Two tuner DVR in the bedroom. Wife's Bones trumps all, leaving me one slot during the 7pm local timeslot (sorry, Freddie!). I watched OTH consistently a couple years ago, often do a lot of 30-second skip. But the brunette with the dimples is a weakness of mine. I hadn't seen ANTM until this season, but am starting to like it. I also laugh every time I see Tyra, as I keep hearing dolphin noises in my head.

Either show is a nice 30 minute or so diversion. Neither will I watch straight through, I'll be skipping here and there...

Neither one is "living room dvr" material. Not in the dirty way... Just it's the kind of show to have on while sorting through the mail, or browsing a magazine. In the living room, I usually have stuff that totally holds my attention. Also, watching something "live OTA" or somesuch isn't an option, as I'm rarely home at that time and don't really watch anything non-sports related live.

Anyway, help me decide which stays!

OTH, although, have you seen recent episodes?

Finally a new episode tonight. I can't wait to see the fall out from the spoiler above.

EDIT: As for your question, OTH is my guilty pleasure. I've never seen ANTM

I have never seen ANTM, but I do watch OTH so I'll throw in my vote for that.

The chicks on OTH are hotter.

Okay, at first I thought it would be a toss-up, but after tonight's episode of One Tree Hill, I can't imagine not watching this show. It was a powerful episode...the best one yet, can't see how a modeling competition would top it.