Why is _______ still on the air?
#1
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
Why is _______ still on the air?
Well this is going to be a thread about venting your frustrations with crap that is on tv. Could be fun. It all came to mind when last night I was thumbing through and saw my #1 pick:
1.) America's Funniest Home Videos on. WTF? Who watches this crap? I'll tell you who, only people that actually submit videos to try and win. Why? B/c no one else in their right mind would waste brain cells on this mind numbing crap. Do they pay the audience to be there? It boggles the mind.
2.) Will & Grace - Relying on a guest star EVERY week and still not funny. I have given this show probably a dozen chances to make me laugh, they failed at 11.5 of them. The only one that was partially funny was the Matt Damon guest spot. Which makes my point. The guest star was funny, not the actual cast.
3.) I wanted to say ALL reality TV, but I have come to grips with the fact that not all is bad. The cable shows seem to be decent(Trading Spaces[most of TLCs shows], Choppers, Pimp my Ride), it is mostly the network ones(any Matchmaking show, Swan, Who's your Daddy, dozens of others) that grate my nerves.
Why do I care? I can change the channel or turn off the tv, but with so many hours wasted on this stuff, there could be shows like Arrested Development, Scrubs, or Lost getting a chance on the air.
So vent your frustrations. The DVDTalk Support Group is open.
1.) America's Funniest Home Videos on. WTF? Who watches this crap? I'll tell you who, only people that actually submit videos to try and win. Why? B/c no one else in their right mind would waste brain cells on this mind numbing crap. Do they pay the audience to be there? It boggles the mind.
2.) Will & Grace - Relying on a guest star EVERY week and still not funny. I have given this show probably a dozen chances to make me laugh, they failed at 11.5 of them. The only one that was partially funny was the Matt Damon guest spot. Which makes my point. The guest star was funny, not the actual cast.
3.) I wanted to say ALL reality TV, but I have come to grips with the fact that not all is bad. The cable shows seem to be decent(Trading Spaces[most of TLCs shows], Choppers, Pimp my Ride), it is mostly the network ones(any Matchmaking show, Swan, Who's your Daddy, dozens of others) that grate my nerves.
Why do I care? I can change the channel or turn off the tv, but with so many hours wasted on this stuff, there could be shows like Arrested Development, Scrubs, or Lost getting a chance on the air.
So vent your frustrations. The DVDTalk Support Group is open.
#4
DVD Talk Hero
• Michael Corvin •
1.) America's Funniest Home Videos on. WTF? Who watches this crap? I'll tell you who, only people that actually submit videos to try and win. Why? B/c no one else in their right mind would waste brain cells on this mind numbing crap. Do they pay the audience to be there? It boggles the mind.
1.) America's Funniest Home Videos on. WTF? Who watches this crap? I'll tell you who, only people that actually submit videos to try and win. Why? B/c no one else in their right mind would waste brain cells on this mind numbing crap. Do they pay the audience to be there? It boggles the mind.
• Michael Corvin •
2.) Will & Grace - Relying on a guest star EVERY week and still not funny. I have given this show probably a dozen chances to make me laugh, they failed at 11.5 of them. The only one that was partially funny was the Matt Damon guest spot. Which makes my point. The guest star was funny, not the actual cast.
2.) Will & Grace - Relying on a guest star EVERY week and still not funny. I have given this show probably a dozen chances to make me laugh, they failed at 11.5 of them. The only one that was partially funny was the Matt Damon guest spot. Which makes my point. The guest star was funny, not the actual cast.
• Michael Corvin •
3.) I wanted to say ALL reality TV, but I have come to grips with the fact that not all is bad. The cable shows seem to be decent(Trading Spaces[most of TLCs shows], Choppers, Pimp my Ride), it is mostly the network ones(any Matchmaking show, Swan, Who's your Daddy, dozens of others) that grate my nerves.
3.) I wanted to say ALL reality TV, but I have come to grips with the fact that not all is bad. The cable shows seem to be decent(Trading Spaces[most of TLCs shows], Choppers, Pimp my Ride), it is mostly the network ones(any Matchmaking show, Swan, Who's your Daddy, dozens of others) that grate my nerves.
das
#5
Moderator
Originally Posted by Red Dog
American Idol.
I will never understand its unbelieveable popularity.
I will never understand its unbelieveable popularity.
#6
DVD Talk God
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Posts: 130,869
Received 693 Likes
on
563 Posts
Originally Posted by Groucho
Never underestimate the appeal of watching idiots humilate themselves on national tv!
I understand the Gong Show aspect of its appeal. However, it sustains those ratings when it goes into the Star Search phase. Doesn't make sense.
#7
DVD Talk Hero
• Groucho •
Never underestimate the appeal of watching idiots humilate themselves on national tv!
Never underestimate the appeal of watching idiots humilate themselves on national tv!
das
#8
Moderator
Originally Posted by Red Dog
I understand the Gong Show aspect of its appeal. However, it sustains those ratings when it goes into the Star Search phase. Doesn't make sense.
I have no idea. It's like televised crack.
#9
DVD Talk Hero
• Red Dog •
I understand the Gong Show aspect of its appeal. However, it sustains those ratings when it goes into the Star Search phase. Doesn't make sense.
I understand the Gong Show aspect of its appeal. However, it sustains those ratings when it goes into the Star Search phase. Doesn't make sense.
Also, in the Star Search phase, some of the performances are so terrible that it's still humiliating, and the allure of watching dreams destroyed before a live audience is strong.
das
#11
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: The Big Easy
Posts: 1,062
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
American Idol, Enterprise, Stargate SS 1 (so sad), reality shows, King of Queens, Emeril Live, Er, CSI (all of them) Law and Order (all of them)..........................
Oh hell, why not make this easier and ask what is good on tv.
Oh hell, why not make this easier and ask what is good on tv.
#13
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: The Big Easy
Posts: 1,062
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Don't get me wrong, I love tv. I just happen to feel that over the last 15 years, (for the most part) it has gone down the tubes. (pun intended). Also no offence to the ones that like the above mentioned shows, everyones taste is different. I liked the original CSI and ER, but enough is enough already.
#14
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: NJ, the place where smiles go to die
Posts: 7,393
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
It's easy, but I have to say ALL reality TV.
Especially shows like Survivor, Apprentice, American Idol (which I just saw my first 10 minutes of & it's so fake it's pathetic). How is this shit entertaining? There are brilliant shows on TV like Carnivale, the new Battlestar Galactica (which is at least getting some attention here), & a new episode of Survivor & Apprentice come around, & they get pages of discussion & analyzing like they are the most intricate novels ever written. How is watching other people become rich entertaining? How is a show that is nothing but a hour long commercial (which is all Apprentice is) captivating. Mindless shows like this have legions of viewers but put something original & creative on TV & it gets a small fanbase struggling to stay on the air.
I hate sitcoms, but at least I can understand that some people just have very simply senses of humor, & they want something light & mindless. But I cannot for the life of me get the obsession with reality TV.
Also, Stargate. The reality TV scenario also applies here. Cliche, never takes any risks (yes I've seen a fair amount of the show), redundant, & extremely boring, yet it's one the air for 8-9 seasons? Farscape is the total oppositie in every way, actually makes an effort to break the sci-fi cliches, & that gets cancelled.
Especially shows like Survivor, Apprentice, American Idol (which I just saw my first 10 minutes of & it's so fake it's pathetic). How is this shit entertaining? There are brilliant shows on TV like Carnivale, the new Battlestar Galactica (which is at least getting some attention here), & a new episode of Survivor & Apprentice come around, & they get pages of discussion & analyzing like they are the most intricate novels ever written. How is watching other people become rich entertaining? How is a show that is nothing but a hour long commercial (which is all Apprentice is) captivating. Mindless shows like this have legions of viewers but put something original & creative on TV & it gets a small fanbase struggling to stay on the air.
I hate sitcoms, but at least I can understand that some people just have very simply senses of humor, & they want something light & mindless. But I cannot for the life of me get the obsession with reality TV.
Also, Stargate. The reality TV scenario also applies here. Cliche, never takes any risks (yes I've seen a fair amount of the show), redundant, & extremely boring, yet it's one the air for 8-9 seasons? Farscape is the total oppositie in every way, actually makes an effort to break the sci-fi cliches, & that gets cancelled.
#17
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: The Big Easy
Posts: 1,062
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Sessa17
It's easy, but I have to say ALL reality TV.
Especially shows like Survivor, Apprentice, American Idol (which I just saw my first 10 minutes of & it's so fake it's pathetic). How is this shit entertaining? There are brilliant shows on TV like Carnivale, the new Battlestar Galactica (which is at least getting some attention here), & a new episode of Survivor & Apprentice come around, & they get pages of discussion & analyzing like they are the most intricate novels ever written. How is watching other people become rich entertaining? How is a show that is nothing but a hour long commercial (which is all Apprentice is) captivating. Mindless shows like this have legions of viewers but put something original & creative on TV & it gets a small fanbase struggling to stay on the air.
I hate sitcoms, but at least I can understand that some people just have very simply senses of humor, & they want something light & mindless. But I cannot for the life of me get the obsession with reality TV.
Also, Stargate. The reality TV scenario also applies here. Cliche, never takes any risks (yes I've seen a fair amount of the show), redundant, & extremely boring, yet it's one the air for 8-9 seasons? Farscape is the total oppositie in every way, actually makes an effort to break the sci-fi cliches, & that gets cancelled.
Especially shows like Survivor, Apprentice, American Idol (which I just saw my first 10 minutes of & it's so fake it's pathetic). How is this shit entertaining? There are brilliant shows on TV like Carnivale, the new Battlestar Galactica (which is at least getting some attention here), & a new episode of Survivor & Apprentice come around, & they get pages of discussion & analyzing like they are the most intricate novels ever written. How is watching other people become rich entertaining? How is a show that is nothing but a hour long commercial (which is all Apprentice is) captivating. Mindless shows like this have legions of viewers but put something original & creative on TV & it gets a small fanbase struggling to stay on the air.
I hate sitcoms, but at least I can understand that some people just have very simply senses of humor, & they want something light & mindless. But I cannot for the life of me get the obsession with reality TV.
Also, Stargate. The reality TV scenario also applies here. Cliche, never takes any risks (yes I've seen a fair amount of the show), redundant, & extremely boring, yet it's one the air for 8-9 seasons? Farscape is the total oppositie in every way, actually makes an effort to break the sci-fi cliches, & that gets cancelled.
#18
DVD Talk God
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Posts: 130,869
Received 693 Likes
on
563 Posts
In defense of Survivor - I think people watch it more because of the game show than the 'reality' aspects of it. The strategy of it provides for good discussion - like watching a sporting event.
#19
Moderator
Originally Posted by latenight
Don't get me wrong, I love tv. I just happen to feel that over the last 15 years, (for the most part) it has gone down the tubes.
In the past 15 years we have had the following shows aired:
Twin Peaks
Seinfeld
Cheers
Frasier
The X-Files
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Sports Night
The West Wing
Law and Order
Angel
The Simpsons
Deadwood
Monk
And many others, most of which I didn't list because I just don't/haven't watched them much.
#21
DVD Talk Hero
• latenight •
Don't get me wrong, I love tv. I just happen to feel that over the last 15 years, (for the most part) it has gone down the tubes.
Don't get me wrong, I love tv. I just happen to feel that over the last 15 years, (for the most part) it has gone down the tubes.
das
#22
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by wendersfan
I disagree. The trouble is that there are currently more networks offering original programming than ever before, but there's just so much talent to go around. Therefore, as a percentage of total broadcasts, the quality of TV might be lower now than ever, but the total number of quality shows is (at least) comparable to any other time in TV's history.
In the past 15 years we have had the following shows aired:
Twin Peaks
Seinfeld
Cheers
Frasier
The X-Files
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Sports Night
The West Wing
Law and Order
Angel
The Simpsons
Deadwood
Monk
And many others, most of which I didn't list because I just don't/haven't watched them much.
In the past 15 years we have had the following shows aired:
Twin Peaks
Seinfeld
Cheers
Frasier
The X-Files
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Sports Night
The West Wing
Law and Order
Angel
The Simpsons
Deadwood
Monk
And many others, most of which I didn't list because I just don't/haven't watched them much.
The Shield and NYPD Blue, not counting the Rick Schroder years, deserve to be up there.
#23
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: The Big Easy
Posts: 1,062
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by wendersfan
I disagree. The trouble is that there are currently more networks offering original programming than ever before, but there's just so much talent to go around. Therefore, as a percentage of total broadcasts, the quality of TV might be lower now than ever, but the total number of quality shows is (at least) comparable to any other time in TV's history.
In the past 15 years we have had the following shows aired:
Twin Peaks
Seinfeld
Cheers
Frasier
The X-Files
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Sports Night
The West Wing
Law and Order
Angel
The Simpsons
Deadwood
Monk
And many others, most of which I didn't list because I just don't/haven't watched them much.
In the past 15 years we have had the following shows aired:
Twin Peaks
Seinfeld
Cheers
Frasier
The X-Files
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Sports Night
The West Wing
Law and Order
Angel
The Simpsons
Deadwood
Monk
And many others, most of which I didn't list because I just don't/haven't watched them much.
#25
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
It just gets to me when you look at the tv landscape and see crap like what's mentioned in this thread - other than SG-1 and then look at what could be on the air:
Sports Night
Freaks & Geeks
Undeclared
Andy Rictor Controls the Universe
..and even Titus
And more I know I'm forgetting.
So I don't think lack of a talent pool is an issue, all of these shows had great casts, writing, & directing. It is all about the quick buck instead of developing a following anymore. This season has been great for a tv comeback with Lost, Deperate Housewives, and Arrested Development (giving it a chance to develop a following).
Sports Night
Freaks & Geeks
Undeclared
Andy Rictor Controls the Universe
..and even Titus
And more I know I'm forgetting.
So I don't think lack of a talent pool is an issue, all of these shows had great casts, writing, & directing. It is all about the quick buck instead of developing a following anymore. This season has been great for a tv comeback with Lost, Deperate Housewives, and Arrested Development (giving it a chance to develop a following).