I can't believe I'm actually watching the show either. Was never into it but I went to college with Judd and knew him through friends so I'm pulling for him.

Shannon,

I agree with you about Bo and Anwar but I thought overall Mario was the best of the evening.

Constantine is going home tonight, I think.

Hope Nikko makes it in. I think he's got some talent, but his presence is definitely better than his voice.

TK

There's no shame in liking this show. Speaking for myself, I find this show amusing and entertaining and don't make it more than that.

It seems by the people posting in this thread and the ratings this show is getting that I'm not the only one liking it...

Fez will win it all.

Really? While I didn't think his singing was that great last night, I think he has enough charisma and the right look to get a lot of votes. I doubt he'd be in the bottom two at this point.

Yeah, I'm beginning to think the guy is a bit of a clod, but I'd expect two of the guys who didn't get much TV time in the early rounds to go.

bring back john stevens?

STRONG AGREEMENT
I thought they put Fez last on purpose just to make sure he wouldn't get forgotten and get screwed by stupid voters. I thought he was far ahead of the pack in the first couple rounds.

The only one I'm worried about not making it through is Nikko, mainly because of all the negative reaction here. I thought he did a great job with Part Time Lovers. Not too many there could hit those high notes.

Can we just have one American Idol thread next week? Or just one for the 2 competition shows and one for the result show that I never watch.

We all said that about Justin Guarini at this point in the game in Season One... and yet Kelly snuck in from the back and kneecapped him.

But then we can't do polls.

And America was right on that choice.

true, but if you had to pick now it's pretty clear that Mario is way ahead of the pack now, and I'd be shocked if he didn't make the final 12. I thought a few guys caught up to him a little though. Especially Bo.


There was a poll on this thread?

But next week when we have 10 guys and 10 gals we can start one then... just like the old days, where someone sits and updates the thread with the titles of the songs that they perform... remember?