I stole this idea from Pdinosaur.

The subject explains the topic.

I'll start with Kathleen Turner in VI Warchowsky and Milla Jovivich in any of the action movies shes done.
and

Richard Dreyfuss in Stakeout.

D

Not exactly an action movie, but there's an action scene in Cool As Ice where Vanilla Ice kicks the crap out of a bunch of tough guys, I think they were bikers. It was completely ridiculous.

I actually liked Richard Dreyfus in Stakeout as his performance was naturally funny. Believe it or not, he was actaully considered before for Total Recall as the original story was about a normal, boring looking guy and not some musclehead like Arnold.

For unbelievability, I choose Ben Affleck in both Daredevil and Sum of All Fears.

Julia Roberts as an attorney in the Pelican Brief.

I liked Ben in Sum of All Fears but I had trouble believing Nick Cage in Con Air even though I like the movie.

Cindy Crawford in Fair Game

Stakeout is an action movie?

I had no problem with Richard Dreyfuss in the action scenes in Stakeout. My complaint in that movie(despite the fact that I really like that flick) is that I never bought Madeline Stowe falling for him. Give me a break!

Keanu Reeves in Johnny Mnemonic.

I mean, c'mon, casting Keanu as someone with too much information in their head?

(1) Anna Nicole Smith in Skyscraper - very unconvincing with a gun in her hand. She fails to make her character convincing in this sub Die Hard ripoff.

(2) Rochelle Swanson in Cyber Tracker - same reason.

Matthew Broderick in "Godzilla"...i win!

I would say Keanu in anything short of Bill and Ted.

Are we talking least believable because of role or acting ability?

I'd pick Sharon Stone in the Quick and the Dead. A fun, quirky western with a great cast, marred by a terrible lead performance. Back in the day when Russell Crowe and Leo DiCaprio would play second banana to someone like Stone.

Pick a Bond girl...Who's an agent, at that.

Bridget Fonda in POINT OF NO RETURN. Her gun weighed more than she did!

Kurt Thomas in GYMKATA. Nuff said!

Sandra Bullock in Speed.

She cant act in any genre ... but action movies too ?

Chris Rock in any action movie.

He weighs less than Bridget Fonda ....

Clooney as Batman

Denise Richards as a nuclear physicist in whichever Bond movie she was in. Woof.

Kim Basinger in that movie about the cell phone and how she was held hostage. I think it was called Cellular. Franky I don't see how she won an Oscar for LA Confidential either.

Most recent:Loved the overall movie, but Natalie Portman in ROTS was a bit painful Thought her delivery was much better in ATOTC

This isn't about bad acting. It's more about seeing someone on screen kicking ass and thinking 'There's just no way'.

For example, I don't care if Drew Barrymore was a 3rd degree blackbelt and had her own karate school, i will never believe should could do a roundhouse kick.

D

Agree. Keanu was the first name that came to my mind.

Cutesy, cuddly, chubby, pudgy, mollycuddled, out-of-shape little menzipoo Ice Cube in anything action but most notably - and ridiculously - in Ghosts of Mars - where he was supposedly the worst badass on the renegade planet - and xXx: State of the Union - where he had to fill Vin Diesel's jockstrap: The man should be escorted by bodyguards every time he steps out of his barbershop... or an anaconda's dinner plate.


Jes' coz' you can scowl the scowl doesn't mean you can prowl the prowl, bro'.

Matt Damon as Jason Bourne.