the most manipulative show on tv is?
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Limited Edition
the most manipulative show on tv is?
My vote is:
I want to say that Flipped on MTV is the single most manipulative
P.C. crap I have ever seen.
It is so santimonous and heavy-handed way in trying to "educate" viewers towards a certain way of thinking.
Look, see what happens when we turn a stuck-up popular girl into a fat girl. She has to learn her lesson that overweight people are just like other people. Let's get her into a fat suit and have people make fun of her.
See what happens when we give a promiscious girl, STD ...
omigod, she has STDs. Now, she's learned her lesson and will enter a convent.
See what happens when we make the bully into the class nerd and have students rag on him.
See what happens when we convert people with behaviors we do not like i.e. gambling, sex, homophobia, ageism, sexism, etc.
I am not condoning these behaviors or beliefs but I am saying the way the show goes about try to presuade the viewer towards a certain way of thinking is so heavy-handed.
I am tired on this show. It's on all the time ...
Give me more of anything else.
-----
others shows which I don't watch are
7th Heaven
Smallville
Survivor
I want to say that Flipped on MTV is the single most manipulative
P.C. crap I have ever seen.
It is so santimonous and heavy-handed way in trying to "educate" viewers towards a certain way of thinking.
Look, see what happens when we turn a stuck-up popular girl into a fat girl. She has to learn her lesson that overweight people are just like other people. Let's get her into a fat suit and have people make fun of her.
See what happens when we give a promiscious girl, STD ...
omigod, she has STDs. Now, she's learned her lesson and will enter a convent.
See what happens when we make the bully into the class nerd and have students rag on him.
See what happens when we convert people with behaviors we do not like i.e. gambling, sex, homophobia, ageism, sexism, etc.
I am not condoning these behaviors or beliefs but I am saying the way the show goes about try to presuade the viewer towards a certain way of thinking is so heavy-handed.
I am tired on this show. It's on all the time ...
Give me more of anything else.
-----
others shows which I don't watch are
7th Heaven
Smallville
Survivor
Last edited by chowderhead; 03-06-02 at 02:16 AM.
#2
DVD Talk Godfather
Joined: Apr 1999
Posts: 65,305
Received 2,704 Likes
on
1,602 Posts
From: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
MTV's REAL WORLD
they keep shoving the whole GAY thing down our throats....It's like "ALRIGHT ALREADY! I GIVE!" Just do the show! No one gives a rip about what the resident gay guy is sucking on in his room......
With that said, I'll be glad when they finally do an ALL GAY REAL WORLD and get it out of their systems.
they keep shoving the whole GAY thing down our throats....It's like "ALRIGHT ALREADY! I GIVE!" Just do the show! No one gives a rip about what the resident gay guy is sucking on in his room......
With that said, I'll be glad when they finally do an ALL GAY REAL WORLD and get it out of their systems.
#4
DVD Talk God
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 133,156
Received 897 Likes
on
741 Posts
From: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
I have to go with West Wing. I love the West Wing even though I disagree with most of the politics involved. Sorkin tries to get the other side of argument in but it is pretty liberal. He has to be careful about this.
#5
Originally posted by Red Dog
I have to go with West Wing. I love the West Wing even though I disagree with most of the politics involved. Sorkin tries to get the other side of argument in but it is pretty liberal. He has to be careful about this.
I have to go with West Wing. I love the West Wing even though I disagree with most of the politics involved. Sorkin tries to get the other side of argument in but it is pretty liberal. He has to be careful about this.
It's about a Democratic presidency, so naturally, everything is skewed through the views of Democratic characters. Frankly, I'm impressed that a show starring so many rabid liberals about a bunch of elected liberals can stay as balanced as it does.das
#6
DVD Talk God
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 133,156
Received 897 Likes
on
741 Posts
From: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
Originally posted by das Monkey
It's not called The West Wing and Their Equally Valid Opponents.
It's about a Democratic presidency, so naturally, everything is skewed through the views of Democratic characters. Frankly, I'm impressed that a show starring so many rabid liberals about a bunch of elected liberals can stay as balanced as it does.
das
It's not called The West Wing and Their Equally Valid Opponents.
It's about a Democratic presidency, so naturally, everything is skewed through the views of Democratic characters. Frankly, I'm impressed that a show starring so many rabid liberals about a bunch of elected liberals can stay as balanced as it does.das
I'm not criticizing it. I understand the way it has to be written. The thread was about most manipulative show. I suspect that a lot of people's only understanding of the workings of gov't & politics come from this show. That is why I think it is manipulative.
#7
Originally posted by Red Dog
I'm not criticizing it. I understand the way it has to be written. The thread was about most manipulative show. I suspect that a lot of people's only understanding of the workings of gov't & politics come from this show. That is why I think it is manipulative.
I'm not criticizing it. I understand the way it has to be written. The thread was about most manipulative show. I suspect that a lot of people's only understanding of the workings of gov't & politics come from this show. That is why I think it is manipulative.
das
#8
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 3,826
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Phoenix, AZ
I have to go with 7th Heaven. I used to watch this show faithfully from the beginning up until about January when I finally got sick of it. I am so tired of that family's holier (sp?) than thou act. THey have covered pretty much every PC cliche out there. Racism, pregnancy, alcoholism, drugs, cursing, gangs, the elderly, veterans, sexual harrasment, teen sex, even Rock N' Roll. And they seem to have the answers for everything. They can't just end an episode with a negative note. Maybe once in awhile it happens but they solve the problem by the next episode. What really bothers me is that they have never said what religion they are. But they have had people from other religions on the show, sometimes all in one episode. I think this sow has run it course and needs to end after this season.
#9
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally posted by adamblast
You want sanctimonious, heavy-handed moralism?
How about Seventh Heaven or Touched By An Angel?
You want sanctimonious, heavy-handed moralism?
How about Seventh Heaven or Touched By An Angel?
I for one wonder how MTV finds people for their "reality" shows. They always find an angry African American, a homosexual, a homecoming princess, a jock, a rich guy, and a racist to live together hoping that will make for good viewing.
#10
Originally posted by Giantrobo
MTV's REAL WORLD
they keep shoving the whole GAY thing down our throats....It's like "ALRIGHT ALREADY! I GIVE!" Just do the show! No one gives a rip about what the resident gay guy is sucking on in his room......
With that said, I'll be glad when they finally do an ALL GAY REAL WORLD and get it out of their systems.
MTV's REAL WORLD
they keep shoving the whole GAY thing down our throats....It's like "ALRIGHT ALREADY! I GIVE!" Just do the show! No one gives a rip about what the resident gay guy is sucking on in his room......
With that said, I'll be glad when they finally do an ALL GAY REAL WORLD and get it out of their systems.
#11
Suspended
Joined: Jun 1999
Posts: 15,108
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Giantrobo
MTV's REAL WORLD
they keep shoving the whole GAY thing down our throats....It's like "ALRIGHT ALREADY! I GIVE!" Just do the show! No one gives a rip about what the resident gay guy is sucking on in his room......
With that said, I'll be glad when they finally do an ALL GAY REAL WORLD and get it out of their systems.
MTV's REAL WORLD
they keep shoving the whole GAY thing down our throats....It's like "ALRIGHT ALREADY! I GIVE!" Just do the show! No one gives a rip about what the resident gay guy is sucking on in his room......
With that said, I'll be glad when they finally do an ALL GAY REAL WORLD and get it out of their systems.
#12
Member
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 241
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Satellite of Luv
Originally posted by WWF Jedi
I have to go with 7th Heaven. THey have covered pretty much every PC cliche out there. Racism, pregnancy, alcoholism, drugs, cursing, gangs, the elderly, veterans, sexual harrasment, teen sex, even Rock N' Roll. And they seem to have the answers for everything. They can't just end an episode with a negative note. Maybe once in awhile it happens but they solve the problem by the next episode.
I have to go with 7th Heaven. THey have covered pretty much every PC cliche out there. Racism, pregnancy, alcoholism, drugs, cursing, gangs, the elderly, veterans, sexual harrasment, teen sex, even Rock N' Roll. And they seem to have the answers for everything. They can't just end an episode with a negative note. Maybe once in awhile it happens but they solve the problem by the next episode.
"This is my happening, and it freaks me out!"
#13
Senior Member
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 553
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Rarezona
I think TV itself is most manipulative.
Every show is trying to get you to view.
Then there are the commercials....
Cable or Dish....
Lets not forget about HDTV....Big screen tv's and
awesome sound systems.....Did I mention Tivo.
Yeah I think it manipulates us all.
Now time to go watch some.
Every show is trying to get you to view.
Then there are the commercials....
Cable or Dish....
Lets not forget about HDTV....Big screen tv's and
awesome sound systems.....Did I mention Tivo.
Yeah I think it manipulates us all.
Now time to go watch some.
#15
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 3,826
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Phoenix, AZ
Originally posted by littlefuzzy
... also, don't forget Rosie.
... also, don't forget Rosie.




