DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Opinions on Firefly (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/335167-opinions-firefly.html)

Deke Rivers 12-18-03 05:29 AM

hey..by the 15th I was just answering the persons question about what I considered dark..I was NOT still asking opinions about the show at that point which was pretty obvious..and why does all things Sci-Fi have to be connected to Star Trek all the time?

and you keep using the word "we" even though YOU are the only person who had any issues with my questions ..probably because of my anti- Star Trek thing which is very very sad..get a life ..if you have nothing good to contribute then dont post at all.

Wizdar 12-18-03 08:27 AM

Anybody who hates Trek can suck my nuts.

No, WAIT! I'd rather not have them touch my junk. I might get cooties.



Hey, das I didn't know you wore rubber ears?

Deke Rivers 12-18-03 09:02 AM

judging by your response i dont think you have any nuts . Do your parents know you are on the PC there Junior?

Chew 12-18-03 09:17 AM

Chew pulls up a chair and pops some corn.........

Deke Rivers 12-18-03 09:26 AM


Originally posted by Chew
Chew pulls up a chair and pops some corn.........
you're killin me Chew! :)

Captain Harlock 12-18-03 10:39 AM

Joss Whedon got the idea from Outlaw Star
 
When I first heard about Firefly I said to myself "this looks familiar". A sci-fi western about a group of misfits wandering around space in a ship with a girl they find in a suitcase? I'm thinking somewhere along the line Joss Whedon saw the anime series Outlaw Star that aired a year eariler on Cartoon Network and thought this would make a good series.

Wizdar 12-18-03 10:48 AM

Wizdar checks his ID, pops open a coupla brewskies, hands one to Chew

;)

das Monkey 12-18-03 10:56 AM

<BLOCKQUOTE> • Quoth Wizdar •<HR SIZE=1>Hey, das I didn't know you wore rubber ears? <HR SIZE=1></BLOCKQUOTE>
Oh yeah ... rubber ears, blue science officer jumpsuit, black boots, and all. Someone made fun of my outfit at the mall yesterday while I was looking for rare toys at KB, so I gave him the Vulcan Death Grip. Yeah, I know there's no such thing, but I figured <i>this</i> joker wouldn't know that, so I'd be OK. Clearly, it was a tactical error, because ... well, let's just say I'm going to need more rubber ears. I can't tell you how embarrassed I was that when he broke my nose, my blood was red instead of green. I inject green food coloring into my bloodstream daily, but apparently the effort was ... are you ready ... <i>in vein</i>.

Oh well ... TR3K R00LZ!!!

Science Officer das

Wizdar 12-18-03 11:36 AM

rotfl

Chew 12-18-03 11:53 AM

:lol::up:

Houstondon 12-18-03 03:46 PM

Re: Joss Whedon got the idea from Outlaw Star
 

Originally posted by Captain Harlock
When I first heard about Firefly I said to myself "this looks familiar". A sci-fi western about a group of misfits wandering around space in a ship with a girl they find in a suitcase? I'm thinking somewhere along the line Joss Whedon saw the anime series Outlaw Star that aired a year eariler on Cartoon Network and thought this would make a good series.
The sources for the basic premise come a long time prior to Outlaw Star (a fun series by the way) and have been done many times before, in Manga, other anime series, other mainstream movies and shows too.

On another note, thanks for the compliment Das and would everyone calm down about the Trek Vs Firefly issues? If you don't like a particular show, there's no reason to attack someone else's taste (liking Trek doesn't make someone Satan anymore than preferring Buffy or whatever other fantasy show makes someone a goofus).

slop101 12-18-03 04:23 PM

I still like Farscape MUCH better than Firefly (or Star Trek for that matter).

Wizdar 12-18-03 05:30 PM

I was very critical of Firefly when it aired, probably due to the way Fox presented it. The light never went on for me until they showed “Serenity.”

I ordered the set without a second thought. It’s different, to be sure. Having watched everything, I’ve seen the light, especially after Adam Baldwin’s rendition of “Hero of Canton.”



But I’m not saluting das. I don’t care what uniform he’s wearing. (OK. After a few beers, I might consider something a la Red Dwarf or 3rd Rock.)

Static Cling 12-18-03 07:12 PM


Originally posted by Deke Rivers
if you have nothing good to contribute then dont post at all.
Sound advice. See you in a week!

Mourn 12-18-03 08:04 PM

If the movie doesnt suck like all Whedon's movies (that i've seen), then i'll buy the series.

Kevin M. Dean 12-18-03 08:35 PM


Originally posted by Mourn
If the movie doesnt suck like all Whedon's movies (that i've seen), then i'll buy the series.
I thought Toy Story was rather successful.

Jay G. 12-18-03 08:54 PM

It's rather unfair to judge Joss Whedon on the movies made from his scripts, since they really aren't his movies. As a screenwriter on a film, his status is just above the Best Boy's, and his creative control is nil. Contrast that with his TV shows, where he's Executive Producer and has near maximum creative control. The Firefly movie, if he were to direct, would really be the first Joss Whedon film.

Wizdar 12-18-03 09:04 PM


Originally posted by Mourn
If the movie doesnt suck like all Whedon's movies (that i've seen), then i'll buy the series.
That’s got to be the weirdest thing I’ve read in a while.

Chances are, it’ll blow, unless the suits let him make a movie that’ll appeal to a very narrow audience. That doesn’t sound like Hollywood to me.

I don’t think Firefly had the exposure to develop a broad fan base, unlike Farscape. Nor did it seem to be something aimed at the usual SF crowd.

At the risk of having a tricorder shoved up my ass (;)), could it be one of those movies that eventually becomes a “SciFi Original”?

Jay G. 12-18-03 09:17 PM


Originally posted by Wizdar
Chances are, it’ll blow, unless the suits let him make a movie that’ll appeal to a very narrow audience.
Why do you think Firefly only appeals to a very narrow audience? I think Firefly has the potential for a much wider audience, if the movie is done well. "The Train Job" showed that Joss could effectively re-introduce the characters without repeating the pilot "Serenity." I don't see why he can't do the same again.

das Monkey 12-18-03 10:12 PM

Tread carefully, <b>Wizdar</b> ... tricorders have a lot of protruding knobs and buttons ...

das

moocher 12-18-03 10:38 PM


Originally posted by Jay G.
Why do you think Firefly only appeals to a very narrow audience? I think Firefly has the potential for a much wider audience, if the movie is done well.
True. I know many who hate sci-fi (including my wife) but who love Firefly. I also know many who love sci-fi (like me) who also love Firefly. Its one of those odd shows that if given a chance, could appeal to a wide audience.

Wizdar 12-18-03 10:55 PM

Well, take comfort in the knowledge that I’m frequently wrong.


Originally posted by das Monkey
tricorders have a lot of protruding knobs and buttons ...
[Wizdar giggles like a schoolgirl.]

Moving to Mature.

MrBob 12-19-03 04:37 PM

I bought this a couple of days ago and have almost finished the first 2 disks. I didn't get to catch most of the series when it aired originally. I must say this show is much better than I remembered. What has been the most pleasent suprise has to be the humor of the show. They don't have a lot of jokes but when they say something funny it is damn funny.

My favorite one liner is this:

Jane: "Do you know what the chain of command is? It's the chain out back that I get to beat you with until you learn that I'm in command!" LOL

bdshort 12-19-03 06:46 PM

I think I may pick this up after Christmas. I loved the series, but had actually forgotten it was coming out on DVD :o

Are the episodes on the discs in chronological order, or in the order than FOX aired them?

Brian

Chew 12-19-03 08:39 PM


Originally posted by bdshort
Are the episodes on the discs in chronological order, or in the order than FOX aired them?
They're in proper order.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:42 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.