DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Greatest "Jump the Shark" Moment? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/439692-greatest-jump-shark-moment.html)

mikehunt 09-28-05 08:22 PM


Originally Posted by CPT
I forgot a big one!

The Practice- When Dylan McDermott left, Eugene Young became a judge, and they added James Spader. I just don't like Spader.

Jessica Capshaw was a good add, though. :hungry:

I like Spader
but I agree that McDermott leaving was bad for the show

tanman 09-28-05 08:28 PM


Originally Posted by dvd-4-life
Lois and Clark---when they got married-was that during season 4?


It was a bit earlier I think. Right after the season finally when he asked Lois out. "Who is asking me, Clark Kent or Superman." After that it just became stupid. Like the monster of the week kind of thing.

Frasier - When Niles and Daphne get together. Although to be fair I think that is when most viewers jumped and not necessarily the show. The tenth season is definately one of the funniest.

SeaQuest DSV - remember this show? It was pretty cool, that is until they ran out of things to do underwater and went into space or something like that.

ER - just how many "jump the shark" moments can one show have?

GoldenJCJ 09-28-05 08:43 PM

Roseanne - The lesbian kiss with Mariel Hemmingway

West Wing - The departure of Aaron Sorkin

and I agree that the X-Files jumped with the X-Files movie. It's not that the movie was bad, but the show just didn't click anymore after the movie came out.

Deftones 09-28-05 08:46 PM


Originally Posted by tanman

SeaQuest DSV - remember this show? It was pretty cool, that is until they ran out of things to do underwater and went into space or something like that.

It wasn't that they went to space, but they introduced aliens into the show.

maingon 09-28-05 09:01 PM


Originally Posted by animalmystic
The only role I like James Spder in is when he plays a sex crazed pervert.....oh wait....

Roseanne-When they won the lottery (I think it was the last season) then it was all a dream or something, stupid.

Home Improvement, when they started having serious storylines like when the kids were going all goth and the drug stuff, lam-o.

The 3's Company spinoff, 3's a Crowd, where Jack became a cook or something in a Hotel, they should have just let it be after 3's finished.

Alias, when they introduced the long lost sister, BORING, though Mia is :drool:




I liked the movie :blush:

I loved the x-files movie.

BigDan 09-28-05 10:16 PM


Originally Posted by Shannon Nutt
Mad About You - When Paul & Jamie had a baby.

I think it was earlier than that. I think Mad About You jumped the shark in the episode where Paul went for the walk with the lady at the film awards and Jamie kissed her co-worker.

Merkin Muffley 09-28-05 10:31 PM

Arrested Development - When Barry Zuckerkorn jumped the shark.

http://www.strangecock.com/images/jumptheshark.gif

calhoun07 09-28-05 11:18 PM

ENTERPRISE-When the opening credits rolled on the first episode with that lame ass music.

Jadzia 09-28-05 11:23 PM


Originally Posted by calhoun07
ENTERPRISE-When the opening credits rolled on the first episode with that lame ass music.

:up:

Dr_Evil 09-28-05 11:27 PM


Originally Posted by Rockmjd23
Bah! The Mooninites are being overexposed.

Weren't they thinking of spinning Spacecataz off into its own series? I think that is why they got rid of Dr. Weird. I wouldn't be surprised to see him return in the future. I agree the Mooninites are overexposed, but they are great in small doses (1 ep per season).

cleaver 09-28-05 11:34 PM

Never ever mentioned
Transformers
Spoiler:
When Optimus Prime died :(

freshticles 09-28-05 11:51 PM

Felicity...when that chick cut her hair off...didn't that murder that show???

lawyer goodwill 09-29-05 01:16 AM

The Simpsons, when they added "Roy" to the family ... -wink-

Count Dooku 09-29-05 01:35 AM

This stuff would be a great idea for a website!

apchrist 09-29-05 01:50 AM

Simpsons - Conan Leaves
News Radio - Phil Hartman Dies
Sesame St. - Everyone can see Snuffleopagus
The Casby Show - It Jumped the shark with every new charachter so about 8 times
Star Trek - The Space Hippie Episode

madara 09-29-05 06:48 AM

Dear god, no way there was any jumping the shark in x-files movie.

Jimmy James 09-29-05 06:52 AM


Originally Posted by apchrist
News Radio - Phil Hartman Dies

I take issue with this one. The show changed for the worse as a result of this, but it wasn't a choice made by the creative talent. I don't think it counts.

wendersfan 09-29-05 07:37 AM


Originally Posted by Cancer Man
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: I guess that occurred either when Buffy Summers hit college

Funny, that's when I think the show finally started to be watchable.

MovieExchange 09-29-05 08:15 AM

Buffy jumped the shark for me in season 6. I started watching the show for the first time about 5 months ago, working my way through the DVD's at work. I got concerned at the beginning of the college season, the shows started to get very weak, but everything got back on track. Then season 6. After surviving monsters and demons for 5 years, the worst damage done to Buffy is by... 3 nerds?

Highlander - well, if we leave out the purist's reason (there shouldn't have been anything after the first movie, and if it's the time of "the Gathering," there shouldn't be anymore immortals being "born"), I'd say it would be season 6 where Adrian Paul started sleepwalking through the scripts.

X-Files - I'll agree that the movie was where the series jumped the shark. Not that the movie was bad, but that was the last time the series was good.

Tracer Bullet 09-29-05 09:16 AM

Dead Like Me season two. There's no "moment", but the energy and humor of the show practically disappeared after the first season. This included Mason suddenly deciding to go sober and the lame conclusion to the story of Rube's daughter.

story 09-29-05 09:23 AM


Originally Posted by Cancer Man
What TV show has the best defined moment when it "Jumped the Shark"? Here are the ones off the top of my head:

Er, none of those are actual "moments." They're all feelings based on a certain period in the show.

wendersfan 09-29-05 09:28 AM


Originally Posted by MovieExchange
Then season 6. After surviving monsters and demons for 5 years, the worst damage done to Buffy is by... 3 nerds?

I think you're looking at it from the wrong angle. In S5, Buffy and the gang defeated <b>a god</b>. How bigger and badder could it get? S6 demonstrates that the real weakness of the characters was internal, that after years of forging relationships with one another, all the little grudges, petty jealousies, and character flaws were the real danger for the Scoobies. They represented a greater danger to one another than any outside force ever could.

stinkeye 09-29-05 11:45 AM

Common belief is whenever this shows up:

http://www.jumptheshark.com/artwork/tedmcginley.jpg

However, I think he has been supplanted by this:

http://entimg.msn.com/i/150/ce/0211/DSpade_150.jpg

Rockmjd23 09-29-05 11:58 AM


Originally Posted by madara
Dear god, no way there was any jumping the shark in x-files movie.

It wasn't in the movie. I liked the movie as well. It just all went downhill afterwards.

dadaluholla 09-29-05 12:35 PM

A lot of these comments I've read are just random opinions of when shows began their decline in quality not actual "shark jumping".


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:20 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.