see the same faces pop up over and over again.


I remember 2: his 'Ropers' character and the one where he played a shrink. I don't doubt that he played a couple other guest characters.

brainee 02-19-07 05:43 PM


Originally Posted by Red Dog
I remember 2: his 'Ropers' character and the one where he played a shrink. I don't doubt that he played a couple other guest characters.

I also remember a couple where he played this rich obnoxious guy who was trying to get Cindy to marry him. There may have been another character thrown in there too :)

Cusm 02-20-07 01:23 PM


Originally Posted by nateman241
This isn’t exactly on topic but munch from Law & Order: SVU plays the same character as he did on Homicide: life on the street.


Actually Detective John Munch may have the title of most cameoed character. Here is all I can remember.

Homicide: LotS
Law & Order (Homicide cross overs)
X-Files
The Beat
Law & Order: SVU
Law & Order: Trial by Jury
Arrested Development

Drexl 02-20-07 01:39 PM


Originally Posted by Cusm
Actually Detective John Munch may have the title of most cameoed character. Here is all I can remember.

Homicide: LotS
Law & Order (Homicide cross overs)
X-Files
The Beat
Law & Order: SVU
Law & Order: Trial by Jury
Arrested Development

From IMDB's page on Belzer:

He is the only actor to play the same character, Detective John Munch, in eight different series: "Homicide: Life on the Street" (1993), "Law & Order" (1990), "The X Files" (1993), "Law & Order: Special Victims Unit" (1999), "The Beat" (2000), "Law & Order: Trial by Jury" (2005), "Arrested Development" (2003) and "Sesame Street" (1969). He appeared on the latter as a Muppet version of the character in a sketch called "Law & Order: Special Letters Unit". He followed John Ratzenberger and George Wendt, who played Cliff Clavin and Norm Peterson respectively in "Cheers" (1982), "St. Elsewhere" (1982), "The Tortellis" (1987), "Wings" (1990), "The Simpsons" (1989) and "Frasier" (1993).

rfduncan 02-20-07 01:56 PM

This happens on Scrubs quite a bit. For example, Mike Schwartz (also a writer on the show) has played Lloyd, a man with an injured hand, a bed pan delivery man and a patient who got his peeps stuck in a flashlight where the batteries go to name a few.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:21 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.