Rank them as you see them (New show edition)
#1
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Fremont, CA
Posts: 2,117
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Rank them as you see them (New show edition)
I liked the idea for movies, and figured for the next few weeks I'm going to be watching more tv than movies. Same rules apply 1 post per person, edit them as you watch more. Rank them however you see fit. Separate into categories (drama, comedy, 30min, 1 hour, network, basic, premium, blah) if you want.
My rankings thus far (best to worst/top to bottom):
Saw, Enjoyed, will continue to watch:
Love Monkey
Prison Break
Rome
Supernatural
Bones
Kitchen Confidential (canceled)
Big Love
How I Met Your Mother
Everybody Hates Chris
Out of Practice (canceled)
Criminal Minds
Few more Chances:
Night Stalker (canceled)
Killer Instinct (canceled)
Threshhold (canceled)
Reunion (canceled)
My Name Is Earl
E-Ring (canceled)
Surface (canceled)
Invasion
Ghost Whisperer
Meh, will watch if nothing is on:
Twins (canceled)
Extras (will be catching it on demand)
The War at Home
Tried to watch, but failed/will no longer watch:
Just Legal (canceled)
Head Cases (canceled)
Sex, Love & Secrets - Oh god I can't believe I wasted 6 minutes trying this (canceled)
Commander In Chief (canceled)
Premiers I probably won't even bother to watch:
Apprentice: Martha Stewart (canceled)
Love Inc. (canceled)
Inconceivable (canceled)
Three Wishes (canceled)
Hot Properties (canceled)
My rankings thus far (best to worst/top to bottom):
Saw, Enjoyed, will continue to watch:
Love Monkey
Prison Break
Rome
Supernatural
Bones
Kitchen Confidential (canceled)
Big Love
How I Met Your Mother
Everybody Hates Chris
Out of Practice (canceled)
Criminal Minds
Few more Chances:
Night Stalker (canceled)
Killer Instinct (canceled)
Threshhold (canceled)
Reunion (canceled)
My Name Is Earl
E-Ring (canceled)
Surface (canceled)
Invasion
Ghost Whisperer
Meh, will watch if nothing is on:
Twins (canceled)
Extras (will be catching it on demand)
The War at Home
Tried to watch, but failed/will no longer watch:
Just Legal (canceled)
Head Cases (canceled)
Sex, Love & Secrets - Oh god I can't believe I wasted 6 minutes trying this (canceled)
Commander In Chief (canceled)
Premiers I probably won't even bother to watch:
Apprentice: Martha Stewart (canceled)
Love Inc. (canceled)
Inconceivable (canceled)
Three Wishes (canceled)
Hot Properties (canceled)
Last edited by Daniel-A; 09-04-06 at 03:57 PM.
#2
DVD Talk Legend
Must watch new shows
Prison Break
Supernatural
My Name is Earl
Everybody Hates Chris
New shows that I have watched and I'm sticking with (until something better comes along)...
Reunion
Threshold
How I Met Your Mother
Kitchen Confidential
Criminal Minds
Shows that I watched the premiere and didn't care for
Bones
Head Cases
Surface
Shows that I watched the premiere and wondered who greenlighted the project.
Ghost Whisperer
Shows that I won't be watching at all
The War At Home
Twins
Killer Instinct
Inconceivable
Three Wishes
Still on the DVR
Invasion
E-Ring
New Shows Coming Up
Night Stalker
Freddie
Hot Properties
Sex, Love & Secrets
Prison Break
Supernatural
My Name is Earl
Everybody Hates Chris
New shows that I have watched and I'm sticking with (until something better comes along)...
Reunion
Threshold
How I Met Your Mother
Kitchen Confidential
Criminal Minds
Shows that I watched the premiere and didn't care for
Bones
Head Cases
Surface
Shows that I watched the premiere and wondered who greenlighted the project.
Ghost Whisperer
Shows that I won't be watching at all
The War At Home
Twins
Killer Instinct
Inconceivable
Three Wishes
Still on the DVR
Invasion
E-Ring
New Shows Coming Up
Night Stalker
Freddie
Hot Properties
Sex, Love & Secrets
Last edited by LorenzoL; 09-24-05 at 03:07 AM.
#3
Moderator
Watched and liked
Rome
Prison Break
Reunion
How I Met Your Mother
My Name is Earl
Extras
On the fence
Invasion
Surface
Watched and did not like
Bones
Threshold
The War at Home
Killer Instinct
Supernatural
Plan on watching
The Night Stalker
Rome
Prison Break
Reunion
How I Met Your Mother
My Name is Earl
Extras
On the fence
Invasion
Surface
Watched and did not like
Bones
Threshold
The War at Home
Killer Instinct
Supernatural
Plan on watching
The Night Stalker
Last edited by Geofferson; 09-26-05 at 08:35 AM.
#4
DVD Talk Hero
Watched and liked
Rome
Supernatural
Prison Break
How I Met Your Mother
Surface
Kitchen Confidential
Criminal Minds
Everybody Hates Chris
My name Is Earl
Meh
Bones
Threshold
War at Home
E-Ring
Invasion
Inconceivable
A few more chances
Reunion
Holy Crap that was bad!
Head Cases
Rome
Supernatural
Prison Break
How I Met Your Mother
Surface
Kitchen Confidential
Criminal Minds
Everybody Hates Chris
My name Is Earl
Meh
Bones
Threshold
War at Home
E-Ring
Invasion
Inconceivable
A few more chances
Reunion
Holy Crap that was bad!
Head Cases
Last edited by MrX; 09-24-05 at 02:56 AM.
#5
DVD Talk Hero
Watched and Liked:
Bones
Criminal Minds
E-Ring
Everybody Hates Chris
Head Cases
How I Met Your Mother
Invasion
Kitchen Confidential
My Name is Earl
Prison Break
Rome
Supernatural
Threshold
Meh, but will Continue:
Surface
The War at Home
Overall Rankings:
1.My Name is Earl
2.Prison Break
3.Rome
4.Bones
5.Kitchen Confidential
6.How I Met Your Mother
7.Supernatural
8.Head Cases ()
9.Everybody Hates Chris
10.Threshold
11.Criminal Minds
12.Invasion
13.E-Ring
14.The War at Home
15.Surface
Bones
Criminal Minds
E-Ring
Everybody Hates Chris
Head Cases
How I Met Your Mother
Invasion
Kitchen Confidential
My Name is Earl
Prison Break
Rome
Supernatural
Threshold
Meh, but will Continue:
Surface
The War at Home
Overall Rankings:
1.My Name is Earl
2.Prison Break
3.Rome
4.Bones
5.Kitchen Confidential
6.How I Met Your Mother
7.Supernatural
8.Head Cases ()
9.Everybody Hates Chris
10.Threshold
11.Criminal Minds
12.Invasion
13.E-Ring
14.The War at Home
15.Surface
Last edited by Quake1028; 10-07-05 at 12:24 AM.
#6
DVD Talk Legend
Will stay tuned in for:
Prison Break
My Name Is Earl
Apprentice: Martha Stewart
Surface
Commander In Chief
Supernatural
Watched and will give more chances:
Close To Home
Reunion
How I Met Your Mother
E-Ring
Everybody Hates Chris
Killer Instinct
Related
Still need to watch my recording(s):
Rome
Night Stalker
Watched & Dropped:
Inconceivable
Invasion
Threshhold
Kitchen Confidential
Criminal Minds
Head Cases
Just Legal
Bones
Love Inc.
Sex, Love & Secrets
Did not watch or not planning to watch:
Twins
The War at Home
Hot Properties
Freddie
Three Wishes
Out of Practice
Ghost Whisperer
Prison Break
My Name Is Earl
Apprentice: Martha Stewart
Surface
Commander In Chief
Supernatural
Watched and will give more chances:
Close To Home
Reunion
How I Met Your Mother
E-Ring
Everybody Hates Chris
Killer Instinct
Related
Still need to watch my recording(s):
Rome
Night Stalker
Watched & Dropped:
Inconceivable
Invasion
Threshhold
Kitchen Confidential
Criminal Minds
Head Cases
Just Legal
Bones
Love Inc.
Sex, Love & Secrets
Did not watch or not planning to watch:
Twins
The War at Home
Hot Properties
Freddie
Three Wishes
Out of Practice
Ghost Whisperer
Last edited by Jadzia; 10-18-05 at 01:06 PM.
#8
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Dec 1999
Location: Seattle
Posts: 2,165
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I like this idea for a thread, so here goes -
Thoughly Enjoying, Definitely will watch:
Prison Break
Kitchen Confidential
My Name is Earl (simply amazing!)
Enjoyed and will give more chances:
Reunion
Watched, OK, but will watch again (until I can bear no more ):
Threshold
Bones
Just Legal
Sitting on my DVR, waiting for me to watch:
Rome (Deleted, will get the DVDs - I have too much to watch)
Supernatural
How I Met Your Mother
Surface
Watched/tried to watch & gave up:
Head Cases
War at Home
No Interest - Not planning to watch:
Twins
Hot Properties
Freddie
Love Inc.
Three Wishes
Ghost Whisperer
Remaining shows - Plan to watch at least the Pilot:
Apprentice: Martha Stewart (NBC) Sept. 21
E-Ring (NBC) Sept. 21
Invasion (ABC) Sept. 21
Criminal Minds (CBS) Sept. 22
Everybody Hates Chris (UPN) Sept. 22
Killer Instinct (Fox) Sept. 23
Inconceivable (NBC) Sept. 23
Commander In Chief (ABC) Sept. 27
Sex, Love & Secrets (UPN) Sept. 27
Night Stalker (ABC) Sept. 29
Close To Home (CBS) Oct. 4
Related (WB) Oct. 5
I think that I'm watching almost everything this fall. My DVRs are doing triple duty this fall , how I like it...
Ratings:
Prison Break
My Name is Earl
Reunion 1/2
Bones
Threshold
Thoughly Enjoying, Definitely will watch:
Prison Break
Kitchen Confidential
My Name is Earl (simply amazing!)
Enjoyed and will give more chances:
Reunion
Watched, OK, but will watch again (until I can bear no more ):
Threshold
Bones
Just Legal
Sitting on my DVR, waiting for me to watch:
Rome (Deleted, will get the DVDs - I have too much to watch)
Supernatural
How I Met Your Mother
Surface
Watched/tried to watch & gave up:
Head Cases
War at Home
No Interest - Not planning to watch:
Twins
Hot Properties
Freddie
Love Inc.
Three Wishes
Ghost Whisperer
Remaining shows - Plan to watch at least the Pilot:
Apprentice: Martha Stewart (NBC) Sept. 21
E-Ring (NBC) Sept. 21
Invasion (ABC) Sept. 21
Criminal Minds (CBS) Sept. 22
Everybody Hates Chris (UPN) Sept. 22
Killer Instinct (Fox) Sept. 23
Inconceivable (NBC) Sept. 23
Commander In Chief (ABC) Sept. 27
Sex, Love & Secrets (UPN) Sept. 27
Night Stalker (ABC) Sept. 29
Close To Home (CBS) Oct. 4
Related (WB) Oct. 5
I think that I'm watching almost everything this fall. My DVRs are doing triple duty this fall , how I like it...
Ratings:
Prison Break
My Name is Earl
Reunion 1/2
Bones
Threshold
Last edited by Sparrow; 09-20-05 at 09:00 PM.
#9
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: HB, CA
Posts: 2,600
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm definitely tuning in for Rome every week.
I've stopped watching Prison Break. If it goes a full season and I hear that it gets better, maybe I'll pick it up on "DVD" this summer. I did that with Veronica Mars this summer and it worked out pretty well.
Based on the screeners of the pilots, I'm looking forward to My Name is Earl. The Ghost Whisperer, however, was horrible. The show totally fails to showcase Jennifer Love Hewitt's charms. Also, it's just a bad show.
I don't really know enough about any other shows to say whether I'm interested in watching them or not. I've actually come to rely on browsing the threads in this forum to find out which shows are interesting.
edited to add: I also watched the pilot of Reunion and it's in the same boat as Prison Break. I'm going to pass on it for now.
I've stopped watching Prison Break. If it goes a full season and I hear that it gets better, maybe I'll pick it up on "DVD" this summer. I did that with Veronica Mars this summer and it worked out pretty well.
Based on the screeners of the pilots, I'm looking forward to My Name is Earl. The Ghost Whisperer, however, was horrible. The show totally fails to showcase Jennifer Love Hewitt's charms. Also, it's just a bad show.
I don't really know enough about any other shows to say whether I'm interested in watching them or not. I've actually come to rely on browsing the threads in this forum to find out which shows are interesting.
edited to add: I also watched the pilot of Reunion and it's in the same boat as Prison Break. I'm going to pass on it for now.
Last edited by belboz; 09-19-05 at 07:19 AM.
#10
Video Game Talk Reviewer
Join Date: Dec 1999
Location: Formerly known as "Vryce"/Detroit, Michigan
Posts: 13,856
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Will stay tuned in for:
The War at Home
Head Cases
Supernatural
Bones
Survivor: Guatemala
Watched and will give more chances:
Still need to watch my recording(s):
Prison Break
Threshhold
Reunion
Watched/tried to watch & gave up:
Not interested or planning to watch:
Twins
Hot Properties
Freddie
Love Inc.
Three Wishes
Out of Practice
Ghost Whisperer
Just Legal
Commander In Chief
Sex, Love & Secrets
Related
Remaining shows:
How I Met Your Mother (CBS) Sept. 19
Kitchen Confidential (Fox) Sept. 19
Surface (NBC) Sept. 19
My Name Is Earl (NBC) Sept. 20
Apprentice: Martha Stewart (NBC) Sept. 21
E-Ring (NBC) Sept. 21
Invasion (ABC) Sept. 21
Criminal Minds (CBS) Sept. 22
Everybody Hates Chris (UPN) Sept. 22
Killer Instinct (Fox) Sept. 23
Inconceivable (NBC) Sept. 23
Night Stalker (ABC) Sept. 29
Close To Home (CBS) Oct. 4
The War at Home
Head Cases
Supernatural
Bones
Survivor: Guatemala
Watched and will give more chances:
Still need to watch my recording(s):
Prison Break
Threshhold
Reunion
Watched/tried to watch & gave up:
Not interested or planning to watch:
Twins
Hot Properties
Freddie
Love Inc.
Three Wishes
Out of Practice
Ghost Whisperer
Just Legal
Commander In Chief
Sex, Love & Secrets
Related
Remaining shows:
How I Met Your Mother (CBS) Sept. 19
Kitchen Confidential (Fox) Sept. 19
Surface (NBC) Sept. 19
My Name Is Earl (NBC) Sept. 20
Apprentice: Martha Stewart (NBC) Sept. 21
E-Ring (NBC) Sept. 21
Invasion (ABC) Sept. 21
Criminal Minds (CBS) Sept. 22
Everybody Hates Chris (UPN) Sept. 22
Killer Instinct (Fox) Sept. 23
Inconceivable (NBC) Sept. 23
Night Stalker (ABC) Sept. 29
Close To Home (CBS) Oct. 4
#11
DVD Talk Limited Edition
WATCHING AND ENJOYING:
Prison Break
WATCHED, HATED, AND NEVER WANT TO SEE AGAIN:
Rome
Bones
Threshold
ONLY OTHER NEW SHOWS I AM GIVING A CHANCE:
Invasion
Kitchen Confidential
Prison Break
WATCHED, HATED, AND NEVER WANT TO SEE AGAIN:
Rome
Bones
Threshold
ONLY OTHER NEW SHOWS I AM GIVING A CHANCE:
Invasion
Kitchen Confidential
#12
DVD Talk Hero
Give a few more chances
Reunion
Eh.
Rome
Ow, my brain.
The War at Home
They canceled Jack & Bobby for this?!?
Supernatural
Plan to check out
How I Met Your Mother
Commander-in-Chief
Invasion
The Apprentice: Martha Stewart
Everybody Hates Chris
Threshold
Reunion
Eh.
Rome
Ow, my brain.
The War at Home
They canceled Jack & Bobby for this?!?
Supernatural
Plan to check out
How I Met Your Mother
Commander-in-Chief
Invasion
The Apprentice: Martha Stewart
Everybody Hates Chris
Threshold
#13
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
the only thing I hate about every new season is when a bunch of new shows come out that completely stink I get stuck watching them anyway because my wife likes crappy shows like flies on poop.
#15
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: May 2002
Location: waiting for forum.dvdtalk.com ...
Posts: 2,755
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Originally Posted by ChrisHicks
the only thing I hate about every new season is when a bunch of new shows come out that completely stink I get stuck watching them anyway because my wife likes crappy shows like flies on poop.
LOOKING FORWARD TO WATCHING IF THE S.O. GIVES THE SHOW A CHANCE
my name is earl (it does have jason lee in it, so this may get a couple of viewings by default)
#16
DVD Talk Legend
So Far So Good:
Prison Break
Rome
Supernatural
Watching, but has a short rope:
Treshhold
Still to check out:
Invasion
The Apprentice: Martha Stewart
Kitchen Confidential
How I Met Your Mother
My Name is Earl
Everybody Hates Chris
Prison Break
Rome
Supernatural
Watching, but has a short rope:
Treshhold
Still to check out:
Invasion
The Apprentice: Martha Stewart
Kitchen Confidential
How I Met Your Mother
My Name is Earl
Everybody Hates Chris
#18
Moderator
Hasn't aired yet, but I've already seen and liked
Extras
I Like it!
Rome
My Name is Earl
Everybody Hates Chris
Ridiculous but Enjoyable
Prison Break
Meh, but I'm giving them a shot
Threshhold
Invasion
Sucks Ass But I'm Strangely Intrigued So I'll Keep Watching
Reunion
Still on my DVR
Just Legal (probably won't watch)
Apprentice: Martha Stewart (probably won't watch)
Movies That Shook the World
Would Like to Try, but too many conflicts
Night Stalker
Haven't Watched/Won't Watch
Everything else
I'm sure there's stuff I'm missing...
Extras
I Like it!
Rome
My Name is Earl
Everybody Hates Chris
Ridiculous but Enjoyable
Prison Break
Meh, but I'm giving them a shot
Threshhold
Invasion
Sucks Ass But I'm Strangely Intrigued So I'll Keep Watching
Reunion
Still on my DVR
Just Legal (probably won't watch)
Apprentice: Martha Stewart (probably won't watch)
Movies That Shook the World
Would Like to Try, but too many conflicts
Night Stalker
Haven't Watched/Won't Watch
Everything else
I'm sure there's stuff I'm missing...
Last edited by Groucho; 09-24-05 at 10:11 AM.
#19
DVD Talk God
Updated:
So far:
Prison Break: B-
My Name is Earl: B
Threshold: C
The War at Home: D
Invasion: C-
So far:
Prison Break: B-
My Name is Earl: B
Threshold: C
The War at Home: D
Invasion: C-
Last edited by Deftones; 09-24-05 at 02:25 AM.
#21
DVD Talk Legend
Ranking from Best to Worst (so far)
Prison Break (5+ episodes)
Supernatural
How I Met Your Mother
My Name is Earl
Everybody Hates Chris
Threshold (2 episodes)
Kitchen Confidential
Apprentice: Martha Stewart
Reunion (2 episodes)
Invasion
Bones
Ghost Whisperer
The War at Home (2 episodes)
Killer Instincts (did not complete)
Plan to Sample
Night Stalker (ABC) Sept. 29
(Also, I am changing my rankings as I see new episodes.)
Prison Break (5+ episodes)
Supernatural
How I Met Your Mother
My Name is Earl
Everybody Hates Chris
Threshold (2 episodes)
Kitchen Confidential
Apprentice: Martha Stewart
Reunion (2 episodes)
Invasion
Bones
Ghost Whisperer
The War at Home (2 episodes)
Killer Instincts (did not complete)
Plan to Sample
Night Stalker (ABC) Sept. 29
(Also, I am changing my rankings as I see new episodes.)
Last edited by DRG; 09-24-05 at 11:10 AM.
#22
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Watched and liked:
Prison Break
Supernatural
Threshold
Reunion
Watched and don't care much:
Bones
Twins
Will Watch Pilot:
My Name is Earl
Commander in Chief
Invasion
The Apprentice: Martha Stewart
Surface
Criminal Minds
Close to Home
Ghost Whisperer
Prison Break
Supernatural
Threshold
Reunion
Watched and don't care much:
Bones
Twins
Will Watch Pilot:
My Name is Earl
Commander in Chief
Invasion
The Apprentice: Martha Stewart
Surface
Criminal Minds
Close to Home
Ghost Whisperer
#23
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Somewhere Hot Scoville Units: 9,999,999 Zodiac Sign: Capricorn
Posts: 12,258
Received 811 Likes
on
316 Posts
Enjoying (so far) - Season Pass Worthy
Bones (aka "I Don't Know What That Means")
Kitchen Confidential
How I Met Your Mother
Head Cases
Waiting Patiently On The DVR
Threshhold
Supernatural
Prison Break
Surface
Rome
Will Give It A Try
Invasion
Night Stalker
My Name Is Earl
Everybody Hates Chris
Ghost Whisperer
Bones (aka "I Don't Know What That Means")
Kitchen Confidential
How I Met Your Mother
Head Cases
Waiting Patiently On The DVR
Threshhold
Supernatural
Prison Break
Surface
Rome
Will Give It A Try
Invasion
Night Stalker
My Name Is Earl
Everybody Hates Chris
Ghost Whisperer
#24
DVD Talk Legend
Saw, Enjoyed, will continue to watch:
Reunion
Supernatural
How I Met Your Mother
Few more Chances:
Out of Practice
Bones
Threshhold
Kitchen Confidential
Prison Break
My Name Is Earl
Meh, will watch if nothing is on:
The War at Home
Tried to watch, but failed:
Head Cases
Premiers I probably won't even bother to watch:
Rome
Inconceivable
Three Wishes
Just Legal
Ghost Whisperer
Commander In Chief
Freddie
Sex, Love & Secrets
Love Inc. (I know nothing about this show)
Hot Properties (I know nothing about this show)
Remaining shows to watch:
Twins
Surface
E-Ring
Invasion
Criminal Minds
Everybody Hates Chris
Killer Instinct
Night Stalker
Close To Home
Related
Apprentice: Martha Stewart
Reunion
Supernatural
How I Met Your Mother
Few more Chances:
Out of Practice
Bones
Threshhold
Kitchen Confidential
Prison Break
My Name Is Earl
Meh, will watch if nothing is on:
The War at Home
Tried to watch, but failed:
Head Cases
Premiers I probably won't even bother to watch:
Rome
Inconceivable
Three Wishes
Just Legal
Ghost Whisperer
Commander In Chief
Freddie
Sex, Love & Secrets
Love Inc. (I know nothing about this show)
Hot Properties (I know nothing about this show)
Remaining shows to watch:
Twins
Surface
E-Ring
Invasion
Criminal Minds
Everybody Hates Chris
Killer Instinct
Night Stalker
Close To Home
Related
Apprentice: Martha Stewart