I spit on your grave, is the rape graphic?
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
I spit on your grave, is the rape graphic?
I decided to buy the movie 100% blind, and all i know is that a woman, after being raped, goes on revenge and kills her attackers. (i was buying 2 things from dvdempire.com's 2 for 15 on mgm titles and needed a 3rd title for free shipping.) I thought the rape in clockwork orange sickening and deplorable, but the rape in Ichi the Killer, i didn't find disturbing. (many reviewers have said the rapes in that movie is worse then irreversable, which i haven't seen)
#3
Banned
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 3,220
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
this movie is genius if you ask me...but Im probably in the minority...the rape lasts for 25min. and is quite graphic and the actress has a scream that sent a chill down my spine...again if you can stomach I find it very satisfactory movie...
#4
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 9,917
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
From: Sitting on a beach, earning 20%
Originally posted by QuiGonJosh
this movie is genius if you ask me...
this movie is genius if you ask me...
#6
DVD Talk Hero
Yes, it's very long, and it's hard to watch but it's not "graphic" in the sense that Rypro525 mentionned, you don't see any penetration (it's the 70's after all). The length and real time feel is what makes that scene disturbing. She gets raped in 3 different locations, i.e. they rape her, they let her run away, play cat and mouse, catch her, rape her again, etc...
Of course the best thing about that DVD is the Joe Bob Briggs commentary. Absolutely hilarious. But even Joe Bob mumbles and runs out of stuff to say during the rape scene.
Of course the best thing about that DVD is the Joe Bob Briggs commentary. Absolutely hilarious. But even Joe Bob mumbles and runs out of stuff to say during the rape scene.
#7
Just to clear things up on the rape...
It's not 25 straight minutes of rape (That would be a bit too much to handle) Instead there's a lengthy "break" between each rapist who attacks her. But being pulled back into the rape once you think it's over makes the sequence much stronger and difficult, IMO.
Nope. None of that is shown.
And don't forget to check out the Joe Bob commentary!
It's not 25 straight minutes of rape (That would be a bit too much to handle) Instead there's a lengthy "break" between each rapist who attacks her. But being pulled back into the rape once you think it's over makes the sequence much stronger and difficult, IMO.
and in my mind, the term "graphic" means penetration, and the works.
And don't forget to check out the Joe Bob commentary!
#8
DVD Talk Hero
There is nudity but no hardcore footage in the rape scenes. (I don't think that such a thing could even be legally shown in the US these days).
#9
Moderator
Originally posted by cultshock
There is nudity but no hardcore footage in the rape scenes. (I don't think that such a thing could even be legally shown in the US these days).
There is nudity but no hardcore footage in the rape scenes. (I don't think that such a thing could even be legally shown in the US these days).
#12
Suspended; also need updated email
Originally posted by eXcentris
(it's the 70's after all).
(it's the 70's after all).
#13
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 536
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Ga
The second rape is mildly funny only in that it looks so fake. Although Camille does scream convincingly, the way this guy thrusts and jerks around like he's going into a seizure made me laugh. It made me realize it was only a movie, which was needed at that point.
I actually felt bad when she killed the retarded guy, because it really seemed like he didn't know what he was doing. Still, after what she goes through, I guess all of them were equally at fault in her mind.
I agree with everyone who said to get the Millenium Edition with the Joe Bob commentary. The director's commentary is also mildly entertaining because Meir Zarchi has a really strong French accent and seems to be reading his commentary from a script. He does try to explain his reasons for making the film, and after hearing his story I didn't see the film as the cheap exploitation flick I had thought it was. Sure, it's excessively violent, but so it's not like the idiots rape her and get away with it. The only difference in this film and, say, The Accused, is that the victim gets her own revenge instead of relying on the often corrupt justice system.
I actually felt bad when she killed the retarded guy, because it really seemed like he didn't know what he was doing. Still, after what she goes through, I guess all of them were equally at fault in her mind.
I agree with everyone who said to get the Millenium Edition with the Joe Bob commentary. The director's commentary is also mildly entertaining because Meir Zarchi has a really strong French accent and seems to be reading his commentary from a script. He does try to explain his reasons for making the film, and after hearing his story I didn't see the film as the cheap exploitation flick I had thought it was. Sure, it's excessively violent, but so it's not like the idiots rape her and get away with it. The only difference in this film and, say, The Accused, is that the victim gets her own revenge instead of relying on the often corrupt justice system.
#14
DVD Talk Hero
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by cultshock
There is nudity but no hardcore footage in the rape scenes. (I don't think that such a thing could even be legally shown in the US these days).
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh, I'm surely familiar with porn. 
I meant that it it would be very unlikely for hardcore porn to have a brutal rape theme these days in the US, as there would be a risk of prosecution.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by cultshock
There is nudity but no hardcore footage in the rape scenes. (I don't think that such a thing could even be legally shown in the US these days).
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
uh, it's called porn.

I meant that it it would be very unlikely for hardcore porn to have a brutal rape theme these days in the US, as there would be a risk of prosecution.
#15
DVD Talk Hero
The ONLY XXX Roughies were made in the 70s ! Actually i think most of the vilest films ever made came out on the 70s. The 80s just brought censorship
You won't see those kind of films made these days.
#17
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by Rypro 525
#18
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by cultshock
I meant that it it would be very unlikely for hardcore porn to have a brutal rape theme these days in the US, as there would be a risk of prosecution.
I meant that it it would be very unlikely for hardcore porn to have a brutal rape theme these days in the US, as there would be a risk of prosecution.
#19
DVD Talk Hero
its not consitered porn but Baise-moi, contained hc footage, and rape (and it was released in the past 5 years) oh and i haven't seen that one.

(but seriously, the fact that it wasn't an actual porn film, produced for the sole purpose of sexual stimulation, might have something to do with it)
#20
Originally posted by bodomnet:
It's quite graphic, though being a guy you will probably find the penis chopping scene more disturbing.
Originally posted by Rypro 525 :
It's quite graphic, though being a guy you will probably find the penis chopping scene more disturbing.
Originally posted by Rypro 525 :
#21
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by gnradd21
I actually felt bad when she killed the retarded guy, because it really seemed like he didn't know what he was doing. Still, after what she goes through, I guess all of them were equally at fault in her mind.
I actually felt bad when she killed the retarded guy, because it really seemed like he didn't know what he was doing. Still, after what she goes through, I guess all of them were equally at fault in her mind.
As everyone has pointed out, this is definitely no porno. There is rampant nudity (Keaton spends most of movie completely nude), but the sex is simulated. I don't even remember there being any male full-frontal, although there's plenty of side and rear thrusting.
Ebert (and the deceased Siskel) often called this the worst film ever made, which I don't understand. I don't care for the film because I find it underwhelming as a supposedly disturbing psychodrama, but I've seen much, much worse. The quality of the filmmaking is at least competent, and I disagree with the accusation of misogyny: The men are all one-dimensionally horny and cretinous; the woman is an intelligent writer who is triumphant at the end. If anything it's a feminist parable.
Last edited by Norm de Plume; 03-11-04 at 12:06 AM.
#23
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 1,886
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Up State NY
Originally posted by DonnachaOne
Bear in mind, this person did like Star Wars: the Phantom Menace, so take the opinion with a grain of salt...
Bear in mind, this person did like Star Wars: the Phantom Menace, so take the opinion with a grain of salt...



