Stephen King's Desperation 5/23 on ABC
#27
DVD Talk Special Edition
I liked it but my damn receiver shut down at the 127 minute mark. So i guess i'm waiting for the dvd as well. Maybe we'll get the complete uncut "mini series".
#28
I thought it was rather mediocre. Started great though. Ron Perlman was terrific in the first half as an evil policeman terrorizing motorists.
The first half was also pretty good for establishing atmosphere and ratcheting up the suspense. Like some other horror, things became less interesting once the nature of the threat was made clearer. And it got worse when an incredibly annoying kid started getting lots of airtime -- the whole bit with "god's plan" just felt really corny. And the final "confrontation" just seemed laughable to me.
It wasn't in HD, which sucked. It didn't seem particular gory to me -- mostly just seeing already dead bodies and lots of scenes in darkness/shadow. I'm glad it wasn't longer -- many of these King mini-series just seem too drawn out as they are.
Spoiler:
It wasn't in HD, which sucked. It didn't seem particular gory to me -- mostly just seeing already dead bodies and lots of scenes in darkness/shadow. I'm glad it wasn't longer -- many of these King mini-series just seem too drawn out as they are.
#29
Member
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 120
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I read the book but it has been a while. I guess I'm the only one that really enjoyed this? Thankfully they didn't try to make a miniseries of "The Regulators" - "Desperation" was the better work .
#33
DVD Talk Special Edition
Originally Posted by brainee
I thought it was rather mediocre. Started great though. Ron Perlman was terrific in the first half as an evil policeman terrorizing motorists.
The first half was also pretty good for establishing atmosphere and ratcheting up the suspense. Like some other horror, things became less interesting once the nature of the threat was made clearer. And it got worse when an incredibly annoying kid started getting lots of airtime -- the whole bit with "god's plan" just felt really corny. And the final "confrontation" just seemed laughable to me.
It wasn't in HD, which sucked. It didn't seem particular gory to me -- mostly just seeing already dead bodies and lots of scenes in darkness/shadow. I'm glad it wasn't longer -- many of these King mini-series just seem too drawn out as they are.
Spoiler:
It wasn't in HD, which sucked. It didn't seem particular gory to me -- mostly just seeing already dead bodies and lots of scenes in darkness/shadow. I'm glad it wasn't longer -- many of these King mini-series just seem too drawn out as they are.
But Pearlman did kick ass in his part - definitely the highlight of the show. I could see where there were obvious bits cut for time. The second half seemed very rushed after the deliberately paced set up, and a few plot holes were pretty glaring. Presumably, the full cut will re-surface on DVD later.
I still enjoyed it - the ABC King miniseries are kind of a late TV season tradition for me. You have to wonder if they are losing theire luster to ABC though. They seem to be cutting them back in both frequency and length lately.
#34
Thread Starter
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 808
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Todash
I thought this was alright but it failed in a lot of ways.
They didn't spend enough time on Collie Entragian. He didn't look half as bad as described in the book. There seemed to be very little tension, it was hard to get a sense of urgency and the fear of just what the hell was happening in this town and what is going to happen.
I didn't like the kid who portrayed David or at least the way he acted. The kid just lost his whole family not to mention all the horrible shit that's going down but he hardly seems to show any emotion. Marinville was badly cast, Tom Skerrit;s an okay actor but he's way too old, Sam Elliot or Nick Nolte would have been better choices. Also Annabeth Gish is a bad actress.
I was disappointed when Steve Ames and Cynthia Smith went into a convenience store instead of one of the houses. That scene in the book is pretty cool, reminded me a lot of The Stand.
The voice for the spirit in the cave was ridiculous.
Another big disappointment is that the IOU/treehouse thing was changed and replaced with a yearbook.
They didn't spend enough time on Collie Entragian. He didn't look half as bad as described in the book. There seemed to be very little tension, it was hard to get a sense of urgency and the fear of just what the hell was happening in this town and what is going to happen.
I didn't like the kid who portrayed David or at least the way he acted. The kid just lost his whole family not to mention all the horrible shit that's going down but he hardly seems to show any emotion. Marinville was badly cast, Tom Skerrit;s an okay actor but he's way too old, Sam Elliot or Nick Nolte would have been better choices. Also Annabeth Gish is a bad actress.
I was disappointed when Steve Ames and Cynthia Smith went into a convenience store instead of one of the houses. That scene in the book is pretty cool, reminded me a lot of The Stand.
The voice for the spirit in the cave was ridiculous.
Another big disappointment is that the IOU/treehouse thing was changed and replaced with a yearbook.
#36
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by OwlAtHome
The voice for the spirit in the cave was ridiculous.
Anyway, I just finished this and have to agree with brainee's points. I thought it was a bit more polished (as in more like a real movie and not a tv-movie) than the usual Mick Garris - King adaptions. But it definitely suffered from the problem of good buildup but nowhere interesting to go with it, leading to a disappointing reveal. I had the same problem with It and (especially) Dreamcatcher. I think the problem is that Pennywise the Clown and Collie the Cop are much creepier than
Spoiler:
#37
DVD Talk God
i liked it 
i read desperation awhile back.. but i could have swore that for one reason or another, i hadnt ever finished it
i kept watching the movie, and remembering everything from the book up until the very end.. so I guess I did read the whole book :lol
I also read regulators and didnt like it as much.. but with the right cast and special effects, it could be pretty freaky.

i read desperation awhile back.. but i could have swore that for one reason or another, i hadnt ever finished it
i kept watching the movie, and remembering everything from the book up until the very end.. so I guess I did read the whole book :lol
I also read regulators and didnt like it as much.. but with the right cast and special effects, it could be pretty freaky.
#38
Moderator
I watched this and didn't care for it at all (and was so looking forward to it). I blame Mick Garris (not the material) though. Very sloppy job on his part, IMO.




