Comcast DVR vs. TiVo question?
#1
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Thread Starter
Comcast DVR vs. TiVo question?
Im not sure if this is in the right forum but Ill ask anyway. I currently have Tivo but have been experiencing many problems with channel changing (Ive tried the fort, it didnt work and Comcast doesnt support serial ports). So Im considering switching to Comcast's DVR. My question is what Tivo features/services/ease of use will I be losing if I were to switch?
#2
DVD Talk God
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Posts: 130,270
Received 614 Likes
on
493 Posts
The Comcast DVR's recording methodolgy is different. The season pass feature isn't as good, and you can't prioritize in case of conflicts. Moving around within the program isn't quite as easy. Also, I've noticed that it sometimes misses recordings for unknown reasons.
The one positive is that you will get 2 tuners with the Comcast DVR, so you can record 2 things at once.
Personally, what I would recommend is get the cable DVR and use both it and the TIVO. I use 2 Replay-TVs and a dual tuner Comcast HD-DVR. Split your cable and use your TIVO solely to record analog channels (don't have to worry about the IR blaster then). Use the Comcast DVR to record everything else.
The one positive is that you will get 2 tuners with the Comcast DVR, so you can record 2 things at once.
Personally, what I would recommend is get the cable DVR and use both it and the TIVO. I use 2 Replay-TVs and a dual tuner Comcast HD-DVR. Split your cable and use your TIVO solely to record analog channels (don't have to worry about the IR blaster then). Use the Comcast DVR to record everything else.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
I'd dump Comcast before I'd dump Tivo.
I solved my channel-changing woes (when I had Comcast and ReplayTV) by switching to DirecTV and getting DirecTivo. I haven't looked back.
I solved my channel-changing woes (when I had Comcast and ReplayTV) by switching to DirecTV and getting DirecTivo. I haven't looked back.
#8
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Thread Starter
Im currently using analog cable but paying for the cable box as I will eventually be getting digital back. Can I use Tivo to handle the analog cable channels while I have digital cable on the TV via a splitter. At one time I had Tivo running off of my digital cable along with analog cable, and the ability to save rivo stuff on my VCR. Is that all possible?
#9
DVD Talk God
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Posts: 130,270
Received 614 Likes
on
493 Posts
Originally Posted by gmal2003
Im currently using analog cable but paying for the cable box as I will eventually be getting digital back. Can I use Tivo to handle the analog cable channels while I have digital cable on the TV via a splitter. At one time I had Tivo running off of my digital cable along with analog cable, and the ability to save rivo stuff on my VCR. Is that all possible?
Yep. You'll have to change your TIVO channel setting though to get the analog lineup in your area.
#10
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Southside Virginia
Posts: 6,457
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Isn't Comcast the cable company that licensed TiVo for their boxes? If so, it's probably only the matter of a year or so before you're converted. I don't know if that might help make your choice...
#13
DVD Talk God
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Posts: 130,270
Received 614 Likes
on
493 Posts
Originally Posted by Jimmy James
That long, huh? It's hard to believe anything takes that long to roll out in this day and age.
TiVo may have an exclusivity agreement with DirecTV up until that point.
#14
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Southside Virginia
Posts: 6,457
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
http://news.com.com/TiVo,+Comcast+re...3-5616961.html
I don't see any later news than that when I do a quick search, but there may be some. It indicates the roll-out should happen in mid to late 2006, though.
I don't see any later news than that when I do a quick search, but there may be some. It indicates the roll-out should happen in mid to late 2006, though.