Band of Brothers ep. #9 [spoilers]
#1
Moderator
Thread Starter
Band of Brothers ep. #9 [spoilers]
What a powerful episode. Not a whole lot to say about this one as I was pretty much left speechless. A nice touch, I thought, was to have the episode begin and end with the man playing that sad melody on the violin. It fit in very well.
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Downers Grove, IL
Posts: 10,470
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Blaster1
how did they get those people to look so skinny and dead like that?
how did they get those people to look so skinny and dead like that?
#4
Admin Emeritus
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Texas, our Texas! All hail the mighty state!
Posts: 12,842
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Looks like Nix's fondness for the bottle has crossed over into addiction, possibly. You can see how his character has changed since the first episodes... smug, wise-cracking Nix in the first episodes vs. jaded, rarely-cracking-a-smile Nix in this one.
Fire bad!
Fire bad!
#5
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by Blaster1
how did they get those people to look so skinny and dead like that?
how did they get those people to look so skinny and dead like that?
Very powerful episode. I was glad to see Capt. Nixon in the show for more than a few minutes.
I can't imagine how shocking and disturbing it would have been for all the soldiers who found the camps.
It's a shame the series is almost over, it's just about the only thing worthwhile on TV these days. I Can't wait for the DVDs to be released...hopefully they'll include the documentary "Standing Alone Together" (I think that's what it's called)
#6
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Downers Grove, IL
Posts: 10,470
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by GoldenJCJ
I Can't wait for the DVDs to be released
I Can't wait for the DVDs to be released
#7
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'll be glad when the series comes out on DVD.
1. My lame cable company doesn't offer DD. The battle sequences will have a lot more impact once I get my grubby paws on the discs.
2. Having to wait a whole week for the next episode was too long. It really broke up the pace for me. It was like reading a chapter in a book and having to wait a whole week to go to the next one.
3.There were a lot of excellent scenes I'd like to see again and again (like SPR). Plus it'll be interesting to watch all the characters from the beginining now that I'm familiar with a lot of them.
*Pvt. Webster venting his frustration was great, esp. when he pulled out his .45 and the baker denied being a Nazi. German citizens being forced to "clean up" the camps was a good move on the part of CINC. Whether or not they learned from it I don't know but they "consented" to it and it was a fitting though inadequate punishment. I believe most Germans (like most Japanese) were very much for their Gov't and their methods. Many are still only sorry they lost to us. Ha. Ha.
1. My lame cable company doesn't offer DD. The battle sequences will have a lot more impact once I get my grubby paws on the discs.
2. Having to wait a whole week for the next episode was too long. It really broke up the pace for me. It was like reading a chapter in a book and having to wait a whole week to go to the next one.
3.There were a lot of excellent scenes I'd like to see again and again (like SPR). Plus it'll be interesting to watch all the characters from the beginining now that I'm familiar with a lot of them.
*Pvt. Webster venting his frustration was great, esp. when he pulled out his .45 and the baker denied being a Nazi. German citizens being forced to "clean up" the camps was a good move on the part of CINC. Whether or not they learned from it I don't know but they "consented" to it and it was a fitting though inadequate punishment. I believe most Germans (like most Japanese) were very much for their Gov't and their methods. Many are still only sorry they lost to us. Ha. Ha.
Last edited by Ian11; 10-29-01 at 12:41 AM.
#8
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by huzefa
See, I don't get that. In my opinion, this show does not have too much replay value. I'm glad it's on TV, and that I'm watching it, but I don't think I'd ever watch it again and again. I have too many DVDs I don't watch again and again including Sopranos season 1 boxset, which I've only ever seen once. I guess, what I'm trying to say is, there better be some amazing extras on the DVD for me to buy it.
See, I don't get that. In my opinion, this show does not have too much replay value. I'm glad it's on TV, and that I'm watching it, but I don't think I'd ever watch it again and again. I have too many DVDs I don't watch again and again including Sopranos season 1 boxset, which I've only ever seen once. I guess, what I'm trying to say is, there better be some amazing extras on the DVD for me to buy it.
I don't own the Sopranos boxset for the exact reasons you mentioned above. Come to think of it, I don't own any season boxsets for those same reasons, but Band of Brothers seems like I could get a better understanding of this tiny part of WWII each and every time I rewatch it.
Either way, I have a lot of DVDs I want ahead of this so it'll be a while before I pick it up anyway, and by then I will have forgotten much of it, so I'll watch it over again for the first time.
[Edited to add] while I was typing Ian11 posted some of my same points for wanting the DVD set...So now it'll seem a lot less sincere when you read my post
Last edited by GoldenJCJ; 10-29-01 at 01:02 AM.
#9
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Zürich, Switzerland
Posts: 5,278
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Wow...what an episode..it had to be absolutely crazy to find one of the prisoner/concentration camps as a soldier, especially if you didn't know about them. As I was watching I was thinking to myself that it was a concentration camp and why couldn't they figure it out...then I realized that I have the benefit of history and these guys are seeing it for the first time, wow!!
I would buy this on DVD in a heartbeat...I love history and this was very well done. I have enough stupid movies on DVD that this would be a nice break from time to time on a cold nasty saturday..
The scene at the end when Nix sees that lady whose son was a Nazi general cleaning up the bodies is so perfect. The woman saw what her son was truely about.
I would buy this on DVD in a heartbeat...I love history and this was very well done. I have enough stupid movies on DVD that this would be a nice break from time to time on a cold nasty saturday..
The scene at the end when Nix sees that lady whose son was a Nazi general cleaning up the bodies is so perfect. The woman saw what her son was truely about.
#10
CineSchlock-O-Rama
Join Date: Aug 1999
Location: Dallas
Posts: 2,828
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Cheddarmuff
The scene at the end when Nix sees that lady whose son was a Nazi general cleaning up the bodies is so perfect. The woman saw what her son was truely about.
The scene at the end when Nix sees that lady whose son was a Nazi general cleaning up the bodies is so perfect. The woman saw what her son was truely about.
It was powerful, but there was some instability to this episode. Why is Nix suddenly off the deep end? He didn't know about his wife. Maybe we're supposed to believe it's over his not seeing combat? Why was he demoted? We just sort of leap from him being a social drinker to a raging alchie. I guess it works like that in real life, but it threw me anyway. Also, why'd he go back to the camp at the end? He's blazing through the woods in the jeep ... rushing to get to the camp?! What, so he could just happen upon the old broad?
Why's Mr. Ivy Leage suddenly flipping out and yammering about horse-drawn wagons? He's shouting at the Germans like a mad man. That was weird. Nothing about his character really indicated he'd do that. Again, the "madness of war" rationalization could come into play.
Wow, I'm picking nits here, eh? It was such a fantastic episode that I guess this question marks that formed over my head bugged me more than they normally would. Can't wait for the DVDs!
#11
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Nov 1999
Posts: 2,022
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You know, it's one thing to view the Holocaust through archival footage or Schindler's List in black and white, but it's uttetly alien to see it in full colour.
I'm also glad to see the series showing "our boys" in a not so gentlemanly fashion.
Only one episode left...
I'm also glad to see the series showing "our boys" in a not so gentlemanly fashion.
Only one episode left...
#12
DVD Talk Legend
I really liked this episode, because I think most of us forget that during WWII we really didn't what was going on by the Nazis. I thought it was great how the one guy laughed about the simplistic "Germans are bad" statement but then later they really saw the full extent of what was happening. We all have the hindsight now of the Holocaust, butthese soldiers who were fighting and risking/losing their lives had no idea what evil they were truly battling until this point.
I think it was great how the episode first painted their disenchantment with the war: "what has this all been for?" "why are we fighting?" to them discovering the camp and finding out.
I also got tears in my eyes when that one old concentration camp victim hugged the soldier that freed him.
I was also cheering when they made the well-dreesed and well-fed German townspeople bury the bodies. It was justice, to make them absolutely aware of what the true cost of their comfort and silence was.
The only thing that was jarring was the disparity between the dead bodies and the live victims. In real life, the victims looked much worse than the skinny actors and more likethe dead skeletons they showed. There was no real way to correct this without making totally CGI humans, but it was the only thing that prevented me from really believing the moment. Everything else about this show has seemed so real, and that wa sthe one moment that reminded me I was watching a TV show.
I think it was great how the episode first painted their disenchantment with the war: "what has this all been for?" "why are we fighting?" to them discovering the camp and finding out.
I also got tears in my eyes when that one old concentration camp victim hugged the soldier that freed him.
I was also cheering when they made the well-dreesed and well-fed German townspeople bury the bodies. It was justice, to make them absolutely aware of what the true cost of their comfort and silence was.
The only thing that was jarring was the disparity between the dead bodies and the live victims. In real life, the victims looked much worse than the skinny actors and more likethe dead skeletons they showed. There was no real way to correct this without making totally CGI humans, but it was the only thing that prevented me from really believing the moment. Everything else about this show has seemed so real, and that wa sthe one moment that reminded me I was watching a TV show.
Last edited by Jadzia; 10-29-01 at 12:30 PM.
#13
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Nov 1999
Posts: 2,022
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Jadzia
I was also cheering when they made the well-dreesed and well-fed German townspeople bury the bodies. It was justice, to make them absolutely aware of what the true cost of their comfort and silence was.
I was also cheering when they made the well-dreesed and well-fed German townspeople bury the bodies. It was justice, to make them absolutely aware of what the true cost of their comfort and silence was.
I completely agree with showing the German people what their government had done, I can understand why they would be forced to bury the dead, but I couldn't take pleasure in watching them.
#14
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by Jadzia
The only thing that was jarring was the disparity between the dead bodies and the live victims. In real life, the victims looked much worse than the skinny actors and more likethe dead skeletons they showed. There was no real way to correct this without making totally CGI humans, but it was the only thing that prevented me from really believing the moment. Everything else about this show has seemed so real, and that wa sthe one moment that reminded me I was watching a TV show.
The only thing that was jarring was the disparity between the dead bodies and the live victims. In real life, the victims looked much worse than the skinny actors and more likethe dead skeletons they showed. There was no real way to correct this without making totally CGI humans, but it was the only thing that prevented me from really believing the moment. Everything else about this show has seemed so real, and that wa sthe one moment that reminded me I was watching a TV show.
das
#15
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by G. Noel Gross
It was powerful, but there was some instability to this episode. Why is Nix suddenly off the deep end? He didn't know about his wife. Maybe we're supposed to believe it's over his not seeing combat? Why was he demoted? We just sort of leap from him being a social drinker to a raging alchie.
It was powerful, but there was some instability to this episode. Why is Nix suddenly off the deep end? He didn't know about his wife. Maybe we're supposed to believe it's over his not seeing combat? Why was he demoted? We just sort of leap from him being a social drinker to a raging alchie.
Why's Mr. Ivy Leage suddenly flipping out and yammering about horse-drawn wagons? He's shouting at the Germans like a mad man. That was weird. Nothing about his character really indicated he'd do that. Again, the "madness of war" rationalization could come into play.
das
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Tesiae
Sorry, but I don't see anything to cheer about here. Though, I don't believe that the German people living near the concentration camps knew nothing about them, I don't think there was much they could do to stop it. Were they supposed to go to their nearest armed goose stepper and ask them to desist murdering Jews? Nazi Germany was not a good place to voice your concerns about human rights.
I completely agree with showing the German people what their government had done, I can understand why they would be forced to bury the dead, but I couldn't take pleasure in watching them.
Sorry, but I don't see anything to cheer about here. Though, I don't believe that the German people living near the concentration camps knew nothing about them, I don't think there was much they could do to stop it. Were they supposed to go to their nearest armed goose stepper and ask them to desist murdering Jews? Nazi Germany was not a good place to voice your concerns about human rights.
I completely agree with showing the German people what their government had done, I can understand why they would be forced to bury the dead, but I couldn't take pleasure in watching them.
These people just were in denial. They knew what was going on, but they just didn't want to even acknowledge it.
If they said they knew, but were afraid to speak up that would be one thing. But to deny even knowing about is the ultimate arrogance. Even if they were afraid, they had more of a voice to speak out than others did. These were respected, upper-class Germans. These townspeople had friends, relatives in the Army.
Sorry, but I found poetic justice in making these people come face to face with the stench and the hooror of these camps. Making them clean it up was only the least thing they could do, since they had "covered it up" for so long.
#17
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Nov 1999
Posts: 2,022
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Jadzia
I diasgree. Most of the neighbors of concentration camps have widely denied knowing their existence, yet the soldiers who liberated them reported the stench was obvious from miles away.
These people just were in denial. They knew what was going on, but they just didn't want to even acknowledge it.
I diasgree. Most of the neighbors of concentration camps have widely denied knowing their existence, yet the soldiers who liberated them reported the stench was obvious from miles away.
These people just were in denial. They knew what was going on, but they just didn't want to even acknowledge it.
If they said they knew, but were afraid to speak up that would be one thing. But to deny even knowing about is the ultimate arrogance. Even if they were afraid, they had more of a voice to speak out than others did. These were respected, upper-class Germans. These townspeople had friends, relatives in the Army.
Sorry, but I found poetic justice in making these people come face to face with the stench and the hooror of these camps. Making them clean it up was only the least thing they could do, since they had "covered it up" for so long.
#20
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by TruGator
i missed this episode...is there a website or something that has a summary of it?
i missed this episode...is there a website or something that has a summary of it?
www.hbo.com/band
Cheddarmuff: Unfortunatley, that happened to a lot of the young men while fighting in WWII. Sad but true.
Last edited by GoldenJCJ; 10-29-01 at 04:58 PM.
#21
Admin Emeritus
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Texas, our Texas! All hail the mighty state!
Posts: 12,842
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
I will always give this site props for the best episode recaps I've ever read...
www.mightybigtv.com
It rules!
Fire bad!
www.mightybigtv.com
It rules!
Fire bad!
#22
Admin Emeritus
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Texas, our Texas! All hail the mighty state!
Posts: 12,842
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Originally posted by Cheddarmuff
Hix's wife....what a biatch..."Hi, I know your off fighting a war, but I'm lonly and I want a divirce.." WTF!!
Hix's wife....what a biatch..."Hi, I know your off fighting a war, but I'm lonly and I want a divirce.." WTF!!
Vat 69 good! *buuuurrrrrp*
#23
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally posted by Cheddarmuff
Hix's wife....what a biatch..."Hi, I know your off fighting a war, but I'm lonly and I want a divirce.." WTF!!
Hix's wife....what a biatch..."Hi, I know your off fighting a war, but I'm lonly and I want a divirce.." WTF!!
Reminds me of In the Mood with Patrick Dempsey.
#24
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Las Vegas
Posts: 2,725
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Cheddarmuff
Hix's wife....what a biatch..."Hi, I know your off fighting a war, but I'm lonly and I want a divorce.." WTF!!
Hix's wife....what a biatch..."Hi, I know your off fighting a war, but I'm lonly and I want a divorce.." WTF!!
I don't really know enough about it to go into how he or she felt and all, but suffice it to say, that it's more than believable.
#25
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by GoldenJCJ
Unfortunatley, that happened to a lot of the young men while fighting in WWII. Sad but true.
Unfortunatley, that happened to a lot of the young men while fighting in WWII. Sad but true.
While he was gone, he heard that she was cheating on him around town and such, so when he got back he promptly divorced her.
The weird, sad thing is that they had a daughter, which to this day my dad does not acknowledge. I think he wonders if she is his or not.
But what's weird about it, is I have this older half-sister whom I have never met.