The TV Rank Them As You See Them Thread
 

I've seen people keep track of all the movies they see on this site and other places, but I'm not sure if I've ever seen it for TV. It is a little harder to rank TV because you have to keep track of all the episodes, but I think that would make this more useful than a movie list. This list would be helpful if you wanted to rewatch certain episodes of a show later on or if you wanted to recommend a show to somebody else. I don't know if anybody else is interested in doing this, but I'll start it off.

I might change my formatting later on, but I'd prefer to keep it as simple as possible for now. I use the episode number, but you could use airdate if that's easier. I haven't decided yet if I want to include older shows I'm watching for the first time or if I should limit the list to only shows that have aired this year.

Scores are on a 1-10 scale:

Arrested Development: 309 - 5
Battlestar Galactica: 211 - 6; 212 - 7
Book of Daniel: 101-102 - 6; 103 - 5
Boston Legal: 211 - 6
Desperate Housewives: 211 - 8
Ghost Whisperer: 113 - 5
Gilmore Girls: 611 - 5
House: 210 - 6
How I Met Your Mother: 112 - 6
Hustle: 101 - 5
In Justice: 101 - 5 ; 102-103 - 4
Invasion: 111 - 8
Las Vegas: 312 - 6; 313 - 5
Lost: 210 - 7
Malcolm in the Middle: 710 - 7; 711 - 7
Medium: 211 - 7; 212 - 6
My Name is Earl: 111 - 5; 112 - 4
OC: 311 - 7
Office: 212 - 7; 213 - 8
One Tree Hill: 310 - 8
RW/RR Challenge: 1105 - 8; 1106 - 8; 1107 - 7
Shield: 501 - 6
Scrubs: 501-502 - 4
Smallville: 510 - 4
South of Nowhere: 107 - 5
Surface: 111 - 7; 112 - 7
Teen Titans: 511 - 6; 512 - 8
West Wing: 710 - 4; 711 - 7

My Top TV Shows right now (and man is it a good year for TV)

1. Rome 9
2. Battlestar Galactica 8.5
3. Boston Legal 7
4. Stargate SG1 7
5. Family Guy 7
6. South Park 6

Shield 10
Battlestar Gallactica 10
Office 9
Arrested Developement 8.5
My name is Earl 8.5
Scrubs (haven't scene new eps yet but I'm guessing 8.5-10)

Top Ten currently: (overall, not doing every ep)

10) Grey's Anatomy
9) NCIS
8) 24
7) Prison Break
6) Las Vegas
5) Boston Legal
4) Scrubs
3) Lost
2) Family Guy
1) My Name Is Earl

Not currently airing eps: Deadwood, Sopranos, Entourage, Rescue Me, Nip/Tuck

Interesting idea. Ranking by episode numbers seems a bit fanatical to me... :)

Shows I Must Not Miss
1. Lost
2. 24
3. Boondocks
4. American Dad

That's about it. Those are the only shows I get mad if I miss a new episode of.

Rate every episode? That's crazy-talk!

1. Arrested Development
2. Lost
3. Scrubs
4. 24
5. The Office
6. South Park
7. The Daily Show
8. The Colbert Report
9. My Name Is Earl
10. Family Guy

My top five shows (not episode-specific) are:

1) 24
2) Lost
3) Battlestar Galactica
4) Prison Break
5) Stargate SG-1