DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Official Last Comic Standing discussion + Josh's Make-A-Wish (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/465939-official-last-comic-standing-discussion-joshs-make-wish.html)

saoirse 05-31-06 05:34 PM

I don't think the judges are on it once they get in the house. Maybe sooner.

I REALLY do NOT want the lisp girl to stay around. 10 seconds was enough for me.

All in all, a pretty good start for me.

clemente 05-31-06 06:40 PM


Originally Posted by JasonF
There was only one comic I really thought got shafted based on the clips they showed us -- the little 19-year-old girl with the gay dad. I thought she was funnier than a lot of the comics they picked.

I thought she was pretty funny too.
Her and the Cuban guy, it may have just been me, but I liked his style.

JasonF 05-31-06 06:40 PM


Originally Posted by saoirse
I don't think the judges are on it once they get in the house. Maybe sooner.

If it's anything like previous years, that's correct -- the Tonight show guys are in the first episode only. Here's the way it will work, assuming they follow previous years:

From here, they'll have the 40 people who got red tickets do longer acts. They'll have a panel of three or four "celebrity" judges pick ten of those contestants to live in the house. One of the jduges will be Anthony Clark; another will probably be one of the contestants from a previous Last Comic Standing. They may do this over one or two episodes.

At that point, it will be them living in the house and being given various comedy-related tasks (pitch a sitcom about yourself; entertain these kids and they'll vote for who's funniest; etc.). Each episode, the person who loses that night's task will have to challenge one other comic to a face off -- they'll each do a set in front of a live audience in a comedy club, and the audience will pick who gets eliminated.

They'll do that for four or five weeks, then have the remaining comics do longer sets in front of a much larger audience. I can't remember if they let the people at home vote at this point (I think so), but from there, it's strictly a stand-up comedy competition without the reality-show "living in a house together" component.

JasonF 05-31-06 06:42 PM


Originally Posted by clemente
I thought she was pretty funny too.
Her and the Cuban guy, it may have just been me, but I liked his style.

I thought he said "um" too much for a deadpan comic. Deadpan doesn't work if it sounds like you're deadpan because you don't know what you're going to say. But I agree he had some good material, so hopefully over time, he'll develop into a stronger comic.

rocketsauce 05-31-06 06:46 PM


Originally Posted by JasonF
There was only one comic I really thought got shafted based on the clips they showed us -- the little 19-year-old girl with the gay dad. I thought she was funnier than a lot of the comics they picked.

And as usual, they blow two-thirds of their wad in L.A, leaving them with three picks for Chicago and two picks for Miami. Yeah, that makes real sense. I mean, what are the odds you'd find a good comedian in Chicago? -ohbfrank-

last year she was on an episode of Made on MTV. I was really rooting for her. and yeah being from Chicago I was thoroughly dissapointed on how the city got the shaft. Thank God Pardo didn't make it. NY rivals Chicago as the greatest comic city, with LA shagging ass behind because it seems anyone from LA shys away from edgier stuff.

das Monkey 05-31-06 06:50 PM


JasonF

From here, they'll have the 40 people who got red tickets do longer acts. They'll have a panel of three or four "celebrity" judges pick ten of those contestants to live in the house. One of the jduges will be Anthony Clark; another will probably be one of the contestants from a previous Last Comic Standing.

From my TiVo description on last night's episode, it looks like Kathy Griffin, Tim Meadows, and Garry Marshall.

Also, if it's like past years, the "judges" are just there to smile and wave. Final decisions are made by the producers, based on who they think will make for good television and who they already manage, hence Brett Butler and Drew Carey's outrage after people who killed on stage weren't picked and people who died were.

das

magiccmom 05-31-06 06:51 PM

Somehow I think I remember that the "house" is actually a ship this year. The Queen Mary? or something like that...Anyone else hear that?

GuessWho 05-31-06 08:09 PM


Originally Posted by Ravenous
FUCK!! I missed this. I dont watch much TV so I never even saw a commercial for this

Is there ANYWAY to see a rerun of this?

Bravo. Tonight.

calhoun07 05-31-06 09:32 PM

I wish they gave more time to show more of the comics. I know they wanted to condense six cities into two hours, so a lot of cuts had to be made, but there were so many we never heard from, and only a snippet of the better ones.

Jimmy James 05-31-06 09:38 PM


Originally Posted by calhoun07
I wish they gave more time to show more of the comics. I know they wanted to condense six cities into two hours, so a lot of cuts had to be made, but there were so many we never heard from, and only a snippet of the better ones.

Ah, but they couldn't justify packing the house or boat or houseboat or whatever with their hand-picked comics if they actually showed you how good some of the un-annointed are.

NORML54601 05-31-06 10:02 PM

Funniest joke from the whole 2 hours was Josh Blue doing the phone number gag

"don't mix em up baby" rotfl

I loved all of his material, and the guy who told the joke about waving his keys in front of the homeless guy.

Wazootyman 05-31-06 10:20 PM

For some reason I thought lisp girl was Amy Poehler dressed up as part of some meta-isc joke. Sadly I'm wrong.

calhoun07 05-31-06 11:35 PM

So who did lisp girl blow to make it as far as she did? She was more annoying than that fat girl a season or two ago whose main schtick was making annoying faces.

Buford T Pusser 06-01-06 12:22 AM

No outrage at the dumb Buck Star routine?

I clearly remember reading that he was a plant by the TV show and they payed for all of his trips to the cities.

Yet they did it again acting as if it was real. WTF?

calhoun07 06-01-06 12:55 AM

I personally failed to see the point behind Buck Star, unless they actually think he's funny. I wondered how the hell he managed to be able to make it to all these US cities while apparently out of work.

Gil Jawetz 06-01-06 08:09 AM

That is Buck Star in the taco bell mountain climbing commercial they show during LCS, right? Hmmmm....

DRG 06-01-06 09:02 AM

Re: Buck Star


Read & Mark apparently also love creating characters for the "reality" show. Do you all remember the hideous Buck Star? He was the tool who went to every city of the regional tryouts whom Read & Mark ripped apart before he was able to finish his first joke. From what I hear, Buck Star is actually a Production Assistant that NBC used to film remotes. That's right! Buck didn't travel all over the country to try out, he was on the payroll doing his job! NBC wanted to create a William Hung type of character (the Dat Phan of American Idol) and decided Buck would be the perfect candidate. They gave Buck a bullshit angle with his father, a joke from Rich Vos, and when he was finally given stage time all he talked about was stalking Read & Mark.
http://www.cringehumor.net/columns/062604_lcs2.htm

atari2600 06-01-06 09:31 AM


Originally Posted by ShallowHal
I just saw a promo for Last Comic Standing, and I'll watch it, but it's still stacked with pros. I don't understand why they do this! I realize they have to be good in order to keep viewers, but they're again using comics that have already been on Comedy Central, The Tonight Show, etc. How is it a search for talent when they have bios on comedycentral.com?

Gabriel Iglesias had a "Comedy Central Presents:" show 3 or 4 years ago. From his site:



His CC special was great, but how can this be a competition to win a Comedy Central special when he's already had one?

EXACTLY my first thought too! i already knew a lot of these guys...they were already somewhat famous and anyone who watches comedy central has seen that iglesias guy. also i KNOW the dwyer guy, just cant remember from where.

why do they allow this? wouldnt it be like american idol allowing famous singers to try out?

pinata242 06-01-06 09:35 AM

Dwyer's on those "I Love Loving Things" shows on VH1 quite a bit. So is Doug Benson. Best Week Ever too.

das Monkey 06-01-06 10:07 AM

Bill Dwyer's probably best known for <i>BattleBots</i>.

das

movieking 06-01-06 10:11 AM

Since I don't really know any of their names yet, I'll just say that I was moderately satisfied with their picks. Obviously, they showed the funny jokes from those who made it, so the real test will be when we start to see longer routines.

I don't really buy this as any kind of contest, just a tool for exposure for these comics. I was surprised to see Jim Wiggans again though, as I would have thought that he made it too far before to qualify, if such a rule exists. I know that he had a fair amount of camera time before, enough that I was able to remember he right away when he was showed the first time this season.

Buford T Pusser 06-01-06 10:29 AM

I guess NBC just wanted to let everyone enjoy Wiggans "Did You Poop Today?" hat. Plus his scarf, cane and turnaround gimmick.




http://www.johnnybeehner.com/video/J...0for%20web.JPG



How bout those hippy years?


http://www.neworleanscomedy.com/talent/jim_wiggins.jpg

Slumbering Fist 06-01-06 02:49 PM

I gave it a whirl. I thought for a moment it was going to be ‟Last Disability Standing.‟

After saying in this thread they never get edgy comedians, I tune in to see Doug Benson. Damn foiled again. But, Benson does have "safe" material. Problem is he’s been doing his safe routine for the past ten years. His "Like most comedians, I just broke up with my girlfriend" line is at least eight years old.

I was really surprised to see some comedians with stolen jokes. For instance, the guy who did a bit about homeless people with dogs (Paraphrasing- "How confusing is that for the dog? The dog probably thinks they’re on a long walk that just never ends.") I swear I’ve heard a popular comedian (like Chappelle, maybe???) do that joke years ago.

Buford T Pusser 06-01-06 03:10 PM

Slumbering Fist :eek:


I've never seen you before. Do you review Asian Porn?

Slumbering Fist 06-01-06 03:27 PM


Originally Posted by Buford T Pusser
Slumbering Fist :eek:


I've never seen you before. Do you review Asian Porn?


Hey, I totally could but choose not too. My descriptive abilities when it comes to sex is sadly limited.

Oh, and the name is a play on a kung fu film called "Sleeping Fist" Besides if it was a porn moniker, it'd be Slumbering Fisting.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:15 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.