DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   characters played by more than one actor? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/286057-characters-played-more-than-one-actor.html)

WiccanPagan 04-14-03 06:55 PM

characters played by more than one actor?
 
i was thinking of some characters i hate recently and figured they'd be more likable if the actor portraying them were different, and it got me thinking about times this actually happened. i can only think of 2, offhand:

1. topanga's dad in boy meets world. he was played by at least 2 and maybe three actors.

2. claire from my wife & kids. went into the season's end with one actress, came back with another. (great joke in that ep about her only changing her hair :lol: )

any other instances of this happening?

stevevt 04-14-03 07:16 PM

Seinfeld's parents

Darren from Bewitched

Ross' first ex-wife on friends


Edit: added the word "first."

devilshalo 04-14-03 07:50 PM

The older sister on Life Goes On.. Tracy Needham & Monique Lanier played Paige Thatcher.

The older sister on Rosanne... Alicia Goranson & Sarah Chalke played Becky Connor.

The aunt on Fresh Prince.. Janet Hubert-Whitten & Daphne Reid played Vivian Banks

On M*A*S*H*.. William Christopher and George Morgan played Father Francis Mulcahy.

inVectiVe 04-14-03 08:59 PM

Lloyd Braun from "Seinfeld."

Had one guy play him originally, then when the character came back from his nervous breakdown, he was played by I think Matt McCoy.

"Hmm......nametags - that's a good idea!"

Iron_Giant 04-15-03 12:43 AM

Justin Whalen replaced Michael Landis as Jimmy Olsen on "Lois and Clark".

chrisih8u 04-15-03 12:46 AM

Zach's dad on Saved by the Bell

Jlbkwrm 04-15-03 01:22 AM

Nikki, the Subway Slayer, over on Buffy has been played by two different people.
Ditto Victor Halliwell on Charmed
There were at least two different Kristine Kochanskis on Red Dwarf
Also on Red Dwarf, two different Krytens

Buck Turgidson 04-15-03 02:10 AM


Originally posted by Jlbkwrm

Ditto Victor Halliwell on Charmed
James Read is a big improvement over Denison. The Gypsy nurse that Emmanuelle Vaugier played earlier this season was played by a different actress when the character showed up again later.

Tom Banjo 04-15-03 02:50 AM

Dr. Who is another big one.

chowderhead 04-15-03 04:16 AM

The younger sister (before the baby) Morgan on Boy Meets World was played by two girls. I thought the first one was funny and had character. I barely remember the person who replaced her because she was boring and they never had a storyline for her.
Edit: Lily Nicksay and Lindsay Ridgeway played Morgan.

Giantrobo 04-15-03 04:36 AM

George Jefferson was played by 2 actors
Lionel Jefferson ws played by 2 actors... One Lionel was kinda uptight(Jefferson's show) and the other was cool(Original Lionel from All in the Family).

slightly off topic but not really...ON M*A*S*H, Harry Morgan played two different characters: He played a crazy General( I think) and Col Potter later in the series

das Monkey 04-15-03 06:08 AM

<BLOCKQUOTE> • Quoth chrisih8u •<HR SIZE=1>Zach's dad on Saved by the Bell <HR SIZE=1></BLOCKQUOTE>

Pardon me, pardon me folks, make way for the <I>Saved by the Bell</I> Trivia Nazi ...

Zach has two different fathers, Peter and Dereck.

das

Numanoid 04-15-03 07:42 AM

On the late '80s Superboy, John Haymes Newton played Superboy the first year, and Gerard Christopher took over for the next three.

jkingfish 04-15-03 07:45 AM

Okay, good topic, because recently I was flipping by and caught an episode of the A-Team. I was an addict as a kid but I don't remember this. Were my ears deceiving me or were they calling a different guy 'Face'? This was one of the last season episodes. Did Dirk Benedict leave the show and get a replacement?

Chew 04-15-03 07:48 AM


Originally posted by Numanoid
On the late '80s Superboy, John Haymes Newton played Superboy the first year, and Gerard Christopher took over for the next three.
-eek- Ok, it's a little scary that you would remember this. The Superboy series isn't exactly the most popular corner of the Superman universe.

Red Dog 04-15-03 08:32 AM

Catwoman in Batman - Lee Merriweather, Julie Newmar :drool:, Eartha Kitt.

das Monkey 04-15-03 08:32 AM

<BLOCKQUOTE> • Quoth jkingfish •<HR SIZE=1>Okay, good topic, because recently I was flipping by and caught an episode of the A-Team. I was an addict as a kid but I don't remember this. Were my ears deceiving me or were they calling a different guy 'Face'? This was one of the last season episodes. Did Dirk Benedict leave the show and get a replacement? <HR SIZE=1></BLOCKQUOTE>

Good call. But it's the first episode ('Mexican Slayride'). Tim Dunigan, or as I call him "That Tool From the Pilot," was Faceman in the premiere. Luckily, Cannell got his way and was able to get Benedict back and take the role he was born to play.

Tim Dunigan's title as "Lamest Thing on <I>The A-Team</I>" was mercifully spared, however, when Eddie Velez arrived on the scene as "Dishpan" Frankie Santana for the ugly 5th and final season.

das

Red Dog 04-15-03 08:42 AM

Steven on Dynasty - Al Corley and Jack Coleman.

Fallon on Dynasty - Pamela Sue Martin and Emma Samms

Miss Ellie on Dallas - Barbara Bel Geddes and Donna Reed


Soaps are, of course, notorious for this due to their long runs. Better to narrow it down to prime time soaps.

RoyalTea 04-15-03 08:44 AM

Michelle Tanner on Full House

Groucho 04-15-03 08:47 AM


Originally posted by RoyalTea
Michelle Tanner on Full House
I wouldn't call Ashley Olson an "actor." Mary Kate, on the other hand...

dgmayor 04-15-03 09:41 AM

Berg's Parents on Two Guys and a Girl (and a pizza place in the early seasons).

Father was played by Howard Hessman originally, then Steve Landesberg

Mother was played by Cheyl Ladd and then Bo Derek.

Dimension X 04-15-03 10:11 AM

Frank Gorshin and John Astin played the Riddler on Batman

George Sanders, Otto Preminger, and Eli Wallach played Mr. Freeze on Batman

Jackson Bostwick and John Davey played Captain Marvel on Shazam!

Mezzanine 04-15-03 10:50 AM

Parker's mom on Parker Lewis Can't Lose.

Numanoid 04-15-03 10:51 AM


Originally posted by Chew
-eek- Ok, it's a little scary that you would remember this. The Superboy series isn't exactly the most popular corner of the Superman universe.
C'mon! It was the Smallville of its day, only with much cheesier effects, worse acting, and far less popularity. :D

Actually, I really liked the show and you sure couldn't complain about Stacy Haiduk as Lana Lang:



http://www.supermanhomepage.com/imag...hn-stacey1.jpg

:drool:

Iron Chef 04-15-03 11:04 AM

Roman on Days of Our Lives

GuessWho 04-15-03 11:30 AM

Dick Sargent & Dick York played same character on Bewitched.

jmaxlow 04-16-03 07:44 AM


Originally posted by devilshalo
The older sister on Rosanne... Alicia Goranson & Sarah Chalke played Becky Connor.
DJ was also played by a different actor for one episode, which I believe was the pilot.

Harriet on Family Matters was played by a second actress during the final season.

Jboone 04-16-03 09:16 PM

There were two different actresses portraying Gladys Kravitz on 'Bewitched'.

zooiiks 04-17-03 01:50 PM

On Happy Days, Richie's older brother Chuck was played by not 1, not 2, but THREE different actors during the first season. He was then unceremoniously written out of the show only to leave us to wonder if Chuck really did exist in the first place.

rkndkn 04-17-03 02:09 PM

David Ackroyd originated the role of Gary Ewing on "Dallas", but Ted Shackelford continued the role on "Knots Landing". Really took me a long time to get used to Ted.

rycki1138 03-20-12 07:58 PM

Re: characters played by more than one actor?
 

Originally Posted by Giantrobo (Post 3543288)
George Jefferson was played by 2 actors

Actually George Jefferson was only played by Sherman Hemsley. They did have another actor, Mel Stewart, on All in the Family when the Jeffersons first moved in, but he played Henry Jefferson, George's brother. The producers wanted Sherman Hemsley for the role of George and he wasn't available at the time so they brought in Mel Stewart to play his brother for a few episodes until Sherman Hemsley became available. It was strange that his brother Henry was never seen or mentioned again even on The Jeffersons.

Deftones 03-20-12 08:18 PM

Re: characters played by more than one actor?
 
weirdest bump ever?

Cardsfan111 03-20-12 09:29 PM

Re: characters played by more than one actor?
 

Originally Posted by Deftones (Post 11159841)
weirdest bump ever?

No doubt. The fact that it was 9 years ago is strange. But that it was by someone who has been a member for nearly 5 years and hasn't posted since that time makes it extra-bizarre.

Fill us in, rycki. What brought you back to address the long-standing George Jefferson quandary? Also, we've missed you. :wave:

Drexl 03-20-12 09:41 PM

Re: characters played by more than one actor?
 
The thread is so old, it predates the multiple Martas on Arrested Development.

Abob Teff 03-20-12 10:01 PM

Re: characters played by more than one actor?
 

Originally Posted by zooiiks (Post 3553073)
On Happy Days, Richie's older brother Chuck was played by not 1, not 2, but THREE different actors during the first season. He was then unceremoniously written out of the show only to leave us to wonder if Chuck really did exist in the first place.

Nine years later this post serves a purpose ... I now understand the "Jimmy was Chuck Cunningham'd" post in the Walking Dead threads. I honestly never knew this.

whotony 03-20-12 10:05 PM

Re: characters played by more than one actor?
 

Originally Posted by Giantrobo (Post 3543288)
George Jefferson was played by 2 actors
Lionel Jefferson ws played by 2 actors... One Lionel was kinda uptight(Jefferson's show) and the other was cool(Original Lionel from All in the Family).

slightly off topic but not really...ON M*A*S*H, Harry Morgan played two different characters: He played a crazy General( I think) and Col Potter later in the series


Originally Posted by rycki1138 (Post 11159820)
Actually George Jefferson was only played by Sherman Hemsley. They did have another actor, Mel Stewart, on All in the Family when the Jeffersons first moved in, but he played Henry Jefferson, George's brother. The producers wanted Sherman Hemsley for the role of George and he wasn't available at the time so they brought in Mel Stewart to play his brother for a few episodes until Sherman Hemsley became available. It was strange that his brother Henry was never seen or mentioned again even on The Jeffersons.

Hemsley was on local radio in Philly the other day and this was talked about. Maybe rycki heard that.

anyway to add to the list. the daughter on 'Till Death was played by several actors even from one ep to the next and it became a running bit on the show that was noticed by one character and no one believed him.

NORML54601 03-21-12 12:10 AM

Re: characters played by more than one actor?
 
Meg on Family Guy

Giantrobo 03-21-12 12:27 AM

Re: characters played by more than one actor?
 

Originally Posted by rycki1138 (Post 11159820)
Actually George Jefferson was only played by Sherman Hemsley. They did have another actor, Mel Stewart, on All in the Family when the Jeffersons first moved in, but he played Henry Jefferson, George's brother. The producers wanted Sherman Hemsley for the role of George and he wasn't available at the time so they brought in Mel Stewart to play his brother for a few episodes until Sherman Hemsley became available. It was strange that his brother Henry was never seen or mentioned again even on The Jeffersons.

God dammit!!!!

You couldn't bump some other thread just to prove someone wrong?!?!

FUCK!!!

NORML54601 03-21-12 12:33 AM

Re: characters played by more than one actor?
 
I hope you've called off the hitman coming for me and sent him/her after the noob!

Lone Wolf 03-21-12 07:38 AM

Re: characters played by more than one actor?
 
Jackie's mom on That 70s Show. She was in one episode early in the series where she was a real estate agent and the gang had a party in one of her empty houses. Later in the series she was played by Brooke Shields.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:44 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.