Carnivale Pilot Episode
#1
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: The White Lodge
Posts: 1,743
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Carnivale Pilot Episode
HALLELUJAH!
Atmospheric as can be I felt like I was watching a collaboration between John Carpenter and David Lynch.
This is the kind of TV I have been waiting for.
Atmospheric as can be I felt like I was watching a collaboration between John Carpenter and David Lynch.
This is the kind of TV I have been waiting for.
#2
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
It's hard to judge a series based on the pilot, where everything is biuld-up, but this definately peaked my interest.
***Spoilers***
I'm glad that Clancy Brown's character seems more of a conflicted person than the stereotypical evil preacher.
The audience is apparently supposed to assume that Nick Stahl is that generation's embodiment of good, while Brown is the embodiment of evil, but it wouldn't surprise me if there was a twist later on that revealed just the opposite. The biggest hint for that was how much death was actually caused around Stahl (in the crops) when he healed the girl's legs. IMHO.
I look forward to next week.
***Spoilers***
I'm glad that Clancy Brown's character seems more of a conflicted person than the stereotypical evil preacher.
The audience is apparently supposed to assume that Nick Stahl is that generation's embodiment of good, while Brown is the embodiment of evil, but it wouldn't surprise me if there was a twist later on that revealed just the opposite. The biggest hint for that was how much death was actually caused around Stahl (in the crops) when he healed the girl's legs. IMHO.
I look forward to next week.
#3
DVD Talk Hero
Kind of hard to judge just with the first episode, but I'm definitely interested.
I was a bit surprised to see a television series paced out like a novel. Quite literally, this entire episode could be seen as the first chapter of a book, with the small snippets of the preacher as short interludes that hint of a larger scope coming later.
Also interesting to see Tarot cards used reasonably accurately in a film/television series.
I was a bit surprised to see a television series paced out like a novel. Quite literally, this entire episode could be seen as the first chapter of a book, with the small snippets of the preacher as short interludes that hint of a larger scope coming later.
Also interesting to see Tarot cards used reasonably accurately in a film/television series.
#4
DVD Talk Legend
It was a little slow but hey...it has to set everything up. I am definitely interested it catching it next week.
It looked great on HBO-HD. The 5.1 had quite a bit of surround use & rumble as well.
It looked great on HBO-HD. The 5.1 had quite a bit of surround use & rumble as well.
#6
Guest
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: Glendale, next to L.A.
Posts: 18,484
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
The most impressive thing about this series so far, is the wonderful recreation of the times (1934) with regards to the clothing and especially the sets (buildings, cars, etc.) When you compare this to other HBO series, it looks like they have to go thru a lot more trouble to get the proper effect for the period and time.
I wonder if that little girl was running away with the Carnivale at the end? They kind of left that in the open! Pretty good first episode and I think we shall see more good stuff in the remaining 11 episodes.
Chris
I wonder if that little girl was running away with the Carnivale at the end? They kind of left that in the open! Pretty good first episode and I think we shall see more good stuff in the remaining 11 episodes.
Chris
#7
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Originally posted by Josh-da-man
Also interesting to see Tarot cards used reasonably accurately in a film/television series.
Also interesting to see Tarot cards used reasonably accurately in a film/television series.
Kudos to the writers.
#9
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
I'm undecided so far. It shows promise.
A few random thoughts:
Liked the opening credits. Maybe they were done by the same folks who did Boomtown last year? Too bad the theme is so boring, though
Was I the only one who expected the dwarf to start talking backwards in the opening shot?
It was driving me nuts trying to figure out who the Preacher was. Thanks for the name. I guess I recognized him from Shawshank. Thanks to IMDB, I now know that he's the voice for both Mr Krabs and Dr Neo Cortex. Cool!
Just like any 80's horror fan, I'm happy to see Adrienne Barbeau get some work. Didn't do much in the pilot
A few random thoughts:
Liked the opening credits. Maybe they were done by the same folks who did Boomtown last year? Too bad the theme is so boring, though
Was I the only one who expected the dwarf to start talking backwards in the opening shot?
It was driving me nuts trying to figure out who the Preacher was. Thanks for the name. I guess I recognized him from Shawshank. Thanks to IMDB, I now know that he's the voice for both Mr Krabs and Dr Neo Cortex. Cool!
Just like any 80's horror fan, I'm happy to see Adrienne Barbeau get some work. Didn't do much in the pilot
Spoiler:
#11
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Phoenix, Arizona
Posts: 2,278
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I really enjoyed the first episode and will be tuning in for quite awhile. This show looks to have a ton of promise.
I agree about the production value; it's top-notch.
I agree about the production value; it's top-notch.
#12
DVD Talk Hero
• Quoth Tom Banjo •<HR SIZE=1>
The audience is apparently supposed to assume that Nick Stahl is that generation's embodiment of good, while Brown is the embodiment of evil<HR SIZE=1>
It doesn't seem that way to me. In fact, most of the scenes with Crowe cast him positively; while many of the scenes with Hawkins were negative. It's just two characters ... I didn't get any feeling that they were trying to cast them one-dimensionally or misdirect the audience.
Btw, everyone keeps calling this the pilot. I thought the pilot was a couple years ago. This is just the premiere.
Hard to make any judgment on this introduction to the series other than I get the feeling I'm really going to enjoy it. I was a bit annoyed at the language they used as it seemed too modern, but they really captured the setting well in every other way. In fact, as the episode drew to a close, I almost felt dirty from all that dust.
I've been looking forward to this (and Deadwood) for what must be a couple of years now, so it's great to finally get underway. I can't wait to get deeper into the story in the coming weeks.
das
#13
Banned
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: The Land Of The "Governator"
Posts: 154
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by das Monkey
Btw, everyone keeps calling this the pilot. I thought the pilot was a couple years ago. This is just the premiere.
#14
DVD Talk Hero
The cured girl at the end running was not running to catch up with the carnivale, but rather, she was showing that Ben's powers don't come without a price, which appear to be that use of his gift to cure take away life elsewhere (in this sequence, the plant life in the fields that the girl ran past turned dark and died).
#15
DVD Talk Hero
• Quoth FranksAndBeans •<HR SIZE=1>Very interesting. Do tell. I did some searching on the net, but I couldn't find any information about this. <HR SIZE=1>
Not sure what there is to tell or if it's interesting. Like most shows, unless my memory is mistaken, they shot a pilot a couple years ago, it went over well, they changed some things (I think they added Crowe's sister) and then produced a series for which last night's episode was the premiere.
das
#17
DVD Talk Hero
• Quoth cliffzig •<HR SIZE=1>Can someone figure out the date/time of the replay? Missed last nights <HR SIZE=1>
http://www.hbo.com/carnivale/
das
#18
DVD Talk Legend
I enjoyed the show and am looking forward to watching it develope. If it were on Fox I would worry about it being canceled after 4 weeks. At least HBO will support it till the end of the season.
I could have sworn I have read a book with this, or avery similar plot. Does anyone know if this is based on any previously existing work of fiction?
I could have sworn I have read a book with this, or avery similar plot. Does anyone know if this is based on any previously existing work of fiction?
#20
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: dc
Posts: 2,597
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
sadly disappointed in carnivale...
it just really bored me. i was looking forward to it, but it was just way too slow (even if it was building up for next week).
visually i loved it, but the story and characters just didn't do it for me. not your typical HBO show, IMHO. sopranos, SFU, and sex/city all peaked my interest immediately.
it just really bored me. i was looking forward to it, but it was just way too slow (even if it was building up for next week).
visually i loved it, but the story and characters just didn't do it for me. not your typical HBO show, IMHO. sopranos, SFU, and sex/city all peaked my interest immediately.
#21
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Jan 2002
Posts: 3,235
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The first 40 minutes or so bored me. When the story turned to Ben's powers, I started getting interested. I'll give it a couple more episodes to develop. I had the same initial reaction to the first season of The Wire. I toughed it out and the payoff was definitely worth it.
#22
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: The White Lodge
Posts: 1,743
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Interesting side note DAS.
What impressed me most besides the production design, credit sequence etc.. was the deliberate long takes, that permeated the room if you let them. I was choking on the dust during some scenes. The fact that the TAROT was also at long last shown in a realistic fashion on television or in film was most heartening.
Also Samson's cold tag opener was a killer.
What impressed me most besides the production design, credit sequence etc.. was the deliberate long takes, that permeated the room if you let them. I was choking on the dust during some scenes. The fact that the TAROT was also at long last shown in a realistic fashion on television or in film was most heartening.
Also Samson's cold tag opener was a killer.
#24
DVD Talk Legend
I was extremely impressed by the atmosphere on the show, and will definitely be tuning in to see how the development of the show goes. I didn't mind the slow pace because I was so drawn in by the setting.
I agree with das in that you can't tell yet which of the 2 characters will be on the side of good or evil yet. I have a question though. Did Ben resurrect the baby? The guy (I assume father) started crying, but I'm not sure if it was because he finally got to hold his dead child or because the child was alive. I'm assuming he didn't bring him back because I didn't see him use any effort like he did with the girl's legs.
I was also shocked just how many crops died to restore that girl's legs. I thought at first that 2 rows was a decent trade-off, but it looked like their entire crops were being destroyed. Could the use of such powers by Ben or other be the cause of the dustbowl?
I agree with das in that you can't tell yet which of the 2 characters will be on the side of good or evil yet. I have a question though. Did Ben resurrect the baby? The guy (I assume father) started crying, but I'm not sure if it was because he finally got to hold his dead child or because the child was alive. I'm assuming he didn't bring him back because I didn't see him use any effort like he did with the girl's legs.
I was also shocked just how many crops died to restore that girl's legs. I thought at first that 2 rows was a decent trade-off, but it looked like their entire crops were being destroyed. Could the use of such powers by Ben or other be the cause of the dustbowl?