Joan of Arcadia 2/13/04
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
Joan of Arcadia 2/13/04
This episode got really hurtful.
Luke is just exploding inside, totally distracted. When prodded by Kevin about why Luke is acting so strange, Luke unleashes some pent up anger towards him that marginalizes Kevin into a "big bad bully"/"super star high school athlete" who could do no wrong and got what he deserved (when Kevin got paralyzed) and Luke admitted to being happy when the accident happened to Kevin. That was a chilling scene as it played out. I'm not quite sure why Luke is in such a funk, though.
Will is still on edge from all the fallout from what's happened to him in the past 6 months. While investigating a tip, Will draws his weapons and almost shoots a little girl. The sheriff recommends counselling, and, instead, Will turns in his badge and gun as a kneejerk reaction. Will finally accepts that he needs help in dealing with his issues, but he's torn up inside from it all.
God tells Joan to go help children afterschool (to boost her resume, of course), and there she comes across Iris who is helping with taking care of children while their mothers are in therapy for domestic violence. Iris catches Adam's eye. Joan had asked Adam to get some concert tickets, but then she couldn't go due to the afterschool gig, so Adam asks Iris to go, which drives Joan a little crazy. Adam falls for Iris rather quickly, and Iris is emotionally "there" to pursue a relationship with Adam, unlike Joan, but seeing Adam with Iris hurts Joan because she's sitting on the sidelines because she doesn't know how to accept Adam as-is, nor how to be his girlfriend.
Joan does the idiotic when she succumbs the children's wish to build a pinata so they can beat the crap out of it. Iris returns to see this activity in full force, and is appalled by Joan's lack of sensitivity, considering that battery and violence is why these children's mothers had to bring them while getting counselling for domestic violence. Joan allowed this because she was trying to one-up Iris for getting too close to Adam, and comes away a smaller person for giving in and not thinking of others.
On a spurious note, Kevin and Rebecca get busy, not letting a broken elevator ruin the rest of their evening, and Kevin allowed Rebecca "into" his world as their attraction for one another grows, as does their intimacy level.
Helen is all abuzzed about being the new art teacher and some of her criteria for art might get her in trouble down the road when she has to hand out grades because she's probably too encouraging in accepting some of the art assignments so far.
Luke is just exploding inside, totally distracted. When prodded by Kevin about why Luke is acting so strange, Luke unleashes some pent up anger towards him that marginalizes Kevin into a "big bad bully"/"super star high school athlete" who could do no wrong and got what he deserved (when Kevin got paralyzed) and Luke admitted to being happy when the accident happened to Kevin. That was a chilling scene as it played out. I'm not quite sure why Luke is in such a funk, though.
Will is still on edge from all the fallout from what's happened to him in the past 6 months. While investigating a tip, Will draws his weapons and almost shoots a little girl. The sheriff recommends counselling, and, instead, Will turns in his badge and gun as a kneejerk reaction. Will finally accepts that he needs help in dealing with his issues, but he's torn up inside from it all.
God tells Joan to go help children afterschool (to boost her resume, of course), and there she comes across Iris who is helping with taking care of children while their mothers are in therapy for domestic violence. Iris catches Adam's eye. Joan had asked Adam to get some concert tickets, but then she couldn't go due to the afterschool gig, so Adam asks Iris to go, which drives Joan a little crazy. Adam falls for Iris rather quickly, and Iris is emotionally "there" to pursue a relationship with Adam, unlike Joan, but seeing Adam with Iris hurts Joan because she's sitting on the sidelines because she doesn't know how to accept Adam as-is, nor how to be his girlfriend.
Joan does the idiotic when she succumbs the children's wish to build a pinata so they can beat the crap out of it. Iris returns to see this activity in full force, and is appalled by Joan's lack of sensitivity, considering that battery and violence is why these children's mothers had to bring them while getting counselling for domestic violence. Joan allowed this because she was trying to one-up Iris for getting too close to Adam, and comes away a smaller person for giving in and not thinking of others.
On a spurious note, Kevin and Rebecca get busy, not letting a broken elevator ruin the rest of their evening, and Kevin allowed Rebecca "into" his world as their attraction for one another grows, as does their intimacy level.
Helen is all abuzzed about being the new art teacher and some of her criteria for art might get her in trouble down the road when she has to hand out grades because she's probably too encouraging in accepting some of the art assignments so far.
#2
Guest
I thought it was a pretty good episode last night and Iris is quite beautiful, though her voice is a little irratating. I saw nothing wrong with the pinata, since it was God's way of helping Iris to open up about her past.
I'm glad Kevin understood why Luke said he was happy when Kevin was paralyzed. I could feel his anger at always being in the shadow of his older brother. That is probably one of the reason why he is an overacheiver. But it's good that he got his feelings out now and hopefully we can come to terms with it, before it gets really bad. There are a lot of new things going on in Luke's life (girls) and he is having trouble understanding it all.
Chris
I'm glad Kevin understood why Luke said he was happy when Kevin was paralyzed. I could feel his anger at always being in the shadow of his older brother. That is probably one of the reason why he is an overacheiver. But it's good that he got his feelings out now and hopefully we can come to terms with it, before it gets really bad. There are a lot of new things going on in Luke's life (girls) and he is having trouble understanding it all.
Chris
#4
DVD Talk Reviewer
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 15,094
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: WAS looking for My Own Private Stuckeyville, but stuck in Liberty City (while missing Vice City)
Re: Joan of Arcadia 2/13/04
Originally posted by Patman
Joan does the idiotic when she succumbs the children's wish to build a pinata so they can beat the crap out of it. Iris returns to see this activity in full force, and is appalled by Joan's lack of sensitivity, considering that battery and violence is why these children's mothers had to bring them while getting counselling for domestic violence.
Joan does the idiotic when she succumbs the children's wish to build a pinata so they can beat the crap out of it. Iris returns to see this activity in full force, and is appalled by Joan's lack of sensitivity, considering that battery and violence is why these children's mothers had to bring them while getting counselling for domestic violence.

BTW...for those who might not know...God's dog-walking incarnation was played by Amber's real-life dad [and star of West Side Story & Twin Peaks].
#5
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Dec 1999
Posts: 7,103
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Number Nine Ville
Re: Re: Joan of Arcadia 2/13/04
Originally posted by Rogue588
BTW...for those who might not know...God's dog-walking incarnation was played by Amber's real-life dad [and star of West Side Story & Twin Peaks].
BTW...for those who might not know...God's dog-walking incarnation was played by Amber's real-life dad [and star of West Side Story & Twin Peaks].
#6
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Very good episode. I wish I had time to lay out some more comments but other posters have done it well. I think things are going to get more interesting now that Adam and Kevin have had this low point.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 20,195
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
7 Posts
From: Sesame Street (the apt. next to Bob's)
Re: Re: Re: Joan of Arcadia 2/13/04
Originally posted by IdgIe49
cool. I saw the last name in the credits, but was looking for a young male person.
cool. I saw the last name in the credits, but was looking for a young male person.
#9
DVD Talk Hero
I agree with pretty much everything that's been said.
Alot of venom in this episode. I thought Luke's was especially vicious.
Iris's would have been better if they would have had someone who could act play the part. I'm glad Adam's with her though. Joan and Adam together doesn't seem right.
Alot of venom in this episode. I thought Luke's was especially vicious.
Iris's would have been better if they would have had someone who could act play the part. I'm glad Adam's with her though. Joan and Adam together doesn't seem right.
#14
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 3,193
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by bigsoos
My fiancee and I were so confused when we were watching the show. I suppose her dad and lil bro got all kooky in between the 2/6 and the 2/13 show?
My fiancee and I were so confused when we were watching the show. I suppose her dad and lil bro got all kooky in between the 2/6 and the 2/13 show?
Luke's revelation did seem a bit out of the blue, but I guess if you keep something like that buried inside you, you don't really know when it'll come to the surface. (The same sort of thing happened with Kevin when he had his breakdown in family conseling several weeks ago at the end of an episode.)
#15
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
For Luke, it could be puberty kicking in, and perceiving Kevin to be acting in the same hurtful jock-ish way before the accident (now that's he's got his own mojo back with Rebecca).




