Just like with the Tim Burton thread my wife and I watched or rewatched through all of Shymalan's films. I had seem them all previously through The Happening so not the last 5. Interested to see what other's opinions are.

***** out of *****
1. The Sixth Sense (one of my favorite films of all time and contains one of the best scenes I've ever seen in a movie)

****1/2 out of *****
2. The Village
3. Unbreakable

**** out of *****
4. Signs

***1/2 out of *****
5. Lady in the Water
6. After Earth

*** out of *****
7. Split
8. Glass

**1/2 out of *****
9. The Visit

** out of *****
10. The Happening
11. Wide Awake
12. The Last Airbender

1. Signs
2. The Sixth Sense
3. Unbreakable
4. Split
5. The Visit
6. The Village
7. The Happening
8. The Last Airbender
9. Lady in the Water
10. After Earth
11. Glass

Sixth Sense
Signs
Split
The Visit
Unbreakable
The Village



The Lady in the Water
The Happening

Never saw:
Last Airbender
Glass
After Earth

Unbreakable
Signs
6th Sense
Village
Lady in the Water
Split
The Visit

Never saw Happening, After Earth, or Last Airbender

I like the one with the twist at the end.

Unbreakable

there are no other films

Unbreakable
Sixth Sense
Split
Glass
Signs
The Visit
Lady in the Water
The Village


Never saw Last Airbender, After Earth, or The Happening.

Now that’s a twist I didn’t see coming!

For someone who is considered by the public as a twist director my top four of his films are infinitely rewatchable. I've seen all 4 probably close to ten times each.

This is where I'm at too. It may be an unpopular opinion, but Unbreakable is the only one of his films I have any interest in revisiting.

I think The Sixth Sense, Signs, and Unbreakable are easily his best and really the only ones with any replay value.

I recently re-watched Signs after reading about the theory that the aliens are actually demons and it plays a lot better, IMO. To me, demons make a lot more sense and the theory fits nicely throughout the movie.

1. The Sixth Sense
2. Unbreakable
3. Split
4. Signs

I haven't seen After Earth, Last Airbender and that Rosie O Donnell one.

The rest are unranked.

1) Unbreakable
2) Signs
3) Lady In The Water
4) Glass
5) Split
6) The Visit
7) The Village
8) The Sixth Sense
9) After Earth
10) The Last Airbender

i think I would have liked the Sixth Sense more when it came out but I was in Elementary school and by the time i was allowed to see it everyone had already spoiled it for me so it was no big deal.

1. Signs
2. Unbreakable
3. The Sixth Sense
4. Split
5. The Village
6. The Visit
7. The Happening
9. Glass
8. Lady in the Water

1) Sixth Sense
2) The Village
3) Unbreakable
4)The Visit
5) Signs
6) Split
7) The Happening
8) Lady in the Water

I haven't seen any others that I can remember. Only 1-4 were decent. The rest were barely watchable, especially 7 and 8. 1, 2 and maybe 3 were very good; 4 was ok. 5 was below average but made some sense. 6 and 7 seemed to have no point to it at all and no real surprise ending. Lady in the Water just seemed like a bunch of stupid scenes splice together that overall mage no sense whatsoever and left most people just scratching their heads all the way through trying to figure out what was going on.

Signs is good until the finale act. Dumb fuck aliens that invade Earth but fail to realize that 2/3rds of the planet is water, which is their only weakness? Yeah, I've read the the demon and religious angle, which is fine and I can see it, but the fact that the aliens are adverse to water still makes no sense.

1. The Sixth Sense
2. Unbreakable
3. Signs
4. Split
5. The VIllage
6. Glass
7. The Happening
8. After Earth (though it's not his fault)

The water complaints are bizarre to me. Aliens are imaginary maybe they don't have water on their planet and they didn't know water was their weakness?

Also when people make up theories about movies that are obviously not what the movie is meant to be is bizarre also.

The Sixth Sense
Signs
Split
The Visit
Unbreakable
Glass
The Lady in the Water
The Happening
The Village

Haven't seen:
Wide Awake
Last Airbender
After Earth

I'm really not much of a fan. The Sixth Sense was great at the time, but it hasn't aged well. I really expected that he would have done a lot more. I think he got too into his own mind, like he felt he was required to deliver the twist, which makes some of his movies feel really labored.

The Sixth Sense
Signs
Unbreakable
The Village
Glass
Split
The Visit
Lady in the Water (Watched this once, with no desire to watch it again)
The Happening (This was one of the worst movies I've ever seen and Wahlberg's acting was comical)

After Earth & The Last Airbender I've never seen & don't plan to
Wide Awake I've never heard of

1. The Sixth Sense / Unbreakable
2. Signs / Lady in the water (I really enjoyed this one).
3. The Village
4. Split
5. Glass

Didn't like any of the others ones.

Wow, you have the sixth sense and the village at the top of your list and split and glass almost at the bottom. Tastes definitely vary!

Out of the movies I've seen. Gigantic cliff drop-off after Sixth Sense.

1. Signs
2. Split
3. Unbreakable
4. The Sixth Sense
5. Lady in the Water
6. The Village
7. The Happening
8. The Last Airbender
9. Glass

No, it's just bad and lazy writing. Aliens who have mastered interplanetary travel? They could have done a scan of Earth, hell, they can see the water on surface, etc. This is why the first three quarters of the film play so well, but once the final act hits, it's garbage.

The Village is his best flick.
Followed by The Sixth Sense, Unbreakable, and Split. Signs was good too. All of his movies have very interesting moments and ideas. The execution is what's inconsistent. Glass upon rewatch, is getting better and better. Still a disappointment, but if you watch it without any knowledge of the Unbreakable universe, it's a very intriguing film.
The Village will be his The Birds 20 years from now.