Survivor All-Stars - 4/8/04
#26
New Member
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 13
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Although I was rooting for Mogo Mogo all along, everyone on that tribe has played so stupidly that nobody from there deserves to win. Strangely, I do have some faith in Kathy to mix things up next week. I'm glad she kept her immunity because she already has some rapport with the original Chapera (although that's probably not worth much seeing how things turned out tonight) and she has a better chance of getting some of them over to her side than Lex would.
I sure hope Rupert gets a clue. Didn't he once say (on the Pearl Islands) that he was the best Survivor ever? From a pure "survival" aspect and physical strength/being good at challenges, maybe, but as far as the "people" side of the game, the guy hasn't got a single clue! C'mon Rupert - wise up to Rob and Amber's plan already!!!
I sure hope Rupert gets a clue. Didn't he once say (on the Pearl Islands) that he was the best Survivor ever? From a pure "survival" aspect and physical strength/being good at challenges, maybe, but as far as the "people" side of the game, the guy hasn't got a single clue! C'mon Rupert - wise up to Rob and Amber's plan already!!!
#27
New Member
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 13
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by the action
I just don't understand why Rob couldn't just vote off Shii Ann instead of Lex and consider that his favor.
I just don't understand why Rob couldn't just vote off Shii Ann instead of Lex and consider that his favor.
#28
Originally posted by chandler_smythe
It's called EGO. Rob had to make sure that he made it known to the old Mogo Mogo that HE was the one calling the shots in this game.
It's called EGO. Rob had to make sure that he made it known to the old Mogo Mogo that HE was the one calling the shots in this game.
#29
DVD Talk Hero
Lex pulled the "you cant vote me, it's about friendship" speech--but he's just a victim of EXACTLY what he did to Ethan... same speech too
#31
DVD Talk God
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 133,095
Received 893 Likes
on
737 Posts
From: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Amber survives another week! 
I thought the same exact thing. Granted, I don't think they had the same 'deal' as we saw here.
Boston Rob's excuse to Lex (I did what I could) was lame particularly given Amber's hesitance to vote for Lex. I was really rooting for Lex to win that challenge since it would have made next week that much more interesting. Plus I still don't this informing the chicken that it is about to get its head cut off. Boston Rob is in real trouble (2 sure votes against) if he gets to the final-2. Same with Amber.
Kathy (with Shi-Ann) really have to work on Alicia, Rupert and Jenna (2 of 3) next week.

Lex pulled the "you cant vote me, it's about friendship" speech--but he's just a victim of EXACTLY what he did to Ethan... same speech too
Boston Rob's excuse to Lex (I did what I could) was lame particularly given Amber's hesitance to vote for Lex. I was really rooting for Lex to win that challenge since it would have made next week that much more interesting. Plus I still don't this informing the chicken that it is about to get its head cut off. Boston Rob is in real trouble (2 sure votes against) if he gets to the final-2. Same with Amber.
Kathy (with Shi-Ann) really have to work on Alicia, Rupert and Jenna (2 of 3) next week.
#34
Senior Member
Joined: May 2001
Posts: 509
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Texas
I certainly do, Jackskeleton.
Rob must go. Not because he's physically the strongest, but because he's the most arrogant.
I could tolerate him before the episode when he went out and speared a bunch of fish to just show up Rupert. After that, I thought he was a complete jackass.
Besides, everyone else has to see that the Rob/Amber alliance is too strong once it got down to the final three. It has to be broken up well before that.
Rob must go. Not because he's physically the strongest, but because he's the most arrogant.
I could tolerate him before the episode when he went out and speared a bunch of fish to just show up Rupert. After that, I thought he was a complete jackass.
Besides, everyone else has to see that the Rob/Amber alliance is too strong once it got down to the final three. It has to be broken up well before that.
#35
DVD Talk Hero
Does this make Lex the biggest tool in Survivor history?
#36
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Good episode. Rupert has good taste in women. He picked two of the best looking girls there (Jenna and Amber) to spent the night with him after reward challenge.
I'm glad Lex is gone. He's not smart for voting out Colby and Ethan. Then he made the mistake of not voting out Amber. Now he paid the price.
I'm liking Amber more and more now. I didn't care much for her in Survivor : Australia. But she's hanging in there by a thread and is someone to root for.
I'm glad Lex is gone. He's not smart for voting out Colby and Ethan. Then he made the mistake of not voting out Amber. Now he paid the price.
I'm liking Amber more and more now. I didn't care much for her in Survivor : Australia. But she's hanging in there by a thread and is someone to root for.
#37
What a hypocrite. Lex is always talking about how the game is the game, but friendship is something outside of the game. He screws Colby and then Ethan and starts whining when Rob takes him out? Cry me a river.
And that crap about him sacrificing his "plan" to help Rob is such bullshit. He votes out Amber, and he's gone tonight anyway. His tribe didn't have numbers, plain and simple. Keeping Amber presents the chance to hang around for a while if they form a new alliance, but voting her out guaranteed his death. What a turd.
das
And that crap about him sacrificing his "plan" to help Rob is such bullshit. He votes out Amber, and he's gone tonight anyway. His tribe didn't have numbers, plain and simple. Keeping Amber presents the chance to hang around for a while if they form a new alliance, but voting her out guaranteed his death. What a turd.
das
#39
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Originally posted by the action
I doesn't really matter they would have been F'ed keeping Jerri. I just don't understand why Rob couldn't just vote off Shii Ann instead of Lex and consider that his favor. I did enjoy Lex's face when Kathy said she was keeping it.
I doesn't really matter they would have been F'ed keeping Jerri. I just don't understand why Rob couldn't just vote off Shii Ann instead of Lex and consider that his favor. I did enjoy Lex's face when Kathy said she was keeping it.
#40
Moderator
On one hand, I thought it was nice of Rob to sit down with Lex and explain what was going to happen, and stress that their friendship was still important. But to stand up and shout "YOU GOT SERVED!" after Lex was voted off? That went a bit too far, IMHO.
#41
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by das Monkey
What a hypocrite. Lex is always talking about how the game is the game, but friendship is something outside of the game. He screws Colby and then Ethan and starts whining when Rob takes him out? Cry me a river.
What a hypocrite. Lex is always talking about how the game is the game, but friendship is something outside of the game. He screws Colby and then Ethan and starts whining when Rob takes him out? Cry me a river.
This surprises me not.
#42
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Poor Lex, I thought he was pretty cool. A shame his plan didn't work, but from where I was standing,t hat was kind of obvious. You'd think Rob would have at least given some sort of favor though.
#44
Banned
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 6,733
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: USA
Originally posted by Josh-da-man
Does this make Lex the biggest tool in Survivor history?
Does this make Lex the biggest tool in Survivor history?
Last edited by icondude; 04-09-04 at 08:04 AM.
#45
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 1999
Posts: 317
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Boston, MA, USA
All these people have played this game before you'ld think they would would have half a clue. You can't trust ANYONE! Lex... You idiot!! Rupert WAKE UP!!
I still think Colby taking Tina to the finals down under was a bigger goof than what Lex did on this season.
I still think Colby taking Tina to the finals down under was a bigger goof than what Lex did on this season.
#46
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Where is Johnny Fairplay when you need him? As much as I could not stand him, Rob has now passed him in my hatred of a cast member. I agree with Baring's sentiments on Rob, I liked him until the spearing incident, now he is acting like a bigger jackass than Fairplay did.
Hopefully the other survivors wake up and realize Rob and Amber must be the next 2 to go.
Hopefully the other survivors wake up and realize Rob and Amber must be the next 2 to go.
#47
DVD Talk Hero
Next week, Omarosa is added to the tribe!!
#49
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 1,806
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Arlington, VA
How comes big Tom didnt step in for Lex though? With lex + the other 2 girls, plus big Tom and Rubert + Jenna, they could have easily flipped the tables on Rob and Amber if they would just realize how much control those 2 have.
Most of the other seasons there has always been some power-struggling with the last 9 or 10 people, hopefully this year will be the same.
Most of the other seasons there has always been some power-struggling with the last 9 or 10 people, hopefully this year will be the same.
#50
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
And how about that Kathy, saying she's giving Lex her immunity and then "I've thought about it, but I'm keeping it"--? Of course Lex said, "Oh no, don't do that," when he should've just said, "OK thanks..."



